legal corner
Unfairly fingered
Is your
employer
allowed to
collect your
biometric
data?
By Scott Trueman
I
ncreasingly, healthcare employers are
using biometric and electronic databases
and surveillance cameras to monitor
their employees, who need to be vigilant
about protecting their rights and personal
information. This case dealt with an
unfair dismissal claim in a non-healthcare
workplace, but it has direct relevance to the
health sector and issues of privacy.
The case concerns a company that
introduced fingerprint scanning of
employees as part of a new attendance
policy. One employee (Mr L) was a casual
‘general hand’ of more than three years
standing. In a November 2017 meeting, he
refused a request to provide his fingerprints.
Mr L was not satisfied the company could
guarantee no third-party access to the
fingerprint database, a concern he provided
in writing. The company responded with
documentation from the scanner supplier
that said the data could not be used for any
“purpose other than linking your payroll
number to a clock in/out time”.
Mr L, however, continued to use the
‘sign in’ book. He was given a verbal and
then a written warning that if he did not
comply with the scanning policy, his
employment would be terminated.
Further discussions did not bring about
a resolution, and in February 2018 he was
dismissed. Mr L brought an application
in the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for
unfair dismissal.
The employer submitted that its policy
to use fingerprint scanning was lawful,
reasonable and practical. Its justification was
that fingerprint scanning improved safety
in the event of an emergency, and that the
policy formed part of Mr L’s contract of
10 | nursingreview.com.au
employment and he was therefore obliged
to comply. Further, the collected biometric
data was secure and confidential, and
there was no breach of privacy due to an
exemption in the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) with
respect to his records.
Mr L’s submissions were that his
fingerprints and associated biometric data
constituted “sensitive information” according
to the Privacy Act, and, in any event, were
his private property. He asserted that once
his personal biometric data was digitised, it
would be difficult to contain its use by third
parties, including for commercial purposes,
and he was never informed exactly who
was likely to have access and under what
circumstances. Lastly, he submitted that the
Privacy Act exemption did not apply to his
records because the company failed to issue
a ‘privacy collection notice’ as required by
the Privacy Act.
The FWC at first instance determined
that the dismissal of Mr L was valid. It said
the site attendance policy was “reasonably
necessary” to improve safety and payroll
efficiency. The commission said that despite
the company not having a privacy policy,
this was outweighed by the reasonable
necessity of implementing a site attendance
policy. The commission concluded that the
dismissal was not, in all the circumstances,
harsh, unjust or unreasonable.
Mr L successfully appealed the decision
to the full bench of the FWC on several
grounds. Overturning the initial decision,
the full bench found that the company’s
reasons for dismissing Mr L were not valid
and contravened Australian privacy laws –
by not complying with its privacy obligations
pursuant to the Act.
As a result, Mr L was within his rights to
refuse to provide his fingerprint data and was
not in breach of his employment contract
because at the time of entering into the
contract such (electronic and biometric)
policies were not part of it.
Mr L’s concerns about data confidentiality
were also found to be valid. The full bench
found that prior to introducing the scanners,
the employer should have provided
employees with detailed information that it
was seeking to collect personally sensitive
information. It should have had a privacy
policy and a mechanism to manage and
protect such data after its collection.
In determining Mr L’s successful appeal,
the FWC undertook a detailed review of the
relevant Australian Privacy Principles (APP).
APP 1 requires a company/business to
have an up-to-date and clearly expressed
policy about its management of personal
information and how, in an open and
transparent means, it manages storage of
such personal information.
The company did not have the required
privacy policy or controls in place for
the collection, use and storage of the
information or data in question. In addition,
the company tended no evidence that it was
able to protect and manage information and
data. Tellingly, FWC found that management
had made little effort to make themselves
aware of privacy laws and their obligations.
APP 3 prohibits the collection of an
individual’s sensitive information without
consent, unless the information is
“reasonably necessary” for the company’s
activities or functioning. Any collection of
personal information can only occur by
lawful and fair means. The FWC found the
company’s direction to Mr L for provision
of his fingerprints was not “reasonably
necessary”, and therefore not lawful.
APP 5 provides that before or as soon
as practicable after collection of personal
information, reasonable steps must be taken
to notify individuals of an entity’s privacy
policy. Such notice must include details
about who is undertaking the collection;
the purposes of the private information
being collected; any consequences if
the information is not collected; how the
information may be accessed and corrected;
how to make complaints concerning
breaches of the APPs; how complaints
will be dealt with; whether it is likely the
information would be disclosed to overseas
recipients, and if so, in which countries those
recipients are located. The company failed
on these points.
The FWC stated that Mr L was within
his rights to refuse consent to having his
fingerprints scanned and registered and
therefore there was no valid reason to
dismiss him.
As more electronic devices are introduced
into health workplaces, nurses need ever
more vigilance. Such vigilance is often
nothing more than reminding an employer
of their legally mandated obligations. ■
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School
of Nursing, Midwifery and Nutrition at
James Cook University.