152 M . Szpytma et al .: J Extra Corpor Technol 2024 , 56 , 149 – 158
Table 1 . Patient demographics for aortic cross-clamp time greater than 90 min .
Characteristic |
HKB |
DNC |
p-value |
N |
194 |
194 |
|
Age |
64 ( 52 , 72 ) |
64 ( 49 , 73 ) |
0.84 |
Male |
135 ( 70 %) |
131 ( 68 %) |
0.66 |
Euroscore II |
2 ( 1 , 4 ) |
2 ( 1 , 4 ) |
0.95 |
BMI |
28 ( 25 , 32 ) |
29 ( 25 , 32 ) |
0.90 |
Diabetic |
40 ( 21 %) |
42 ( 22 %) |
0.80 |
Insulin dependent |
8 ( 4 %) |
11 ( 6 %) |
0.64 |
Baseline creatinine ( umol / L ) |
87 ( 73 , 104 ) |
87 ( 71 , 102 ) |
0.91 |
Dialysis dependent |
4 ( 2 %) |
3 ( 2 %) |
1.00 |
Pulmonary hypertension |
15 ( 8 %) |
16 ( 8 %) |
1.00 |
COPD |
41 ( 21 %) |
45 ( 23 %) |
0.62 |
Smoking history |
105 ( 54 %) |
97 ( 50 %) |
0.42 |
PVD |
8 ( 4 %) |
8 ( 4 %) |
1.00 |
Cerebrovascular disease |
15 ( 8 %) |
16 ( 8 %) |
1.00 |
Redo sternotomy |
25 ( 13 %) |
23 ( 12 %) |
0.76 |
NYHA 1 |
75 ( 39 %) |
68 ( 35 %) |
0.36 |
2 |
64 ( 33 %) |
74 ( 38 %) |
|
3 |
41 ( 21 %) |
32 ( 16 %) |
|
4 |
14 ( 7 %) |
20 ( 10 %) |
|
LVEF Normal |
114 ( 59 %) |
110 ( 57 %) |
0.71 |
Mild dysfunction |
48 ( 25 %) |
56 ( 29 %) |
|
Moderate dysfunction |
24 ( 12 %) |
23 ( 12 %) |
|
Severe dysfunction |
8 ( 4 %) |
5 ( 3 %) |
|
Baseline troponin T ( ng / L ) |
49 ( 25 %) |
52 ( 27 %) |
0.73 |
Continuous variables are expressed median ( IQR ), categorical variables are expressed number (%). Abbreviation : HKB – hyperkalaemic blood cardioplegia ; DNC – Del Nido cardioplegia ; BMI – body mass index ; COPD – chronic obstructive pulmonary disease ; PVD – peripheral vascular disease ; NYHA – New York Heart Association ; LVEF – left ventricular ejection fraction .
Table 2 . Subgroup analysis : Patient demographics for aortic crossclamp time greater than 120 min .
Characteristic |
HKB |
DNC |
p-value |
N |
64 |
64 |
|
Age |
57 ( 45 , 72 ) |
62 ( 45 , 69 ) |
0.83 |
Male |
40 ( 63 %) |
46 ( 72 %) |
0.26 |
Euroscore II |
2 ( 1 , 5 ) |
2 ( 1 , 5 ) |
0.92 |
BMI |
27 ( 24 , 30 ) |
28 ( 24 , 33 ) |
0.40 |
Diabetic |
11 ( 17 %) |
11 ( 17 %) |
1.00 |
Insulin dependent |
5 ( 8 %) |
2 ( 3 %) |
0.44 |
Baseline creatinine ( umol / L ) |
85 ( 69 , 104 ) |
85 ( 71 , 104 ) |
0.75 |
Dialysis dependent |
1 ( 2 %) |
1 ( 2 %) |
1.00 |
Pulmonary hypertension |
10 ( 16 %) |
9 ( 14 %) |
1.00 |
COPD |
19 ( 30 %) |
19 ( 30 %) |
1.00 |
Smoking history |
33 ( 52 %) |
34 ( 53 %) |
0.86 |
PVD |
2 ( 3 %) |
0 ( 0 %) |
0.50 |
Cerebrovascular disease |
7 ( 11 %) |
8 ( 13 %) |
1.00 |
Redo sternotomy |
10 ( 16 %) |
10 ( 16 %) |
1.00 |
NYHA class 1 |
26 ( 41 %) |
20 ( 31 %) |
0.27 |
2 |
18 ( 28 %) |
27 ( 42 %) |
|
3 |
15 ( 23 %) |
10 ( 16 %) |
|
4 |
5 ( 8 %) |
7 ( 11 %) |
|
LVEF Normal |
41 ( 64 %) |
36 ( 56 %) |
0.83 |
Mild dysfunction |
15 ( 23 %) |
19 ( 30 %) |
|
Moderate dysfunction |
6 ( 9 %) |
7 ( 11 %) |
|
Severe dysfunction |
2 ( 3 %) |
2 ( 3 %) |
|
Baseline troponin T ( ng / L ) |
17 ( 27 %) |
18 ( 28 %) |
0.84 |
Continuous variables are expressed median ( IQR ), categorical variables are expressed number (%). Abbreviation : HKB – hyperkalaemic blood cardioplegia ; DNC – Del Nido cardioplegia ; BMI – body mass index ; COPD – chronic obstructive pulmonary disease ; PVD – peripheral vascular disease ; NYHA – New York Heart Association ; LVEF – left ventricular ejection fraction . theatre , or mortality ( Table 4 ). The DNC had a higher rate of return to theatre for bleeding ( 6 % vs . 2 %).
The median troponin value at time points 6 , 12 , and 72 h postoperatively , the maximum postoperative troponin , area under the curve nor the number of patients with positive troponin profile showed any difference between the two groups ( Table 5 and Figure 2 ), similarly , there was no difference in time to peak troponin ( Table 6 ). Equivalence testing found DNC to be equivalent to HKC for all troponin measures other than peak troponin ( Table 5 )( p = 0.101 ).
Sensitivity analysis
Similar findings were found for the AXC time > 120-minute subgroup with no differences in preoperative characteristics and clinical outcomes ( Tables 2 , 7 , and 8 ). Troponin profiling did demonstrate differences , with the 72 h , maximum postoperative troponin value and the area under the release curve being higher in the DNC group ( p < 0.05 , Table 9 , Figure 3 ). The median troponin profile at 6 and 12 h , and the number of patients with positive troponin profile between cohorts were not different ( Table 6 ). Equivalence testing found DNC to be not equivalent in troponin measures other than for positive troponin profile ( Table 9 ).
Discussion
Del Nido cardioplegia has a well-established safety profile in myocardial ischaemic times of up to 90 min [ 6 ], with current literature providing little consensus on management protocols for extended AXC times and optimal reporting of clinical endpoints [ 13 , 19 , 20 ]. Clinical advantages of DNC compared to HKB are thought to be mediated by lidocaine ’ s inhibition of cardiomyocyte sodium channels , prevention of hypertonic myocardial oedema moderated by mannitol and competitive inhibition of calcium influx by magnesium [ 7 , 21 ]. Comfortable dosing intervals , and advantages over glycaemic control and reperfusion arrhythmias make it a popular alternative for myocardial protection [ 6 ]. The continued reporting of clinical experiences is mandated to build an evidence base upon which practice may evolve .
Our results showed patients receiving DNC had significantly longer ischaemic time compared to the matched HKB group , while demonstrating increased rates of return of sponta-