20 WESTERN PALLET
The pallet industry is currently navigating a complex and challenging environment. Inflation, rising costs, and unpredictable demand have created significant hurdles for companies across the sector. Chaille Brindley, publisher of Pallet Enterprise, Pallet Profile Weekly and Recycle Record, recently shared his insights on these challenges. He offered insights on how companies can survive and thrive in this volatile landscape. His observations touched on various critical issues, from pricing strategies to automation opportunities, labor management, and strategic planning. In this article, we explore Brindley’s analysis and his recommendations for pallet companies facing the current economic storm.
The Current State of the Pallet Market
Brindley opened his discussion by addressing the economic conditions impacting the pallet industry. Reflecting on the past year, he noted that the industry has been through "an interesting year," with many expecting economic relief that never materialized. "Inflation has been much stickier than a lot of people thought it was going to be," Brindley remarked, highlighting the broader economic challenges that have affected demand across the board.
For many in the pallet industry, the economic downturn feels like a recession, even if it isn’t officially labeled as one. Brindley pointed out, "Economists are saying we’re not in a recession, but anyone in the pallet industry would probably say we’ve been in a recession for at least the last year, year and a half." Demand has significantly declined from historic highs, with some companies reporting drops of 25-45% compared to previous years. This stark reality has dampened optimism for a strong finish to the year, with many looking towards 2025 for potential recovery.
Despite these challenges, Brindley emphasized the importance of resilience and strategic planning. He shared insights from industry veteran Steve Clark, CEO of PRO Pack, who predicts that "there’s not going to be a material change this year," but is hopeful for recovery in the "early second quarter of next year." This outlook suggests that companies need to prepare for continued difficulties in the near term while positioning themselves for growth as the market recovers.
Pricing Strategies: Holding the Line and Knowing When to Walk Away
One of the most pressing issues facing pallet companies is the pressure to reduce prices in response to declining demand. Brindley noted that many manufacturers, particularly in the used pallet market, have already lowered prices significantly but are now reaching a point where further reductions are unsustainable. He explained, "There’s a certain point where recyclers are telling me prices can’t go much lower and I’m going to stay in business."
This scenario underscores the importance of knowing your costs and being prepared to walk away from unprofitable business. Brindley advised, "When everyone’s pushing for lower, lower, lower, you have to know your cost, and you have to know when you’re like, 'I can go no more,' and stick to that." He acknowledged that this might mean losing some business in the short term, but maintained that it’s crucial to protect the long-term viability of the company.
Brindley also observed that companies who maintain high standards of quality and service often see customers return after experiencing lower quality from other suppliers. "If you’re a good supplier, they may go away for a period of time, but once they get really poor quality or service... don’t be surprised if they beat on your door again," he said. This suggests that maintaining a firm stance on pricing, even in tough times, can ultimately pay off.
The Role of Automation: A Critical Opportunity
In the face of rising costs and labor shortages, automation presents a significant opportunity for pallet companies to improve efficiency and reduce dependency on manual labor. Brindley emphasized the importance of automation, noting that while some companies may be hesitant to invest in new technology during uncertain times, this could be the ideal moment to do so. "If you don’t spend on the right thing, you may not be ready for when it does come back," he warned.
One area where Brindley sees significant potential for automation is in the assembly of wood packaging, which has traditionally been a highly manual process. He noted the growing interest in robotic systems that can automate these tasks, thereby reducing labor costs and improving consistency. "You’re eventually going to see, hopefully, someone’s going to be able to develop an automated repair system where a robot or advanced system is able to do everything," Brindley predicted. While fully automated systems are not yet widespread in the industry, the ongoing development of such technologies could revolutionize the way pallet companies operate in the near future.
Managing Labor: Balancing Costs and Retention
Labor management has become increasingly challenging as wages have risen significantly in recent years. Brindley pointed out that wage increases of "between 23 and 47%" have been observed across various roles in the industry, making it difficult for companies to maintain profitability without careful cost management. However, he emphasized that cutting wages is not a viable option for most companies, as it could damage their reputation as an employer and make it harder to attract and retain top talent.
Instead, Brindley suggested that companies focus on retaining high-performing employees while cutting hours or positions that are less critical. He also highlighted the importance of training and development programs to maximize the efficiency of the existing workforce. "You may be trying to do more to get more out of employees, but those higher wages are kind of baked in the cake," he said, indicating that companies need to find ways to make the most of their labor investment.
In addition to managing labor costs, Brindley noted that companies should be proactive in addressing potential safety concerns and worker satisfaction. He advised looking for areas where improvements can be made to reduce workers' compensation claims and enhance the overall working environment. This could include upgrading equipment, improving processes, or addressing any machines that
Cont'd on Page 22
mployees are reluctant to work with due to safety concerns.Co
Diversification and Specialization: Exploring New Markets
Brindley also discussed the importance of diversification and specialization as strategies for growth, particularly in the current economic climate. He observed that some pallet companies have found success by expanding into specialty packaging, custom crates, and other niche markets. These areas often offer higher margins and less price competition than standard pallet production, making them attractive options for companies looking to diversify their revenue streams.
For companies interested in exploring these opportunities, Brindley recommended investing in training and resources to develop the necessary expertise. He mentioned a short course offered by Virginia Tech on designing crates and specialty packaging, which has been highly popular and could provide valuable knowledge for companies looking to diversify. "If this is something that you’re like, 'I’m not really quite sure how to calculate these prices, I’m not really sure will this be the optimum design,' how can I design it so it really does well," he suggested attending the course to gain the skills needed to enter this market.
Brindley also emphasized the importance of understanding local market conditions and identifying unmet needs in the region. Whether it’s agricultural containers, medical product packaging, or custom solutions for industrial equipment, there are likely opportunities for growth in areas outside of traditional pallet production. "There’s got to be some specialty packaging in your area, and maybe it’s not being serviced well enough," he noted.
Strategic Planning: Preparing for the Future
As the industry looks ahead to 2025 and beyond, Brindley stressed the importance of strategic planning and investment. While the current economic conditions may be challenging, they also present an opportunity for companies to evaluate their operations, identify areas for improvement, and position themselves for future success. "This is the time where people either get good or they get gone," he remarked, underscoring the urgency of making smart business decisions.
One critical area of focus should be developing a robust lumber strategy. With lumber prices fluctuating and supply chains disrupted, companies need to ensure they have reliable sources of material and a clear plan for managing costs. Brindley also suggested that companies consider investing in new technology and equipment that can improve efficiency and reduce waste. "If you have an area that you really want to automate, start talking to people, go out there, see what you can find, and you may be the one who comes up with that solution," he advised.
Brindley also highlighted the potential for automation in areas beyond traditional pallet production, such as automated guided vehicles (AGVs) and multi-sort lines for odd-sized pallets. These technologies, while still in the early stages of adoption in the U.S., have been proven in Europe and could offer significant benefits for companies willing to invest in them. "Your next forklift may not need a driver," he noted, suggesting that companies explore the possibilities of AGVs for material handling and pallet sorting.
Summary: Key Takeaways from Chaille Brindley
Chaille Brindley’s insights into the current state of the pallet market provide a comprehensive guide for companies looking to navigate these challenging times. Despite the economic difficulties, there are clear strategies that companies can employ to maintain profitability and position themselves for future growth.
First and foremost, Brindley emphasizes the importance of knowing your costs and being prepared to walk away from unprofitable business. In a market where price competition is fierce, maintaining a firm stance on pricing is crucial for long-term success.
Automation presents a significant opportunity for improving efficiency and reducing labor costs. While some companies may be hesitant to invest in new technology during uncertain times, Brindley argues that this could be the ideal moment to do so, particularly in areas like wood packaging assembly where automation has the potential to transform traditionally manual processes.
Managing labor effectively is also critical, and companies should focus on retaining high-performing employees, investing in training and development, and addressing any safety concerns or inefficiencies in their operations. Diversification into specialty packaging and other niche markets can provide new revenue streams and reduce reliance on standard pallet production.
Finally, strategic planning and investment in technology, equipment, and lumber sourcing will be essential for companies looking to position themselves for success in the coming years.
Navigating the Pallet Market in Uncertain Times: Insights from Chaille Brindley