CS October 2026 | Page 11

The BJP Rulers and the Big-Capital are Making Every Possible Effort to Defeat and Nullify the Spirit of the Supreme Court Judgement on Niyamgiri

The Supreme Court’ s judgment against bauxite mining without the consent of the gram sabhas of the Niyamgiri Hills in Odisha is considered a landmark judgment in asserting and protecting the forest rights of tribal communities, as guaranteed by the Constitution of India. The Supreme Court’ s ruling in the Niyamgiri case gave the affected tribal communities the authority to examine whether the proposed projects would infringe upon their religious and cultural rights under the Forest Rights Act, 2006. Following the Supreme Court’ s ruling, the decisions of the gram sabhas of the Niyamgiri Hills rejecting mining in the region were upheld. Moreover, the Supreme Court also stipulated that the Ministry of Tribal Affairs would be responsible for implementing the Forest Rights Act, particularly with regard to ensuring that the decisions of the gram sabhas were honoured and respected.
This judgment is not palatable to the rulers of India, who are devoted to serving the interests of big capital. This is particularly true of the BJP rulers, who are handing over the country’ s rich resources to big capital for exploitation, even at the cost of the interests of the people of India and the environmental disasters that follow.
In the name of India’ s growth and strategic concerns, the government is planning and constructing mega hydroelectric projects, permitting large-scale mining activities and projects by the private sector, and building highways and tunnels, mostly in areas inhabited by tribal communities and covered by forests. These activities
October-2026 are displacing and dispossessing tribal communities of their natural habitats and undermining their rights guaranteed by the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and the Constitution of India.
However, the government has been unable to proceed at the pace it desires to enable big capital to exploit resources and reap superprofits. This is due to the Supreme Court’ s Niyamgiri judgment and its ruling on the protection of the forest rights of tribal communities, which made the decisions and consent of tribal gram sabhas a mandatory precondition for proceeding with construction projects, mining activities, or the diversion of forest areas for any other purpose. This requirement restricts the government’ s and the rulers’ efforts to displace and dispossess tribal communities from their natural habitats in forests and hills and to usurp the forest rights statutorily guaranteed to these indigenous communities
On the one hand, the BJP government led by Prime Minister Modi has showcased a tribal woman as the President of India and celebrated the 150 th birth anniversary of Birsa Munda, an icon of tribal communities, on a grand scale. Through these gestures, it has projected itself as a government committed to the welfare of tribal communities, with its Ministry of Tribal Affairs supposedly striving to fulfil their aspirations and secure their votes to retain political power. On the other hand, the government has been acting in concert with big capital, cunningly making every effort to dilute the spirit of the
Supreme Court’ s judgment in the Niyamgiri case and undermine its authority through devious means, with the aim of nullifying its ruling and circumventing the mandatory requirement of obtaining the consent of the gram sabhas of tribal communities.
On the other hand, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs, which is responsible for implementing the Forest Rights Act, 2006, in letter and spirit, is attempting, through perverse logic and reasoning, to evade and abdicate its constitutionally assigned responsibility.
Various state governments and government departments, such as the Forest Department, Finance Department, Environment Department, and Mining Department, are putting forward arguments and demands that they cannot proceed with mega-hydroelectric projects, megaseaport projects, green energy projects, wildlife conservation projects, mining projects, and other initiatives planned by the central and state governments for the country’ s economic development, as envisaged by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The so-called experts and intellectuals supporting the BJP governments and big capital are propounding that the requirement under the Forest Rights Act, 2006, for the necessary consent of tribal communities and their gram sabhas is impeding the economic development of the country and are demanding that such a restriction be removed.
The BJP Minister for Tribal Affairs in the Central Government has argued that, owing to court interventions and the Supreme Court’ s judgment, a controversy
11