The NJ Police Chief Magazine - Volume 32, Number 11 | Page 24

NEW JERSEY POLICE CHIEF MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 2026
RETIRED MEMBER SPOTLIGHT

From the Badge to the Boardroom

Chief John Bouthillette on Leadership, Identity, and Life After Command
South River Police Department( Ret.)
NJSACOP is spotlighting retired police chiefs who have moved on to successful careers in other professions. In this edition, we highlight Chief John Bouthillette.
Chief John Bouthillette served in the South River Police Department for 26 years. He is currently Deputy Director, Center for Law Enforcement Safety and Wellness at the Institute for Intergovernmental Research. He is also an adjunct faculty member of the University of Virginia, School of Continuing Education and Professional Studies and a member of the advisory board for the University of Virginia, Center for Public Safety and Justice.
I’ m most proud of the full arc of my career, from patrolman all the way to chief. I was able to show up for people in their hardest moments, fight for the truth, and guide our department to being an NJSACOP accredited agency.
What drew you to your current career?
I was drawn to my current career because my commitment to effective and compassionate law enforcement didn’ t stop when I retired. My job lets me continue protecting officers, strengthening their resilience, and being part of the solution for a profession that shaped my entire life.
What advice would you give to police chiefs on the brink of retirement who are considering future career paths?
Don’ t panic, plan. Retirement isn’ t a free fall; it’ s a transition. The more intentional you are, the stronger and more secure your next chapter will be. Get clear about what you want your life to look like— not a rigid blueprint, but a direction and a purpose that still matters when the badge comes off.
“ Retirement isn’ t a free fall; it’ s a transition.”
Chief John Bouthillette( Ret.), South River Police Department
Chief John Bouthillette( Ret.), South River Police Department.
What job skills did you develop as a police chief that you now use in your career?
I learned to lead through pressure, build trust, elevate people, and turn experience into action during my years as a police chief, and these are skills I use each day in my current position.
What are you most proud of from your years of police work?
What was the most challenging part of transitioning from law enforcement to your current career?
The most challenging part of transitioning from law enforcement to my current career was confronting the loss of identity, authority, and purpose that had defined my entire adult life. Almost overnight, you become just another person in a world that doesn’ t know your rank or your reputation. That reality hits harder than most chiefs expect.
What mindset shifts were necessary for you to succeed outside of policing?
I had to shift from command-driven leadership to influencedriven leadership. In law enforcement, decisions are immediate, direct, and often non-negotiable. In the private sector, you must let go of the instinct to take charge and instead learn to guide, support, and adapt.
■
Page 22