Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 51-6 | Page 40
J Rehabil Med 2019; 51: 434–441
ORIGINAL REPORT
FUNCTIONAL EFFECTS OF BOTULINUM TOXIN TYPE A IN THE HIP ADDUCTORS
AND SUBSEQUENT STRETCHING IN PATIENTS WITH HEREDITARY SPASTIC
PARAPLEGIA
Bas J. H. VAN LITH, MSc 1 , Jasper DEN BOER, PT, PhD 1 , Bart P. C. VAN DE WARRENBURG, MD, PhD 2 , Vivian
WEERDESTEYN, PT, PhD 1 and Alexander C. GEURTS, MD, PhD 1
From the 1 Department of Rehabilitation and 2 Department of Neurology, Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud
University Medical Center, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
Objective: To investigate the functional effects of bi-
lateral botulinum toxin A treatment and subsequent
stretching of spastic hip adductors on gait and reac-
tive lateral stepping responses in patients with pure
hereditary spastic paraplegia.
Design: Explorative pre-post intervention study.
Patients: Twenty-five patients with pure hereditary
spastic paraplegia.
Methods: Patients were treated with bilateral bo-
tulinum toxin A injections in the hip adductors and
performed daily self-administered stretching exerci-
ses for 16 weeks. Before the intervention (T0), and
6 (T1) and 16 (T2) weeks thereafter, gait width, gait
speed, and leg angles at first stepping-foot contact
after lateral balance perturbations were assessed,
as well as the corresponding success rates of reac-
tive lateral steps.
Results: Compared with baseline, gait width in-
creased by 12.6% and 9.7% and comfortable gait
speed by 8.3% and 11.5% at T1 and T2, respecti-
vely. In known perturbation directions, leg angles
increased by 5.9% at T1 and 8.0% at T2, while suc-
cess rates increased from 70% at baseline to 90%
at T1 and T2. No effects were found for maximal gait
speed or lateral stepping responses in unknown per-
turbation directions.
Conclusion: Bilateral botulinum toxin A treatment
and subsequent stretching of the hip adductors may
improve gait and reactive lateral stepping in patients
with pure hereditary spastic paraplegia.
Key words: hereditary spastic paraplegia; botulinum toxin;
balance control; gait.
Accepted Mar 29, 2019; Epub ahead of print Apr 10, 2019
J Rehabil Med 2019; 51: 434–441
Correspondence address: Bas van Lith, Department of Rehabilitation,
Donders Institute for Brain, Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud Uni-
versity Medical Center, PO Box 9101, 6500 HB Nijmegen, The Nether-
lands. E-mail: [email protected]
P
atients with pure hereditary spastic paraplegia
(HSP) show a slow, retrograde axonal degeneration
of the corticospinal tract, which leads to bilateral pro-
gressive lower extremity spasticity. Although muscle
strength and somatosensation are often also affected,
the degree of paresis and sensory loss is usually milder
than in other conditions with spastic paraparesis (e.g.
LAY ABSTRACT
Patients with pure hereditary spastic paraplegia often
have hip adductor spasticity, causing reduced gait width
and a narrow base of support. In addition, they expe-
rience difficulties stepping sideways to recover from si-
deward balance perturbations. A small base of support
and the presumed side-stepping difficulties probably in-
crease their risk of falling. Botulinum toxin type A injec-
tions are commonly used to reduce spasticity in patients
with hereditary spastic paraplegia, but no studies have
systematically investigated the effects of botulinum
toxin type A in (with subsequent stretching of) the hip
adductors on gait and balance. The results of this study
indicate that, after botulinum toxin type A administra-
tion, there is an increase in comfortable gait speed and
gait width. Furthermore, patients show improved reac-
tive stepping responses when the perturbation direction
is known. It is concluded that botulinum toxin type A
treatment and subsequent stretching of the hip adduc-
tors may improve gait and reactive lateral stepping in
patients with pure hereditary spastic paraplegia.
spinal cord injury or multiple sclerosis) (1, 2). Hip
adductor spasticity is often prominently present in
patients with pure HSP. Besides loss of gait propulsion
and deterioration of balance in the plane of progression
(1, 3), patients are usually also affected by frontal-plane
imbalance, to which hip adductor spasticity is sug-
gested to be an important contributing factor (4). This
may be explained by spasticity of the hip adductors
leading to forced, spontaneous narrowing of the base
of support while standing and walking (“scissoring”).
In addition, patients with HSP may experience difficul-
ties stepping sideways to recover from lateral balance
perturbations, as the hip abductors have to overcome
the involuntary activity of the spastic hip adductors.
The small base of support in combination with the pre-
sumed difficulties in side-stepping probably increase
the risk of falling in patients with HSP.
Botulinum toxin type A (BTX-A) injections are
commonly used for reducing spasticity in patients with
HSP (2, 5–8), although BTX-A is still on off-label
prescription in HSP for all commercially available
toxins. BTX-A treatment of the hip adductors, calf
muscles and hamstrings has been suggested to lead to
functional improvements in balance and gait capacities
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license. www.medicaljournals.se/jrm
doi: 10.2340/16501977-2526
Journal Compilation © 2019 Foundation of Rehabilitation Information. ISSN 1650-1977