A . Calhoun et al .: J Extra Corpor Technol 2025 , 57 , 24 – 31 27
Table 1 . ( Continued ) Author , Publication Date , |
Hemodynamic indications |
Echocardiographic indications |
Recommended LV unloading |
Type , Ref # |
|
|
|
Alkhouli et al ., 2016 , CS , [ 29 ] |
PCWP > 18 , “ High Left Atrial |
No Echocardiographic indications |
Surgical Vent , AS , TVMA |
|
Pressure ” |
were noted |
|
Au et al ., 2023 , RR , [ 30 ] |
No Hemodynamic Criteria |
LVEF < 25 % |
IABP , TVMA |
|
Described |
|
|
Eliet et al ., 2018 , RR , [ 31 ] |
ALPP < 10 |
No AV opening , heavy Echo |
TVMA |
|
|
Smoke in LV , LVOT VTI < 5 cm |
|
Gaudard et al ., 2015 , RR , [ 32 ] |
No Hemodynamic Criteria |
Acute LV dilation / Echo Smoke in |
TVMA |
|
Described |
LV / LA |
|
Hu et al ., 2016 , CS , [ 33 ] |
Decreased ALPP |
LV Blood Stasis |
IABP |
Karatolios et al ., 2016 , RR , [ 34 ] |
No Hemodynamic Criteria |
Echo Smoke in LV , LV Dilation , |
TVMA |
|
Described |
Low or No AV opening |
|
Kim et al ., 2021 RR , [ 35 ] |
ALPP < 10 |
No Echocardiographic indications |
TVMA |
|
|
were noted |
|
Lüsebrink et al ., 2020 RA , [ 36 ] |
Lack of ALPP |
Low or No AV opening , LVOT |
TVMA |
|
|
VTI < 10 cm , LV Blood Stasis , Increased LV Dimensions from Previous Exam , severe AR |
|
Pappalardo et al ., 2017 , RR , |
No Hemodynamic Criteria |
Stone Heart , LV Thrombus , |
TVMA |
[ 37 ] |
Described |
significant AR |
|
Rali et al ., 2022 , RA , [ 38 ] |
elevated PCWP , low or absent |
No AV opening |
IABP , TVMA , AS |
|
ALPP |
|
|
Saeed et al ., 2023 , RA , [ 39 ] |
ALPP < 15 , PCWP > 30 , PAD > 25 |
LV / Ao Root Thrombus , No AV opening |
IABP , TVMA , AS , TSLAV , LV Vent |
Thresholds for defining LVD and indications and triggers for LV mechanical unloading were tabulated according to categories of clinical ( or radiographic ), hemodynamic , and ECHO findings or parameters . Clinical and radiologic criteria for LVD were placed within the same category for simplicity and to be succinct . Hemodynamic manifestations of LVD were defined as abnormalities with invasive filling pressures and ALPP monitoring . All pressures are reported in mmHg . ECHO criteria for LVD included cardiac ultrasound or pulmonary findings suggestive of pulmonary edema . Several papers stratified their indications and treatments as mild , moderate , and severe . Where applicable this has been included . ALPP : Arterial Line Pulse Pressure ; AV : Aortic Valve ; AS : Atrial Septostomy ; CS : Case Series ; CVP : Central Venous Pressure ; Ed : Editorial ; GD : Guideline Document ; IABP : Intra Aortic Balloon Pump ; IVC : Inferior Vena Cava ; LA : Left Atrium ; LV : Left Ventricle ; LVD : Left Ventricular Distension ; LVOT VTI : Left Ventricular Outflow Tract Velocity Time Integral ; PA : Pulmonary Artery ; PAC : Pulmonary Artery Catheter ; PAD : Pulmonary Artery Diastolic ; PCWP : Pulmonary Capillary Wedge Pressure ; RA : Review Article ; RR : Retrospective Review ; RT : Randomized Trial ; TSLAV : Transeptal Left Atrial Vent .
congestion index were also described . Hemodynamic criteria for LVD and the need for mechanical unloading were described in numerous studies . Of quantifiable criteria , two articles used PCWP above 18 mmHg , one above 20 mmHg , one above 30 mmHg , and three used a graded scale of PCWP . Four articles used a PAD of 25 mmHg . Three articles used an ALPP below 15 mmHg , three below 10 mmHg , and one used a graded scale .
While these criteria are helpful in the diagnosis of LVD and in establishing thresholds for mechanical LV unloading , their advantages and disadvantages must be highlighted . In what follows , we will describe the benefits and limitations of various surveillance methods for LVD .
Review of indicators of LV distension-clinical , radiographic , hemodynamic , and echocardiographic
The most frequently used clinical indicators of LVD are significant pulmonary edema as evidenced by frothy secretions from the endotracheal tube , pulmonary hemorrhage , or ventricular arrhythmias [ 2 , 3 , 40 ]. These signs are often regarded as emergent indications for mechanical LV unloading and may indicate irreversible damage to cardiac muscle [ 1 ]. It is likely that the presence of clinical signs of LVD makes myocardial recovery less likely to occur . Thus , other subclinical indications of LVD should be sought for earlier detection to avoid irreversible heart failure and the subsequent need for durable left ventricular assist device placement or heart transplant .
Radiographic ( chest films or chest computed tomography ) indications of LVD are used to assess for the presence of pulmonary congestion [ 5 ]. These findings usually precede the clinical indicators of LVD and are often easily obtained for patients in a multitude of settings . Though helpful , these findings suggest a parenchymal abnormality and may represent a delayed finding in patients with LVD or could suggest a different pathology such as acute respiratory distress syndrome or aspiration pneumonitis .
Hemodynamic indications of LVD include elevated CVP , elevated PAC pressures ( including pulmonary diastolic pressure ), and PCWP [ 1 , 2 , 5 ]. Additionally , ALPP is an important