Kashmir Scan 05 | Page 4

Coming back to my observation
flexibility Kashmiris had shown .
the decision to hang Afzal is purely
as to why Kashmir was buried in
From 2003 onwards the people had
political and taken at the level of
Tihar . The decision to hang Afzal , as
supported the peace process be-
Congress core committee . Accordis
now clear , was purely political
tween India and Pakistan , though
ing to insiders , the top brass of Army ,
since Congress was feeling the heat
with limited benefit to Kashmiris in
Intelligence Bureau , and Central Reof
Modi march to Delhi in 2014 . But
the shape of Confidence Building
serve Police Force have argued
could they take a similar decision a
Measures . But it was to show that
against this decision apprehending
decade back to keep BJP at bay for
they are for peaceful settlement of
serious trouble in Kashmir , but the
the electoral gains . Perhaps not . It is
the issue and want to take active part
political weightage has over shadactually
the confidence New Delhi
in that process . It is ironic that Con-
owed their “ advice ” and plunged the
has gained over a period of time that
gress “ apparently fell into the trap ”
place into the crisis .
they could take any “ risk ” in Kash-
of Bhartiya Janta Party ' s continued
Kashmir may revert back to normir
. Looking closely at this decision ,
tirade and succumbed to the situa-
malcy though nothing can be anticiit
is an unquestionable fact that the
tion in order to ensure that they are
pated at this stage . But those who
Congress led UPA government no
back in the saddle in 2014 . But it is
believe that it will not push into a situlonger
looks at Kashmir through the
BJP ' s stalwart Atal Bihari Vajpayee
ation as it did after five years of
prism of political exigency but
who is seen as a peace maker in the
Jammu and Kashmir Liberation
purely as a law and order issue
Front founder Maqbool Butt ' s
which can be dealt with the rein-
hanging in the same month in
forcement of few thousand more
same jail in 1984 are wrong in
Para military forces . By taking
their assessment . It may not push
Afzal to gallows , Congress might
another generation into violence ,
have won the “ hearts ” of Indian
but at least the generation that has
voters , but it has shut the doors of
grown after 1990 will identify itreconciliation
at least for some
self with Guru and the rest one
time . Even if Kashmiris were
will follow . The hanging will igready
to move forward on the path
nite a sense of renewed disilluof
peace and reconciliation , New
sionment and alienation . Today ' s
Delhi has shown that it does not
generation is not as naive as it was
care much about that . It has virtu-
in 1984 . They are well educated ,
ally dismissed the sentiments in
articulate and politically more con-
Kashmir with contempt by going
scious of their political rights .
ahead with Afzal ' s hanging . Not
They are unarmed and it is diffionly
has the hanging a potential to
cult to contain them through the
have a long term impact on the psy-
methods , which have been used in
che of Kashmir youth as sug-
the past . Kashmiri students agitatgested
by Omar Abdullah , but the
ing at Jantar Mantar in Delhi is
way the family was denied the last
enough to learn a lesson about
meeting with him has hurt a common Kashmiri to the hilt .
The decision of hanging has purely come at the cost of Kashmir .
A place battered with conflict is yet to recover from the wounds inflicted on its population . Still it had shown the courage and resilience to compromise with the fact that normalcy
was an important tool to sustain the economy , though not at the cost of the political aspirations . While the
GoI was “ celebrating ” this “ normalcy ” by projecting 85 percent participation in Panchayat elections and arrival of 1.4 million tourists in
2012 , it failed to encash on this wave
region . His former adviser and RAW chief AS Dulat has said that if it would have been Vajpayee , there was no possibility of sending Guru to gallows . He was also disturbed at
the fact that this situation has pushed the Valley back by many years .
There was an overwhelming demand from various quarters in India , including the various human
rights groups , for commutation of
Guru ' s death sentence . In hindsight ,
had it indeed been commuted to life sentence , it could have proved a ma- jor confidence building measure for the valley .
how volatile the youth can be in this age . In 1984 there was none to agitate against Butt ' s hanging in
Delhi and not many even in Kashmir but this time the only option with the government to quell the strong re- sentment is to barricade the Valley and put it under long spell of curfew .
If they do not have problems with
New Delhi ' s decision vis-a-vis Kash- mir then why this long siege ? Politi- cally they did bury Kashmir in another grave in Tihar but it has a les- son for the government to learn and not just merely see it as an end of an offender who helped militants attack the parliament .
and rather “ misused ” this sense of
If the sources are to be believed ,
| KASHMIR SCAN | May 2013 | 1 |