African Mining August 2025 | Page 40

• INSIGHT
the Government allegedly adopts harmful measures against the company’ s investment and the company considers itself compelled to seek damages from an international tribunal.
I asked one of the speakers whether they take investment treaties into account when planning for a project abroad. Investment treaties contain substantive investment protection standards which protect the“ investments” of“ investors” from internationally wrongful state interference. If a state interferes with an investor’ s investment, that investor may be able to bring a claim against the state before an international tribunal. If successful, an investor may be able to recover substantial damages.
The answer to my question can be summarised as follows: another way must be found to resolve disputes with states rather than going to international arbitration. The respondent struggled to see why a dispute with an African Government would need to be taken to an international tribunal“ in London”( of course, disputes under investment treaties are not limited to being heard in London).
This answer was correct, but only on a surface level. Mining companies do not start a project just to have a dispute with the state; and many states also want to comply with their international legal obligations. When a dispute does arise, it is correct that discussion and diplomacy can and should be at the forefront of any resolution strategy.
But beneath the surface, there is a lot more to consider. At its simplest level, resolving a dispute based on an existing relationship requires two to tango. If one side isn’ t interested, an impasse will be reached quickly. Steps can be taken to mitigate the risk of this happening, but investors must never assume that the risk can be eliminated entirely.
Governments, and the people within them, change. Across the African continent, 18 national elections took place in the course of 2024. Many candidates successfully ran on promises of reform of the mining sector, to ensure that the state gets more of the benefits from its natural resources as compared to foreign investors.
It is an error to equate a positive relationship with a government with a conclusion that a project is impervious to resource nationalism. When a government announces a plan to withdraw mining permits, as the military junta of Burkina Faso did last year, mining companies would be well-advised not to assume that the government isn’ t referring to them. It could be.
Structuring an investment so that it benefits from the protections set out in an investment treaty isn’ t a declaration of war. And it isn’ t a suggestion to the government where a mining company operates that they aren’ t trusted. It is a legitimate and reasonable strategy to mitigate future political risk. It can be done at the outset of a project or during( provided that a dispute is not reasonably foreseeable). On many occasions, simply having a company incorporated in a state which has an investment treaty with the host state of one’ s investment in the ownership structure is enough to secure protection. Often this structuring exercise can be done in a way that complements corporate and tax considerations. In other words: the best advice is to fix one’ s roof while the sun is shining.
Equally, having an investment treaty in play doesn’ t mean that a mining company has to use it. And ideally it won’ t: either political
Investment treaties contain substantive investment protection standards which protect the‘ investments’ of‘ investors’ from internationally wrongful state interference.
risks won’ t manifest or, as was suggested in the answer to my question, a different way will be found. However, even if these different routes are explored, an available investment treaty will continue to provide an extra layer of support protecting the interests of a mining company and, crucially, its shareholders. But if one fails to structure their investment in order that an investment treaty is in play before a dispute becomes foreseeable, one loses this valuable route of last resort. If the worst happens, particularly if one lacks political capital as compared to larger players, it provides confidence and solace to shareholders that a route has been prepared that may provide them with some return on their investment.
Further, the availability of a potential investment treaty claim can be a valuable tool in negotiations with governments. The threat of a claim can( when appropriate) be used as a dispute avoidance tool, bringing governments to the negotiating table through the application of mandatory negotiation periods.
The current reality is that mining investors are turning more and more to investment treaties to resolve disputes with African States. While there may have been a suggestion at the London Indaba that investment arbitration shouldn’ t be used, the publicly available data tells us that it is being used. Nearly 20 % of all cases registered with the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes( ICSID – the main institution administering such disputes) related to mining concessions. So far in 2025, of the 29 cases registered with ICSID, six have related to mining concessions( i. e., around 20 %). Four of the six cases have been brought against African States( three against Niger and one against the DRC).
London Indaba demonstrated that political risk is high on the agenda for mining companies. Increased investment in Africa paired with a rising proliferation of protectionist policies and resource nationalism across the continent means that mining investors should look towards investment treaties as an option to ensure their investments are entitled to protection. •
About the author: Scott Macpherson is a senior associate and solicitor advocate in the Hogan Lovells International Arbitration team focusing on public international law and, in particular, dispute settlement under investment treaties. Based in London, he advises clients on international economic law, including sanctions, and acts for states, international organisations and businesses in international disputes. The views expressed in this article are his own and do not represent those of African Mining, incorporating Mining Mirror, Hogan Lovells or its clients.
Supplied by Scott Macpherson
38 • African Mining • August 2025 www. africanmining. co. za