FINANCE FORUM •
BEYOND GREEN – SUSTAINABLE
FINANCE VERSUS GREEN LOANS ( PART 1 )
By Natasha Pather , partner at Webber Wentzel
ESG-linked financing is a hot topic in the finance arena . What does it mean for you ?
A
holistic approach to ESG-linked funding can unlock additional funding benefits for businesses . Understanding the various elements in the ESG umbrella and the interplay between them , coupled with determining the right funding instrument and type of funding arrangement , appropriate metrics , reporting obligations and intervals is key to this and can require specialist insight from a number of advisors . Businesses should partner with experienced advisors to achieve these objectives .
To begin – let us define " ESG ". " ESG " is an umbrella term encompassing three broad spheres – environmental aspects , social causes and governance issues . These three spheres are often considered mutually exclusive , but this is frequently not the case , and they can each be much broader than they first appear .
A great practical example of the interlinked nature of ESG is a renewable energy project . There are obvious potential environmental benefits to the construction and operation of a renewable energy project . When you look closer , however , it is easy to see how the implementation of that project can have farreaching social implications for the immediate local community and broader society – job creation , contributing to relieving the energy crisis and income generation , to name a few – while the manner of implementation , quantifying and reporting on performance , as well as ensuring compliance with the relevant regulatory regimes falls firmly within the " governance " sphere .
Businesses tend to focus on the environmental aspects , as these are easiest to identify and quantify , but the social and governance aspects can be equally important levers when negotiating your funding arrangements . The interplay between these aspects is key to unlocking value in funding arrangements .
Forms of funding in the South African market In the South African market , we generally see two types of ESGlinked funding made available to corporate borrowers – sustainable financing and use of proceeds financing ( also sometimes known as green loans or social loans ). Here are a few high-level risks and benefits of each and when they might be suitable for your business :
Sustainable financing Sustainable financing is a type of funding that allows borrowers to measure their performance against a set of predetermined key performance indicators ( KPIs ). Depending on the level of performance achieved against those KPIs , the borrower can obtain a financial benefit , such as a margin reduction or access to additional funding for which that borrower may otherwise not be eligible . A failure to perform against one or more KPIs can sometimes also result in a margin ratchet , which was not the case in the early days of sustainable financing . Depending on the number of KPIs and level of performance with individual KPIs and as a whole , the margin ratchet or reduction may be structured on a tiered basis .
Naturally , this arrangement requires detailed and
Natasha Pather , partner at Webber Wentzel .
accurate information to be delivered timeously to and verified by the funders . Suitable KPIs are usually determined with reference to the nature and extent of the business of the borrower or its group , its operational requirements and what is achievable and sustainable , without compromising on the business ' s product .
This type of funding typically takes the form of a loan instrument , rather than a bond , commercial paper or other securities , as the number of funders is generally limited ( and thus the borrower is more easily able to manage these information requirements with a smaller pool of funders ). Depending on the nature of the business of the borrower , its creditworthiness and various other factors , other financial institutions may also not be able to participate in the instrument , which would limit uptake in the broader market .
Sustainable financing is typically a better fit for larger corporates who already have their own corporate social responsibility programmes geared towards one or more ESG objectives and have the relevant information and verification systems and relationships in place , as well as the requisite financial resources to implement these .
Funders may be willing to accept pre-existing KPIs determined by the borrower where it can be shown that adequate consideration and objective assessment has gone into determining these KPIs , however , they may wish to set their own KPI targets or verify that the proposed targets are sufficiently ambitious . In the UK and European markets , there appears to be an emerging trend of requiring more aggressive KPI targets , both upfront and year-onyear , to avoid allegations of greenwashing . The basis for these allegations within the funding space specifically seems to be that the funders ' intervention has not caused the " good behaviour " for which both these corporates and funders are being rewarded
Supplied by Webber Wentzel www . africanmining . co . za African Mining Publication African Mining African Mining • May 2024 • 31