NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
LEADERSHIP LESSON # 1: MAINTAIN COMPOSURE DURING CRISIS
At Shiloh, after a disastrous first day of combat left Union forces battered and pushed toward the Tennessee River, many officers believed defeat was imminent. Yet Grant remained calm. When General Sherman came to Grant under his tree in the rain, intending to raise the possibility of retreat, he instead blurted out that they had experienced“ the devil’ s own day.” Grant simply responded,“ Yes, lick’ em to-morrow, though.”¹
That response reflected more than optimism. It demonstrated emotional discipline. While others focused on losses already sustained, Grant focused on actions that could still influence the outcome.
Jean Edward Smith observes that Grant possessed an unusual ability to remain clear-headed during moments of crisis.² Ronald White similarly notes that adversity seemed to sharpen rather than diminish Grant’ s effectiveness.³
For modern police leaders, the lesson is straightforward: emotional stability is a leadership force multiplier. Organizational confidence often mirrors executive confidence. When leaders panic, organizations panic. When leaders remain composed, organizations retain the capacity to solve problems.
Grant understood that calmness is contagious.
Every leader eventually faces moments when circumstances appear to spiral out of control. During such periods, followers often look less for answers than for reassurance.
Grant’ s greatest leadership strength may have been his emotional steadiness.
Page 34