Australian Doctor Australian Doctor 2 June 2017 | Page 29

Letters

Plan to make Medicare irrelevant

Letters

Your Views
EDITOR Your leading article,‘ Peace in our time: College and AMA sign budget pact with the Government’( Australian Doctor, 19 May), aptly described the capitulation of the AMA and RACGP in their negotiation with the government.
The sop of removing the freeze on consultations next year some time completely ignored the pathetic indexation formula, which has made the contribution for consultations become ridiculously low.
In many places the gap fee is already greater than the Medicare rebate. Labor got it wrong— the government is not intending to privatise Medicare, it is making it irrelevant.
Bulk-billing practices are an expected component of the medical system. While they exist, the government can appease the workers who have not had an effective pay rise for years.
The government will not let bulkbilling crash— doing just enough to keep it going is the obvious plan. The capitation proposal for chronic illness management is an example of how it will be propped up.
Meanwhile, gap payments will have to rise.
Dr Ray Burn GP, Yass, NSW
FROM THE WEB
EDITOR They have lost the plot... and now, the plot— general practice— is a new wasteland.
The AMA and RACGP do not speak unanimously for the bulk of GPs. Dr Breck McKay GP, Brisbane, Qld
Have your say
All letters should contain the sender’ s title, address and daytime phone number. Letters should be exclusive, no more than 250 words and may be edited. Letters should be sent to: Fax:( 02) 8484 0800 or email: mail @ australiandoctor. com. au
Health Care Homes = unpaid paperwork
EDITOR The criteria that Health Care Homes need to meet can be summarised as: paperwork, paperwork and more paperwork(‘ Corporates dominate Health Care Homes trial’, 18 May, australiandoctor. com. au).
Meanwhile, as I take 24 / 7 phone calls from the elderly, palliative care patients, nursing homes, as well as constant texts and phone calls from other worried patients, that work has no value at all.
How about asking patients what they value?
Dr Maureen Fitzsimon GP, Logan, Qld
EDITOR The amount of extra paperwork involved in Health Care Homes will be mindboggling. And it will need to be mostly performed after working hours. With the 24 / 7 email and video access by patients— and thus 24-hours on-call— it will mean no rest.
Also, it appears only accredited practices will be eligible. That will cut out a lot of small practices for whom accreditation is not practical or financially worthwhile.
Dr Tibor Konkoly GP, Morayfield, Qld
australiandoctor. com. au
Australian Doctor team
Editor-in-chief: Clifford Fram( 02) 8484 0765
Editor: Jo Hartley( 02) 8484 0741
Deputy editor: Paul Smith( 02) 8484 0795
Medical co-editors: Dr Isis Maitland-Scott MBBS FRACGP( 02) 8484 0903
Dr Paul Muthiah MUDr FRACGP( 02) 8484 0948
How to Treat editor: Dr Claire Berman MBBCh( 02) 8484 0749
Clinical news editor: Michael Woodhead( 02) 8484 0674
Digital editor: Paddy Wood( 02) 8484 0615
Chief reporter: Brett Evans( 02) 8484 0784
Reporters: Geir O’ Rourke( 02) 8484 0879 Clare Pain( 02) 8484 0826 Antony Scholefield( 02) 8484 0957 Rachel Worsley( 02) 8484 0883 Jocelyn Wright( 02) 8484 0917
Chief content producer / Smart Practice editor: Cheree Corbin( 02) 8484 0860
Deputy chief content producer: Gita Sankaran( 02) 8484 0806
Content producers: Gill Canning( 02) 8484 0786 Sophie Attwood( 02) 8484 0606
Photo editor and site producer: Stacey Shipton( 02) 8484 0799
Art director: Suzanne Elworthy( 02) 8484 0673
Senior graphic designer: Edison Bartolome( 02) 8484 0872
Managing director: Bryn McGeever( 02) 8484 0650
Sales and marketing inquiries:( 02) 8484 0603
Classified pages bookings: Classifieds Manager gpclassifieds @ adg. com. au
Production co-ordinator: Eve Allen( 02) 8484 0764
EMAIL US @: To email staff, use the following format: first name. surname @ adg. com. au

TWEET OF THE WEEK

“ Wear odd socks June 1 make point Drs in crisis.”
— Dr Geoff Toogood, cardiologist and mental health advocate @ gdtoogood
Follow us at @ australiandr
College conned
( RACGP chief defends budget pact with govt, 16 May) The AMA’ s graph plotting CPI against Medicare from 1985- 2015 sort of tells the story, doesn’ t it? Most of us thought the rebates had sunk to about half of what they should be, but it’ s actually worse. So even if they lift the freeze in a year, it matters not. GPs will still be receiving only about a half of what they should. By the govt’ s own admission, 85 % of GP services are bulk-billed, so half is all they will get— forever— unless something drastic is done. There is nothing in the RACGP’ s agreement that comes close to doing this. The college was conned, and still thinks it achieved something worthwhile. How sad.
Subtractor
Rural folk miss out
( Call to cut hospital transfer time of stroke patients, 17 May) I guess those living in rural or remote locations and have a thrombotic stroke just miss out.
Rick Hambour That is great, but what about outside of the cities? It would be nice if the country areas got upgrades before the cities start
worrying about shaving off response times for their cases. These goals eat up the funding that has to be shared among the entirety of each state and territory. Clearly, there needs to be a bigger push for country funding. Not only do you have to contend with one helicopter over a larger geographical area in the country but you also have to allow for the helicopter not being operational due to servicing and / or change of shift.
Karina
It takes two to tango
( 8 reasons for GPs to grill patients about alternative therapies, 9 May) Well, it actually goes both ways. When I see a patient, I write back to all their involved
health‘ professionals’ I know of. While that’ s usually doctors, it includes physios, hand therapists, etc. Apart from the two above, I have never received a letter from a chiropractor, podiatrist, osteopath, etc. You will counter that I should make the time, but let’ s be honest— who has the time to chase down whichever quack the patient is currently seeing? And if the patient with dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma wants to go to Mexico for a vegetable cleanse, good luck to them. But it will be without my involvement. awfulpod I used to scoff at acupuncture, but then realised a less arrogant approach is more productive. And yes,
acupuncture does work, but it’ s operator-dependent. Examples of‘ alternative’ remedies now firmly in the therapeutic armamentarium also abound( eg, magnesium). So if a patient is taking something alternative, I inquire what it is supposed to do and whether it does it. If so, I exert myself to look it up. Who knows, I might even learn something.
Iliya Englin
Dose a confounder
( 4 new findings about heart attack risk with NSAIDs, 10 May) We need to look at the specifics of the study— eg, what doses were used. A recently published study( see: bit. ly / 2pNi5XN) showed the non-inferiority of celecoxib compared with a common NSAID with respect to cardiovascular safety, but they used 200mg daily of celecoxib and more than 2000mg of ibuprofen, whereas in Australia the maximum dose commonly used is 1200mg.
Fouad Dawood What about dosing of the anti-inflammatories? If we start at half-dose for the first few weeks, and then increase to full dose, is the risk reduced relatively?
Lawrencetlc
The views expressed in this publication are not necessarily those of Australian Doctor Group.
Australian Doctor is an independent publication serving the needs of Australia’ s general practitioners. It has no affiliation with any medical organisation or association, and our editorial content is free of influence from advertisers.
Australian Doctor is sent free to full-time GPs in private practice and certain prescribing and staff specialists. It is available to other readers on subscription for $ 390.00 pa including GST. Overseas rates apply. Phone( 02) 8484 0666.
Average Net Distribution Period ending September 2016 19,810
Australian Doctor is published 48 times a year by Australian Doctor Group, Tower 2, 475 Victoria Avenue, Locked Bag 2999, Chatswood DC, NSW 2067 Ph:( 02) 8484 0888 Fax:( 02) 8484 0800 Email: mail @ australiandoctor. com. au
www. australiandoctor. com. au( Inc in NSW) ACN 132 719 861 ABN 94 615 959 914 ISSN 1039-7116 © Copyright 2017 www. adg. com. au
Australian Doctor is printed by Fairfax Media on PEFC certified paper, meaning it originates from forests that are sustainably managed. PEFC is an international certification program which assures consumers that a forest product can be tracked from a certified, managed forest through all steps of processing and production in the supply chain by a chain of custody process. Fairfax Media source their magazine paper from mills that are FFC and PEFC certified.
www. australiandoctor. com. au 2 June 2017 | Australian Doctor | 29