royal commission
Senator Richard Colbeck, minister
for aged care and senior Australians.
Photo: Kym Smith/News Corp
respect the independence of the royal
commission,” he said.
Labor MP Julie Collins described
Pagone’s comments as a “slap down” of
Colbeck.
“Senator Colbeck should correct the
record and apologise for verballing the
royal commissioners,” Collins said in a
statement.
The Liberals are obsessed with
privatisation – aged care assessments
are already being done by well
qualified professionals, why would
the Morrison government want to
privatise them?
— Julie Collins (@JulieCollinsMP)
30 Dec 2019
government. Our tasks as commissioners
are detailed in the terms of reference, and
we have not yet made recommendations
about which sector or mechanism will
best achieve an integration of Regional
Assessment Services and the Aged Care
Assessment Teams.”
However, Colbeck fired back on
Wednesday saying that the government
refutes “claims that our intention is to
privatise the assessment process for
aged care”.
“That assertion is incorrect. The
government is completely cognisant
of the view the royal commission has
expressed in its interim report regarding
the integration of these assessment
services as reiterated by Commissioner
Pagone ... The government continues to
Some fear that if the assessment buck is
passed on to the private sector, the current
standard of assessment will decrease and
move to a KPI-focused model.
Dr Timothy Woodruff of the Doctors
Reform Society said: “A privatised ACAT will
be a race to the bottom.
“Poorly trained assessors will
inadequately assess complex patient needs
as they gouge government fees for their
private owners and force the dedicated
assessors out of the system because they
will not be profitable. More taxes wasted
and gifted to private businesses.”
Neuroscience Research Australia
professor of geriatric medicine Tony Broe
wrote in a recent opinion piece that this
is another misstep in a long history of
aged care mismanagement by successive
governments.
“[The government] has failed to deal
effectively with the country’s aged health
care needs, and what has developed is an
aged-care crisis with social, political and
health-related ramifications,” he said.
“Senator Colbeck is correct to say there
are inconsistencies in the service that need
to be addressed with a national approach.
However, this does not mean throwing the
ACAT baby out with the failed aged care
bath water.”
However, two of the aged care peak
bodies say they are more concerned with
the best possible outcomes for consumers
than who delivers the assessments.
Aged and Community Services Australia
chief executive Patricia Sparrow told
Nursing Review that she is supportive
of the government’s announcement
to integrate the RAS and ACAT teams
to “deliver consistent and accurate
assessment for older Australians”.
“Our concern is not with who delivers
the assessment on behalf of the
government, as many government services
are contracted out to third parties.
“It needs to be well resourced so that
assessments are accurate and timely,
allowing providers to confidently deliver
the care that’s needed.
“The issue is of the government
providing enough funding to keep the
residential care sector, who are struggling,
as well as home care providers who are
being forced to cut costs to remain viable
and deliver the care older Australians
require,” she said.
Leading Age Services Australia CEO Sean
Rooney said: “LASA supports an efficient
and effective system that delivers the
best outcomes for consumers, including
accurate assessments that provide a strong
basis for providers to develop care plans.”
Elsewhere, the commission has
announced that it will reconvene for 2020
in a slightly different format.
Held over 10–11 February at the Adelaide
Convention Centre, the hearing will be a
workshop with a panel of witnesses who
will have the ability to form discussions
with each other, counsel assisting and the
commissioners as they test propositions
and ideas in preparation for the final report,
due in November this year.
This more informal set up will not take
place in a hearing room or court-like
setting and will focus on the redesign of
the aged care system.
The commission said that future
workshops may be scheduled later.
This announcement coincided with
the release of two background papers
conducted by Flinders University for the
commission. The research looked at
international systems and innovations
in aged care and has identified many
opportunities for improvement in Australia.
In one paper, the researchers examined
aged care systems in 22 countries and
found Australia lacking in funding,
transparency of staffing levels and
regulation, when compared with better
performing countries.
In the other paper, which focuses on
innovative models of aged care, the
authors identify approaches which could
benefit the Australian system, such as
telehealth communications, training which
supports people with dementia living at
home and their carers, and remote support
of independent living through ‘health smart
homes’. Both papers can be found on the
royal commission website. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 9