African Mining May 2024 | Página 34

• FINANCE FORUM
through financial incentives . We may see a similar trend for more aggressive KPI targets in future in the South African market and perhaps more punitive margin ratchets and structuring .
The benefits of a sustainable financing arrangement are that a borrower can :
• save on its interest costs ( and often in circumstances where it is already complying or aligning with its own internal objectives ); and
• potentially access additional funding that it may otherwise not be eligible to access .
The risks are that :
• failure to comply could result in an increased interest cost ; and
• if the KPI targets are not set at appropriate levels , one could potentially face allegations of greenwashing .
Use of proceeds financing Use of proceeds financing focuses on the purpose against which the proceeds are applied . This funding arrangement can be either a loan ( or similar instrument ) or a security , such as bonds , notes or other commercial paper . Listed bonds and notes tend to largely be limited to the use of proceeds financing due to many of the factors mentioned above .
This type of funding is appropriate where it is possible to link the purpose to which the funding will be applied to an ESG-linked cause . This purpose could take various forms , such as a once-off expenditure such as the installation of a solar-powered system , a multi-stage project , such as the construction of a greenfields development ; or a brownfields expansion , or even a longer-term , ongoing initiative such as a housing or education development programme .
We initially saw a number of " green bonds " or " green loans " ( also known as sustainability-linked funding instruments ) where the proceeds were used to fund an environmentally friendly or climate-based initiative . There has been a recent rise in the number of social funding instruments ( targeting , for example , housing or employment initiatives ), " blue " funding instruments ( targeting ocean-based initiatives ) and sustainability funding instruments ( which combine characteristics of green and social instruments ).
A benefit of this type of funding is that it can be more accessible for a broader range of borrowers or issuers , ranging from governments , project companies and big corporates to smaller enterprises looking to fund an ESG-linked purpose . There are even products available now to individuals who are looking to fund alternative energy sources for their homes . In addition , access to the listed and unlisted bond market may provide additional funding opportunities for a range of borrowers .
It is a key requirement for the borrower or issuer to disclose how the proceeds are applied for this type of funding . This may include a report on initial expenditure and subsequent reporting on the actual and anticipated impact of the funded initiative .
There are similar risks and benefits for this type of funding – namely , a potential margin ratchet for non-compliance , on the one hand , and a margin reduction and / or access to additional funding on the other . Greenwashing also remains a risk if , for example , the purpose to which the loan proceeds are applied does not actually benefit , or even indirectly support an initiative that actively harms the relevant cause .
Additional bond market considerations may also apply if the funding instrument is a debt security . These include , on the one hand , access to a different , potentially broader pool of funders ( each with their own internal investment criteria ) and the ability to determine the pricing of the instruments up front . On the other hand , the listed bond space is also subject to additional regulatory requirements , which may impose further reporting obligations and pose other regulatory pitfalls . •
In the UK and European markets , there appears to be an emerging trend of requiring more aggressive KPI targets , both upfront and year-on-year , to avoid allegations of greenwashing .
Image by User6702303 | Freepik . com
32 • African Mining • May 2024 www . africanmining . co . za