The Launceston Link SPRING 2015 | Page 27

Turbines For or Against? Readers were invited to write in and send their views on wind turbines on the inclusion of an article in the last issue on this subject. A number of you thought that energy produced by renewable technology must be a good thing, because fossil fuels are:A.- likely to run out the future, if not in our lifetime then at some point. B.- the cause of Co2 gases or ‘Greenhouse Gases’ in the Earth’s atmosphere, thought by some to be a contributory cause of so-called ‘global warming’. Against this were opinions that the evidence of ‘global warming’ is pretty shaky, particularly that in the last 20 years careful monitoring has shown no increase in the Earth’s temperature, and furthermore that so-called ‘Greenhouse Gases’ do not appear to have had any deleterious effect. The visual impact of turbines has aroused much controversy; particularly as Cornwall now has far more of these in evidence than other areas, and it is felt that the Cornish landscape has suffered as a result. Subsidies paid to encourage wind turbine building have to be paid for by consumers. On average, a wind farm earns roughly one third when paid to switch off than when producing electricity for sale to the National Grid. Recent statistics Under the heading – “Wind Power peters out as demand peaks”, it was reported in “The Daily Telegraph” that in the recent cold snap wind power produced only one percent of the demand, at peak, and less than that at other times. In the same newspaper, under ‘Business Comment’, the conclusion was that wind turbines cannot be relied on for electricity generation; although astronomical sums of money have been expended on subsidies. These recorded figures are valid and incontestable, and not produced to support ‘for’ or ‘against’ viewpoints. Conclusions Are turbines viable? Are they simply an unnecessary blight on the Cornish countryside? Are other ‘clean’ methods of energy generation preferable? This is a real and topical question for debate. Certainly solar power is proving a big success under the right conditions; in other words where, quite simply, there is enough sunshine. All of us who have spent holidays in sunny climes cannot have failed to notice the proliferation of solar devices to provide hot water, and in many cases electricity as well. Some remarkable scientific advances by Israeli inventors amongst others may well bring about generation methods hitherto unthought of. In this country the introduction of geothermal energy has great promise, with the great advantage of having minimal visual impact on the countryside. Finally We thank all who have taken the trouble to express their opinions to us. It is not our policy to weigh in on this debate with personal opinions on one side or the other, but simply to allow views to be put by our readers on both sides of the question. I Ё