March 2026 | The New Jersey Police Chief Magazine 26
SCOTUS Affirms Standard for Emergency-Aid Entry into the Home in Case v. Montana
Eric Daigle, Esq.
The Fourth Amendment draws its sharpest line at the front door of a home, but that line is often blurred as modern policing increasingly intersects with mental health crisis response and the need to render emergency aid.
On January 14, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States addressed this intersection in Case v. Montana, 607 U. S. ____( 2026), where the high Court considered“ whether law enforcement may enter a home without a search warrant based on less than probable cause that an emergency is occurring, or, whether the emergency-aid exception requires that officers have probable cause for such intrusion, as they typically would when investigating a crime.”
The unanimous opinion leaves no space for uncertainty, as the Court reinforced a long-standing principle that it has held before:“ Officers may enter if, but only if, they have an‘ objectively reasonable basis for believing’ that an occupant faces serious danger.” Brigham City, 547 U. S., at 400.
Summary of Facts In September 2021, William Case’ s ex-girlfriend, J. H., called police after a troubling phone conversation between the couple. During that call, Case threatened suicide, and J. H. believed he was intoxicated because of his erratic behavior. She became even more alarmed when he mentioned getting“ a note or something like that” before committing suicide. J. H. warned Case that she would call and report this information to police, to which Case responded by threatening to harm any officers who came to his home. According to J. H., the phone call ended with a“ pop” followed by silence, which J. H. believed resembled the sound of a gunshot. Unable to get Case to verbally respond to her, J. H. contacted the police and drove to his residence.
When law enforcement officers arrived, they attempted to contact Case by knocking and announcing their presence and by calling his name through an open window but received no response. Through the windows of the residence, officers observed empty beer cans, an empty handgun holster, and a notepad that they believed contained a suicide note. Prior to responding to this call, officers had notice of Case’ s history of alcohol abuse, mental health issues, and previous suicide threats, including a prior suicide-by-cop attempt. Despite the urgency of the situation, officers did not immediately force entry, and instead, remained on scene for approximately forty minutes before entering the home.
At the time officers made warrantless entry into Case’ s residence, they advanced with weapons drawn due to J. H.’ s report that Case had threatened to harm any officers who came to his home. While clearing the residence, a Sergeant discovered Case in an upstairs bedroom closet. When Case suddenly opened the closet curtain, the Sergeant saw what he believed to be a dark object positioned at Case’ s waist, prompting the sergeant to discharge a single shot into Case’ s abdomen. A handgun was later recovered in a laundry hamper next to where Case fell.
Continued on page 40