Vermont Bar Journal, Vol. 40, No. 2 - Page 34

by Erin Jacobsen , Esq .

THE CHILDREN ’ S CORNER

Looking Out for Immigrant Children : What State Court Judges , Family Law Attorneys , and Child Advocates Should Know About Special Immigrant Juvenile Status

Approximately one-quarter of children in the U . S . are children of foreign-born parents . 1 In Vermont , the percentage is smaller , approximately 6 %— or about 7,000 children total — but if current immigration and population trends continue , that number will continue to rise . 2 Of course , these statistics matter little to the individual child , for whom the stakes can be incredibly high . Many immigrant children , especially recent arrivals , are fleeing violence , torture , or abuse in their countries of origin . Once in the U . S ., achieving permanent legal status is paramount to their survival . One of the chief ways abused immigrant children can legalize their status , and thereby find safety and stability , is through the Special Immigrant Juvenile ( SIJ ) program . It is therefore crucial that those working with juveniles understand the SIJ program and how to identify eligible youth .
WHO ARE “ SPECIAL IMMIGRANT JUVENILES ?” -- TWO CASE STUDIES : 3
Roberto At the age of 14 , Roberto ’ s father tried to force him to join his violent drug-trafficking gang in Mexico . Roberto resisted , and for this , his father beat him severely . When Roberto ’ s mother tried to intervene , she too was beaten . Roberto ’ s father swore that if Roberto did not join the gang , both Roberto and his mother would be killed . Roberto and his mother decided to flee to the United States . They snuck across the Rio Grande , but were apprehended at the border . After being held in immigration detention for several weeks , they were released and made their way to Vermont to join Roberto ’ s uncle working on a farm . After living in Vermont for a couple of years , Roberto , now 16 , wants to figure out if he can get his green card so he can stay in the U . S . and go to college .
Fatou
Fatou , age 15 , came to the United Sates from Mali to visit her aunt and cousins for the summer . As the end of her trip neared , she begged her aunt to let her stay , because upon her return home , she would be forced to enter into an arranged marriage . Fatou explained to her aunt that she just wanted to stay in school and eventually go to college . She had never met the man she was to marry . She only knew that he had paid a steep price for her and that he was 40 years her senior . She would be his fourth wife and as the youngest , Fatou would be the primary domestic servant and would be expected to soon bear children . She would face a lifetime of domestic servitude . After Fatou continually begged her aunt to let her stay in Vermont , Fatou ’ s aunt wants to know if Fatou can do this legally .
One way that both Roberto and Fatou could stay in the U . S . legally is by obtaining Special Immigrant Juvenile status . A Special Immigrant Juvenile is :
• an unmarried person under the age of twenty-one who is in the United States ;
• who has been declared dependent by a juvenile court in the U . S , or who has been placed in the custody of an agency or an individual by a state or juvenile court ;
• whose reunification with one or both parents is not viable due to abuse , neglect , abandonment or a similar basis found in state law ; and
• for whom it has been determined in a judicial or administrative proceeding that it is not in the child ’ s best interest to be returned to her / his country of origin . 4
In order for Roberto and Fatou to obtain the status of Special Immigrant Juveniles , they must file petitions with the United States Immigration and Citizenship Services , or USCIS . However , as indicated by the above definition , SIJ cases commence not at USCIS , but in a state “ juvenile court .”
STATE COURTS AND “ SPECIAL FINDINGS ”
The SIJ statutory scheme is a unique federal-state process that directs applicants to first obtain “ special findings ” from their state juvenile court and to then submit those findings with their petition to USCIS . Under this scheme , a “ juvenile court ” is defined as “ any court located in the United States having jurisdiction under State law to make judicial determinations about the custody and care of juveniles .” 5 Therefore , in Vermont , Roberto could request findings from the Family Division in the context of a divorce-related , parentage or other family proceeding filed by his mom , and Fatou could request findings from the Probate Division in the context of a guardianship petition filed by her aunt .
The requisite special findings mirror the definition of a Special Immigrant Juvenile .
For example , in Roberto ’ s case , Roberto could file a motion requesting that in addition to the order granting full parental rights and responsibilities to his mother , the Court also issue the following special findings :
1 . The court has placed Roberto in the full physical and legal custody of his mother ;
2 . Roberto ’ s reunification with his father is not viable due to abuse and neglect ;
3 . It is not in Roberto ’ s best interest to be returned to Mexico .
It is important to note that mere physical custody does not constitute the kind of legal custody required by the agency in order to qualify for SIJ status . Therefore , Roberto ’ s mother would have to obtain both physical and legal rights and responsibilities . It is also essential that in the court filings , Roberto reference not only the legal framework of the SIJ program , but also other reasons for requesting the custody determination . This is because the USCIS has rejected SIJ petitions in cases where it has determined that a guardianship or a custody order was sought solely so the child could receive an immigration benefit .
Finally , it is crucial that the special findings be specific to Roberto . USCIS has rejected petitions that included boiler-plate findings lacking in specificity to the child . Findings that do not reference such details as the child ’ s name , the specific allegations of wrongdoing by the parent ( rather than a vague , all-inclusive reference to “ abuse , abandonment , and / or neglect ”), or the name of the country of origin , could be looked at with skepticism . Furthermore , and whenever possible , courts should also issue a more detailed order that explains how the specific facts of the case indicate abuse , abandonment , and / or neglect under Vermont law and why it is not in the
34 THE VERMONT BAR JOURNAL • SUMMER 2016 www . vtbar . org
by Erin Jacobsen, Esq. THE CHILDREN’S CORNER Looking Out for Immigrant Children: What State Court Judges, Family Law Attorneys, and Child Advocates Should Know About Special Immigrant Juvenile Status Approximately one-quarter of children in the U.S. are children of foreign-born parents.1 In Vermont, the percentage is smaller, approximately 6%—or about 7,000 children total—but if current immigration and population trends continue, that number will continue to rise.2 Of course, these statistics matter little H[]YX[[ ܈HHZ\[H[ܙYXHY X[H[[ZYܘ[[[\XX[HX[\][\HYZ[[[Kܝ\K܂X\H[Z\[Y\وܚY[ۘH[HKˋXY][\X[[Y[]\š\\[[[Z\\][ ۙHوBYY^\X\Y[[ZYܘ[[[[Y[^HZ\]\[\XH[Y]H[X[]K\YHXX[[[ZYܘ[][[H RHܘ[K]\\YܙHܝXX[]Hܚ[]][[\[\[HRܘ[H[Y[YH[YXH[] TH8'PPSSSRQԐSUSST'H KHTHQQTΌ‚ؙ\]HYHو M ؙ\&\]\YYܘH[H[\[[Y]YX[[[Y^Xˈؙ\\\Y [܈\\]\X][H]\[K[ؙ\&\[\YY[\[KH\X][ؙ\&\]\ܙB]Yؙ\Y[H[ؙ\[\[\[H[Y ؙ\[\[\XYYYHH[]Y]\ˈ^H۝XXܛB[ܘ[K]\H\Z[Y]Bܙ\Y\Z[[[[[ZYܘ][ۈ][[ۈ܈]\[YZ^H\H[X\Y[XYHZ\^H\[۝š[ؙ\&\[Hܚ[ۈH\KY\][[\[۝܈H\HوYX\ؙ\ M[Y\H]YB[]\ܙY[\H[^H[BKˈ[YK]B]KYH MK[YHH[]Y]\™HX[H\]\][[\[܂H[[Y\\H[و\\X\Y HYY\][]\^KX]\H\ۈ\]\YKH[BܘY[\[[\[YX\XYK]H^Z[Y\][]H\[Y^H[[][X[HYKHY]\Y]HX[B\X\KHۛHۙ]]HYZYHY\XH܈\[]H\ YX\\[[܋H[H\\YH[\H[[\ ]H[BH[X\HY\X\[[[B^XYۈX\[[H[XHHY][YHوY\X\]YKY\]H۝[X[HYY\][]\^H[\[۝ ]x&\][[šۛY]H[\Y[KۙH^H]ؙ\[]B[^H[HKˈY[H\H؝Z[[”XX[[[ZYܘ[][[H]\ˈHXX[[[ZYܘ[][[H\΂([[X\YY\ۈ[\HYBو[K[ۙH\[H[]Y]\¸(\Y[X\Y\[[HH][[H\[HK܈š\Y[XY[H\Hو[Y[H܈[[]YX[HH]H܂][[H\¸(H][YX][ۈ]ۙH܈\[\XXHYHX\KYX X[ۛY[܈H[Z[\\\™[[]H][(܈H]\Y[]\Z[Y[BYXX[܈YZ[\]]HYY[]]\[H[8&\\[\\H]\Y\\[BوܚY[[ܙ\܈ؙ\[]H؝Z[H]\وXX[[[ZYܘ[][[\^H]\[H]][ۜ]H[]Y]\[[ZYܘ][ۈ[]^[\\X\܈TTˈ]\\[X]YHBXݙHY[][ۋR\\[Y[H]TT][H]H8'][[H\ 'BUHTS'PPSSS'BHR]]ܞH[YH\H[\]YHY\[ \]H\]\X\X[\؝Z[8'XX[[['HHZ\]H][[H\[[XZ]H[[]Z\]][ۈTT˂[\\[YKH8'][[H\8'H\Y[Y\8'[H\]Y[H[]Y]\][\\X[ۈ[\]H]XZHYXX[]\Z[][ۜX]B\H[\Hو][[\˸'MH\YܙKHTSӕTTS8(SSQT M[\[۝ ؙ\[\]Y\[[™HH[Z[H]\[ۈ[H۝^قH]ܘK\[]Y \[YH܈\[Z[HYY[[YH\[]B[\]Y\[[HHؘ]H]\[ۈ[H۝^وHX\X[\]][ۈ[YH\][ H\]Z\]HXX[[[Z\܈BY[][ۈوHXX[[[ZYܘ[][[K܈^[\K[ؙ\&\\Kؙ\[[HH[[ۈ\]Y\[][Y][ۈHܙ\ܘ[[[\[[Y[\ۜX[]Y\\[\H\[\YHH[XX[[[΂KH\\XYؙ\[B[\X[[Y[\Hو\›[\Œؙ\&\][YX][ۈ]\]\\XXHYHX\H[YXŒˈ]\[ؙ\&\\[\\˜H]\YY^X˂]\[\ܝ[H]Y\H\X[\H\ۜ]]HH[قY[\H\]Z\YHHY[H[ܙ\]X[YH܈R]\ˈ\YܙKؙ\&\[\[]H؝Z[\X[[Y[Y[\ۜX[]Y\ˈ]\[\[X[][H\[[ؙ\Y\[HۛHHY[[Y]ܚوHRܘ[K][›\X\ۜ܈\]Y\[H\B]\Z[][ۋ\\X]\HHTTš\ZXYR]][ۜ[\\\B]\]\Z[Y]HX\X[\܂H\Hܙ\\Y[HB[[XZ]H[[[ZYܘ][ۈ[Y] [[K]\ܝXX[]HXX[[[HXYXؙ\ˈTT\ZXY]][ۜ][YY[\\]B[[X[[XYX]HH[ [[]Y\[HX]Z[\H[8&\KHXYX[Y][ۜوܛۙ[HH\[ ]\[HYYK[ Z[\]HY\[H¸'X\KX[ۛY[ [ ܈YX8'JK܈HHوH[HوܚY[[HY]]\X\K\\[ܙK[[]\XK\[[š\YHH[ܙH]Z[Yܙ\]^Z[šHXYXXوH\H[X]BX\KX[ۛY[ [ ܈YX[\\[۝][H]\[B˝\ܙ‚