Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 51-6 | Page 3
J Rehabil Med 2019; 51: 397–404
REVIEW ARTICLE
ASSESSMENT FOR INCIPIENT HOSPITAL-ACQUIRED DECONDITIONING IN
ACUTE HOSPITAL SETTINGS: A SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEW
Susan GORDON, PhD 1 , Karen A. GRIMMER, PhD 1,2 and Sarah BARRAS, PhD 3
From the 1 College of Nursing and Health Sciences, Flinders University, South Australia, 2 Physiotherapy, Faculty of Medicine and Health
Sciences, Stellenbosch University and 3 Australian Health Services Alliance, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Objectives: To systematically identify literature re-
porting on assessment instruments relevant for inci-
pient hospital-acquired deconditioning during acute
hospital admissions; evaluate their psychometric
properties; and identify individual assessment items
to form the basis of a comprehensive acute hospital
test battery for hospital-acquired deconditioning.
Design and data sources: Systematic evidence scan
of MEDLINE, CINAHL, PubMed and Google Scholar
from database inception to January 2018.
Study selection: Papers reporting psychometric pro-
perties of assessment instruments to detect change
in body function and structure, relevant to hospital-
acquired deconditioning were selected. Included in-
struments should assess one or more elements of
hospital-acquired deconditioning, reflect the short
time-frame constraints of acute hospital admissions,
and be able to be applied by any healthcare provider.
Quality evaluation: Evidence of psychometric pro-
perties and utility were assessed using a validated
instrument.
Data extraction: Hospital-acquired deconditioning
assessment items.
Results: Eight potentially-relevant instruments were
identified, with moderate-to-good validity and
utility, but limited evidence of reliability. These
instruments reported a total of 53 hospital-acquired
deconditioning assessment items. Seventeen items
with measurement periods greater than 3 days were
excluded. The remaining items measured anthro
pometrics, gait, balance, mobility, activities of daily
living, and skin integrity.
Conclusion: These assessment items provide the ba-
sis of a multifaceted evidence-based test battery to
comprehensively and repeatedly assess acute hospi-
tal inpatient function for incipient hospital-acquired
deconditioning.
Key words: hospital-acquired deconditioning; HAD; assess-
ment; inter-professional practice; quality care; discharge
planning; functional decline; frailty; systematic evidence
scan; psychometric properties; utility; older people; acute
hospital admission.
Accepted Feb 26, 2019; Epub ahead of print Mar 15, 2019
J Rehabil Med 2019; 51: 397–404
Correspondence address: Sue Gordon, Chair of Restorative Care in
Ageing, A partnership position funded by ACH group and Flinders Uni-
versity, College of Nursing & Health Sciences, Clinical Teaching and
Education Centre at ViTA, 17 Rockville Avenue, Daw Park, South Aus-
tralia 5041, Australia. E-mail: [email protected]
LAY ABSTRACT
Hospital-acquired deconditioning can occur insidiously
and rapidly as a result of enforced bed rest, immobiliza-
tion or sedentary behaviours. While hospital-acquired
deconditioning can occur in people of any age, it is par-
ticularly problematic in elderly people, as it can lead to
irreversible functional decline. Hospital-acquired decon-
ditioning is preventable with proactive, comprehensive
regular assessment to detect changes in the perfor-
mance of body systems. The time-period of assessment
must be short, so that repeated assessments can be
made during an acute hospital admission. At present
there is no comprehensive, time-sensitive assessment
instrument for hospital-acquired deconditioning. Ba-
sed on a systematic scan of the literature, this paper
proposes a core set of items that could be developed
into a comprehensive, standardized assessment instru-
ment for regular application by any healthcare provi-
der during an acute inpatient stay, to identify incipient
hospital-acquired deconditioning. The assessment items
measured anthropometrics, gait, balance, mobility, acti-
vities of daily living, and skin integrity.
D
econditioning is “a complex process of physio-
logical change following a period of inactivity,
bedrest or sedentary lifestyle” (1, p. 16). Older people
are particularly at risk (1–5), as deconditioning in this
age group can quickly progress to irreversible functio-
nal deterioration and frailty (3, 4, 6, 7), decreased life
expectancy and quality of life.
Hospital-acquired deconditioning (HAD) can occur
within days for adults of any age, during acute hospital
admissions involving enforced bed rest, immobiliza-
tion and/or sedentary behaviours (2–4, 7). There is
no standard definition of HAD, and no agreement
on common HAD elements, or assessment practices
(1–4, 8–10). HAD changes can be insidious, and if
undetected, can delay safe discharge from hospital and/
or require additional recuperative care (5–7, 9). It is
counterintuitive that HAD should occur in healthcare
settings, where it could be reasonably expected that
health should improve, not decline (2, 4, 12). How
ever, HAD is a reality in many countries (2, 4, 12). It is
coded as M62.81 (generalized muscle weakness) in the
International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision,
Clinical Modification (ICD-10-CM), a system used by
healthcare providers to code diagnoses, symptoms and
procedures related to hospital care (8).
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license. www.medicaljournals.se/jrm
Journal Compilation © 2019 Foundation of Rehabilitation Information. ISSN 1650-1977
doi: 10.2340/16501977-2546