industry & reform
There’s a big piece of research called
the Malik paper and it came out in 2018.
It was published in lots of planetary health
and leading medical journals in the world.
It showed that the health sector’s carbon
footprint is 7 per cent of our national
emissions. That’s the same as the total
emissions of South Australia.
It’s very good research which shows
what impact we’re having. But also, on the
flip side, what an opportunity we have to
get our own house in order.
We talk a lot now about the co-benefits:
what’s good for the environment is
good for health. For example, walking
and cycling rather than driving; eating
more plant-based foods; renewable
energy. Good for health, good for the
environment. So there are lots of these
win-win situations.
But we can save money doing this as
well. I did a lot of my training in the UK.
About 10 years ago when I was there, they
set up a national unit which was tasked
with reducing the carbon emissions of
the National Health Service. Over the past
decade, they’ve reduced their carbon
emissions by nearly 20 per cent despite an
increase in healthcare activity. And they’ve
saved nearly a billion pounds.
That’s something that gets the attention
of the executive and our healthcare
leaders. Now, this is a win-win situation
in health.
What does the sustainability plan in
your own health district entail?
We developed this plan in close
consultation with our staff, which was
really important. There are 10 areas
under that. We used the Sustainable
Development Assessment Tool, which is
what they use in the NHS. I think we’re the
first organisation in Australia to do that.
We measured our carbon footprint,
which I don’t think many organisations in
Australia have done. I’ve personally run
small group sessions with nearly 1000 of
our staff – that’s only 10 per cent of our
workforce. There’s that happening, and
there are great little pockets of practice
going on.
What we need to do now is think about
implementation and the broad changes
we can make at a strategic level to do
that. That’s what we’re grappling with at
the moment.
About a third of our carbon footprint
is energy. So we’re working with Health
Infrastructure NSW, which builds all the
buildings and does all the capital work.
We’re also trying to work with
HealthShare on procurements. There’s
a bunch of things going on, but we’re only
a few months in. There’s clearly a long
way to go. In the past, you’ve marched in protests
under the banner ‘Doctors for Climate
Action’. As someone who has this
knowledge, how does it feel when
governments and health systems ignore
the science?
What are the biggest wastes in hospitals,
and what areas are easiest to tackle? That’s a tricky one. There are great
opportunities to improve health and save
money and save carbon. I think we really
could be taking these on.
Nurses are a key group. I think there
are something like 400,000 nurses in this
country and they’re all well educated, well
trained, well organised and professional.
They work in every setting: hospitals.
healthcare centres, aged care facilities and
so on. We really think that nurses could be
climate leaders.
If nurses stepped up and said, “This
is a health issue, we’re really concerned
about this, and we’re going to be acting
on climate action,” then nurses could be
climate leaders and a key group.
Health professionals have a real
responsibility and opportunity to act, and
they have in the past on tobacco, asbestos
and other key public health issues.
This is now the issue for our age – it’s
scientific fact.
A global carbon footprint was published
just recently by Health Care Without Harm.
They found that 70 per cent of the global
footprint is procurement. So, it’s everything
that we buy and use.
The most surprising thing there is the
pharmaceuticals. The pharmaceuticals are
nearly 20 per cent of the carbon footprint
of our whole health system in this country.
It’s also food, medical devices, equipment
and furniture. All of those things we buy
and use.
What can healthcare professionals do
day-to-day on an individual level?
We can start to reconsider this in our
clinical decisions. There’s a lot of
literature now around the overdiagnosis
mode of treatment. We know that there
are significant harms and risks to patients
in ordering too many tests and doing too
many procedures. There are also costs
from that: not just financial costs but
carbon costs.
The key thing of course, as a system,
is to keep people well. Someone in my
PhD, one of the interviewees, said: “The
greenest system is the system in which
people don’t get sick in the first place.”
If you look at the health sector overall,
we need a much stronger focus on broad
and strong primary community-based
care. If you look at the carbon footprint
for our sector, about half of it is hospitals.
Everyone’s concerned about what we do
in hospitals, but in a low-carbon system,
we wouldn’t have so many hospitals. We’d
have much stronger and broader primary
community-based care.
We’re always going to need some sort
of substantive tertiary care – somewhere
to do heart transplants and things. So our
hospitals will need to have renewable
energy, and sustainable design and
procurement, and low-carbon models of
care and so on.
But we need to think much more
broadly and creatively beyond hospitals.
Day-to-day, professionals can look at
waste, keeping people well and out of
hospital, procurements – all of those
schemes are really important considering
the clinical decisions.
You mentioned earlier your switch to the
work you do now. Was there a moment
or an incident that made you think: I’ve
got to do this and I’ve got to tackle this at
a hospital or health system level?
Yes. I was working as a hospital doctor
about 10 years ago, and I happened to
go along to a university talk on climate
and health. I hadn’t really thought much
about climate change before that, and I
really didn’t see how it was relevant to my
day job on the ward or in the emergency
department. Then I went along to this
lecture and it was about an hour and they
just set out evidence for climate change,
what we’re on track for, what it would
mean for health. That was the penny-drop
moment for me.
I remember sitting there, looking at
the evidence. Health professionals are
scientifically trained. In my experience,
when you present the evidence to them
– it’s overwhelming now – they’re really
concerned.
The second thing was that within a few
months, I moved to London for a job.
There was a huge amount happening in
Europe and the UK in climate and health.
I really got caught up in that and I was
fortunate to work in a couple of leading
organisations at that time. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 17