Existing regulations on commercial sterilizers , as well as other facilities that manufacture or use ethylene oxide , do not account for the EPA ’ s latest research on the chemical that shows it is far more toxic than the agency knew .
In 2016 , the agency concluded that ethylene oxide was 30 times more carcinogenic than previously thought for people who continuously inhale it as adults and 50 times more carcinogenic for those who are exposed since birth . The conclusion fueled a backlash from the chemical and sterilizer industries , which say that the EPA ’ s findings are deeply flawed . They have made it clear they plan to fight the EPA ’ s forthcoming regulatory proposals .
The EPA has known since at least 2018 that some of the communities it identified on Wednesday are at risk from ethylene oxide pollution and has even directed regional offices to hold public meetings . Those occurred in many places ; in some more affluent and white communities , residents used the information to pressure elected officials to sue and even shutter sterilizer plants and enact stricter regulations of the chemical at the state level .
The EPA played catch-up last year , holding meetings in several additional communities , though it left out others . One of those communities was Laredo , a city of 260,000 on the Texas-Mexico border .
Last year , an unprecedented analysis of five years of industry data by ProPublica and The Texas Tribune found that a 38-year-old commercial sterilizer located in close proximity to an elementary school in Laredo was the most toxic facility of its kind in the country . Yet none of the more than 100 residents contacted by reporters , including local officials , were aware of the risk ; all but one said they didn ’ t even know the plant existed .
The EPA told ProPublica and the Tribune last year that it was holding off on public engagement in certain communities while it gathered more recent emissions data from each of the nearly 100 commercial sterilizers that it regulates . This data collection is a key step in the agency ’ s work to craft updated regulations of the facilities .
The agency ’ s analysis of that data served as the basis of Wednesday ’ s announcement . It found that ethylene oxide emissions from 23 sterilizers across the country created an excess cancer risk for nearby residents of at least 1 in 10,000 . That means that if 10,000 people are exposed to that amount of ethylene oxide over their lifetimes , at least one of them would likely develop cancer as a result of the exposure . ( That ’ s in addition to any cancer risk caused by factors like lifestyle and genetics .) The EPA stressed that the amount of ethylene oxide the facilities are emitting is not high enough to pose short-term health risks .
The Laredo facility , owned by Midwest Sterilization Corporation , was one of those 23 . So was the company ’ s other sterilizer plant in Missouri , which the ProPublica / Tribune analysis found to be the second-most toxic sterilizer plant in the country . Midwest , the country ’ s largest privately owned contract ethylene oxide sterilizer , didn ’ t respond to a request for comment .
Its Missouri facility moved to reduce ethylene oxide emissions after the EPA identified it as high-risk in 2018 , triggering the agency ’ s regional office to contact the facility and meet with local leaders . Yet its ethylene oxide emissions remained high enough for it to make the EPA ’ s list of highrisk facilities .
In a news release Wednesday , the EPA noted that “ medical sterilization is a critical function that ensures a safe supply of medical devices for patients and hospitals ” and that it is “ committed to addressing the pollution concerns associated with EtO in a comprehensive way that ensures facilities can operate safely in communities while also providing sterilized medical supplies .”
According to the EPA ’ s webpage detailing cancer risk at the Laredo facility , the agency will hold a community meeting in that city on Sept . 15 .
Last year , Laredo ’ s lone environmental group , which first learned about the Midwest facility from ProPublica and the Tribune , spearheaded the formation of a clean air coalition that has pushed for emissions reductions and worked to inform residents of the risks associated with ethylene oxide exposure .
The group , the Rio Grande International Study Center , urged the EPA on Wednesday “ to go beyond informing the public , and require immediate third-party fence-line air monitoring in neighborhoods and schools that are most impacted by Midwest .”
“ Laredo has been a sacrifice zone for long enough ,” said Sheila Serna , the group ’ s new climate science and policy director , who previously investigated a serious complaint against the Midwest facility while working as an inspector for Texas ’ environmental agency . “ We demand that our voices be heard and that any and all actions be taken to protect the most vulnerable in our community , which means phasing out the emissions of this highly dangerous and carcinogenic air toxin .”
State Study Finds High Cancer Rates In Laredo
On July 19 , the Texas Department of State Health Services published the results of a cancer cluster study requested earlier this year by the Laredo health department . ( The state health department only conducts cluster studies by request .)
The study examined rates of four different types of cancer that have been linked to ethylene oxide exposure in three different census tracts nearest the Midwest plant , focusing on diagnoses from 2006 to 2019 .
It found that rates of one type of cancer associated with ethylene oxide exposure , extranodal non-Hodgkin lymphoma , were “ significantly greater than expected ” given the population . It also noted higher-than-expected numbers of cases of breast cancer and nodal non-Hodgkin lymphoma , which have also been linked with the chemical , though not at rates that are statistically significant . None of the rates were high enough to trigger an investigation into possible causes , a state health department spokesperson said .
38 x The Trial Lawyer