INSIGHT •
INVESTMENT TREATIES – A GUARD AGAINST PROTECTIONIST POLICIES AND RESOURCE NATIONALISM?
By Scott Macpherson, a lawyer at Hogan Lovells based in London, UK
On 24 and 25 June 2025, the London Indaba returned for its third edition on“ investing in resources and mining in Africa”. Scott Macpherson, a lawyer at Hogan Lovells based in London, UK, attended on behalf of African Mining, incorporating Mining Mirror, and reports on some of the key discussions arising out of the conference.
Another panel session composed of leaders in copper mining revealed that there will be a growth in demand for copper of 53 % between 2025 and 2050, and that without investment in potential projects, a supply shortfall could be created.
Supplied by Resources 4 Africa
Peter Leon, partner and Africa chair, Herbert Smith Freehills; Ronak Gopaldas director Signal Risk; Calvin Bailey MBE MP, the UK’ s Trade Envoy to southern Africa; Michel van Hoey senior partner McKinsey & Company; Dr Ian Lange Coulter chair of Mineral Economics, Colorado School of Mines, US; Claude de Baissac CEO, Eunomix; Dr Lauren A. Johnston, associate professor, University of Sydney.
It seemed to me that it was no coincidence that the first panel discussion of the 3rd annual London Indaba was entitled“ Geopolitics: the new world order – what does it mean for mining?” Ronak Gopaldas, a director at Signal Risk, commented that diplomacy and the current world order is increasingly being governed by muscle and money. He is correct: political risk is more prevalent, and more obvious, than many other times in living memory.
But what does this mean for mining? As is well known, a series of coups in the Sahel region have led to disputes with certain governments( most notably Mali, Niger and Burkina Faso). More broadly, there is now significant uncertainty across the region about where projects stand with military-led governments. For example, in the days leading up to the London Indaba, Orano’ s Somair uranium mine project in Niger was nationalised by its military junta. Claude de Baissac, CEO of Eunomix, commented during the panel session that CEOs would have to assume as part of their role that of a company’ s“ chief geopolitical risk officer.” Now more than ever, mining companies investing abroad need to be alive and responsive to political risk, in particular resource nationalism.
The risks are clear, but the various panels also stressed the benefits of partnership with governments in implementing an effective project. The flip side for mining is the significant increase in demand for critical minerals and metals as part of the energy transition.
How, then, should mining companies and their investors seek to balance an increasingly more resource nationalistic approach by African governments with a substantial increase in demand?
A key message arising out of the London Indaba was relationship building: developing trust with governments is essential. Mark Cutifani, chair of Vale Base Metals, highlighted that a perception that may be felt by certain governments on the African continent is“ you don’ t trust us, and we don’ t trust you.” If an investor is perceived to be looking to make a“ quick buck,” their pockets will be picked. However, if there is proper relationship building and collaboration, there will be support. Cutifani commented that partnerships are key for Africa to be successful, and this involves mining companies and governments seeking to move forward together. He declared the next half century as belonging to Africa.
Similarly, Endeavour Mining chair Srinivasan Venkatakrishnan noted that mining is a long-term game. A natural corollary of the capital-intensive nature of mining, in particular its long-term profit horizons, is uncertainty. As Venkatakrishnan noted, this is not for the faint-hearted. His advice was that developing trust and partnership with host governments over time is critical for risk mitigation.
But what happens when those relationships break down? As an international arbitration lawyer focusing on disputes involving states, I regularly see examples where previously positive collaboration between a company and a government erodes,
How, then, should mining companies and their investors seek to balance an increasingly more resource nationalistic approach by African governments with a substantial increase in demand? www. africanmining. co. za African Mining Publication African Mining African Mining • August 2025 • 37