Specialty focus
Choosing a
good death
Doing ‘everything’ near the
end may be inappropriate
for seniors in ICU.
By Magnolia Cardona, Ebony
Lewis and Alex Psirides
N
o one wants to be a patient in
an intensive care unit. But if you
ever do require intensive care,
would you or your family like to be better
informed about the harms and benefits of
intensive treatment?
And would having better information
about what may happen during the ICU
stay and after help you make informed
decisions, especially if you are no longer in
a position to make decisions?
A recently released review of 13 medical
studies published over the past two
decades investigated just that.
The review involved 6194 older patients
or relatives from Australia, the US, Canada
and France. The researchers found that
asking people about their preferences
for intensive care was rare (1 per cent to
53.6 per cent).
Less than a third (1 per cent to
34.7 per cent) were asked about ‘goals
of treatment’ – whether they wanted
everything at all costs in the hope of
getting back to normal and how much
suffering they would endure to do so,
or whether they would want treatment
focused mostly on their comfort.
Understanding of fears or involvement in
decision-making were also low. Phrases
such as ‘dissatisfaction’ with end of life care
or ‘discordance’ with clinicians about the
benefits of ICU procedures were common.
Some patients felt that ‘too much
treatment’ causes unacceptable suffering;
or when treatments were provided despite
the likelihood of improving a patient’s
18 | nursingreview.com.au
quality of life; or if they were given to
extend life for people in a coma with little
to no chance of recovery.
Two messages were clear. Firstly, people
are aware of the concept of ‘futility’ –
providing treatment that doesn’t change
what happens to patients in either the
short or long term – even if they call it
something else.
Secondly, seniors have strong opinions
about such treatments but are not often
given the opportunity to express them.
Some of the reasons suggested for this lack
of consultation included patients’ cognitive
impairment or advanced age, doctors’
doubts about prognosis, paternalistic
attitudes towards decision-making, and
generally a difference of opinion between
health professionals and members of the
community regarding what is realistically
achievable in the ICU.
The review concluded that what was
thought to be inappropriate treatments
in ICU for families and patients were
usually based on social circumstances
and compassionate grounds, and not
necessarily confined to the medical
aspects.
Clinicians are urged to place themselves
in the patient and family’s shoes, and
involve them in reconciling these
differences of opinion. In short, by asking
patients and their loved ones what they
would want, based on the best and worst
case outcomes.
The theme of poor or insufficient
communication between clinicians and the
patient emerged repeatedly; unsurprisingly,
this is not a new challenge. Sometimes
families and patients themselves have not
been told about prognosis or impending
death, so despite the presence of frailty
and multiple chronic conditions, when
death comes, it can seem to be a sudden
and unexpected event. There is ongoing
debate about how far prognostic disclosure
should go. We believe honest, clear and
timely communication of expectations is
an ethical obligation of clinicians.
Quality end of life care encompasses
many aspects: from the technical
competencies of procedural staff to
clinicians taking time to engage with
empathy and compassion, to enabling the
death to occur at a place and time of the
patient’s (or their family’s) choosing.
Older adults with life-limiting illness
and informal bereaved caregivers of older
Australian patients have told us before
about their end of life priorities. They need
some sense of control over what happens
near the end of their life. They have made
it clear that they want to be involved in
treatment decisions made about them.
And they need clinicians to adhere to
their wishes.
A recent New Zealand study confirmed
that the personal traits and behaviours of
ICU clinical staff affected how families felt
about the care provided for their loved
ones nearing death from a critical illness.
Suggestions for improvement included
regular and sensitive communication with
families of dying patients, more contact
with physicians, and flexibility in allowing
a larger number of visitors by the bedside
towards the end.
While clinicians are trained to save lives
and cure disease, there is a point where ‘if
they can’t save their lives, they should save
their deaths’. Allowing a dignified death
rather than prolonging the dying process
could reduce unnecessary suffering as
well as avoid giving families false hope and
pathological grief.
The concept of ‘inappropriateness’, in a
system where ‘everything’ is both provided
by default, and is an expectation of both
society and medical culture, needs to be
recognised and discussed.
Treatments that do not impact on
survival time or improve quality of life
are not in seniors’ best interests, often
prevent the achievement of a ‘good’ death
and erode the sustainability of the health
system. As one family member recently
told an ICU clinician during a meeting to
talk about realistic expectations for their
loved one, “Sometimes, Doctor, there are
things worse than death.”
The often default process of ‘decisions
made about me without me’ is only slowly
changing. Empowering seniors and their
families to challenge clinicians and ask
about treatment burdens and realistic
expectations, as well as encouraging open
and honest conversation about dying, will
only improve the care they receive. ■
Associate Professor Magnolia Cardona,
Gold Coast Hospital and Health Service
and the Institute for Evidence-Based
Healthcare, Faculty of Health Sciences and
Medicine, Bond University.
Nurse Ebony Lewis, School of Public
Health and Community Medicine,
University of New South Wales.
Dr Alex Psirides, Intensive Care
Unit, Wellington Regional Hospital,
New Zealand.