has arisen between the Forest Rights Act( FRA) and the Forest( Conservation) Act. He has suggested that the issue be reviewed and that the BJP government will move forward by resolving this controversy, indirectly implying that the provisions of the Forest Rights Act would be suitably diluted.
Very recently, the Minister of Tribal Affairs came forward boldly with the perverse argument that the FRA contains no provision requiring the consent of the gram sabhas of tribal communities for the construction of mega-hydroelectric projects and other such initiatives. He further argued that even if the consent of the gram sabhas is required, unanimous consent is not necessary and that the consent of 70 % to 80 % of the gram sabhas would be sufficient. In practice, we are already witnessing forged gram sabha consents being presented by various administrations, along with various machinations, such as attempts to create divisions within tribal communities in the name of elections, as is being attempted by the administration of the Nicobar Islands. The administration has also grandly announced that tribal communities must be brought into modern civilisation, implying that they must leave their rightful forest habitats and ancestral lands, relocate to towns and unfamiliar regions, and become‘ civilised’.
The Tribal Affairs Minister recently announced that his ministry would abdicate its mandated responsibility for implementing the Forest Rights Act, 2006.
On the other hand, Prime Minister Modi is openly batting for big capital, invoking national interest to counter environmental protection concerns and advocating an approach that effectively sidelines environmental considerations. Yesterday, we witnessed PM Modi urging the courts to take national interest into account while considering such matters. He was 12 supporting Vedanta Corporation’ s demand for permission to operate its proposed‘ green’ copper plant, operated by its Sterlite subsidiary, at the Thoothukudi site, after the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board rejected its application to reopen the facility. Speaking in Hyderabad, PM Modi said,“ I appeal to the courts that whenever such situations arise, efforts should be made to find solutions keeping national interest foremost.” In doing so, he appeared to support the interests of big capital under the guise of‘ national interest’.
Recently, the Central Government filed petitions in the Supreme Court seeking a stay on further proceedings in petitions pending before the Calcutta High Court until a final hearing, alleging that the provisions of the Forest Rights Act( FRA) had been violated in obtaining consent for the ¹ 92,000- crore Great Nicobar Island( GNI) project. The government argued that it was duty-bound to ensure that the country’ s growth was not brought to a halt. The petitions on behalf of the tribal communities were filed by Ms. Meena Gupta, a retired IAS officer who served as a secretary in both the Environment and Tribal Affairs ministries. She was involved in drafting the Bill that eventually became the Forest Rights Act. Over the past two years, Ms. Gupta has filed several petitions“ espousing the cause of the vulnerable tribal community,” as noted by the Calcutta High Court. These petitions challenge the gram sabha resolutions consenting to the diversion of forest land for the project under the FRA, the constitution of a sub-divisional committee under the same law, and the notifications reducing the buffer zones of both Campbell Bay and Galathea Bay National Parks. The petitions also question the validity of a certificate issued by the Andaman and Nicobar Islands administration claiming that all rights under the FRA have been identified and settled.
W hile the BJP-led Central Government has been making efforts to undermine the spirit and ruling of the Supreme Court’ s Niyamgiri judgment by seeking to absolve the Ministry of Tribal Affairs of its responsibility to implement the FRA in letter and spirit, big capital, too, is making efforts to undermine the same judgment through another devious means.
Recently, the chairman of the Vedanta Group met the Chief Minister of Odisha and discussed reopening the Niyamgiri bauxite reserves in Odisha for mining, which had previously been assured to the company. He put forward the pretentious argument that“ the tribal population there should be given employment opportunities and brought into the development process,” while also seeking to entice the BJP-led Odisha state government with the promise that the Vedanta Group was committed to investing 1 lakh crore in the state, which is seeking to deepen“ mineral-based industrialisation.”
This proposal to revive mining comes against the backdrop of the gram sabha decisions rejecting mining in the Niyamgiri Hills, in opposition to which the Dongria Kondh community, a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group( PVTG), has consistently resisted mining. The proposal is particularly noteworthy in light of the Supreme Court’ s ruling in the Niyamgiri case, as it seeks to undermine, circumvent, and obscure the spirit, force, and authority of the Supreme Court’ s judgment, thereby threatening the statutory forest rights and constitutional guarantees of tribal communities.
This is how, in subservience to big capital and big capitalists, the BJP rulers are making efforts to plunder India’ s resources at the cost of the forest rights of vulnerable tribal communities and environmental protection! �
Class Struggle