truth , his readiness to answer all objections to what he had taught , and to submit his doctrines to the decision of certain leading universities . But at the same time he protested against the cardinal ' s course in requiring him to retract without having proved him in error .
The only response was : " Retract , retract !" The Reformer showed that his position was sustained by the Scriptures and firmly declared that he could not renounce the truth . The legate , unable to reply to Luther ' s arguments , overwhelmed him with a storm of reproaches , gibes , and flattery , interspersed with quotations from tradition and the sayings of the Fathers , granting the Reformer no opportunity to speak . Seeing that the conference , thus continued , would be utterly futile , Luther finally obtained a reluctant permission to present his answer in writing . " In so doing ," said he , writing to a friend , " the oppressed find double gain ; first , what is written may be submitted to the judgment of others ; and second , one has a better chance of working on the fears , if not on the conscience , of an arrogant and babbling despot , who would otherwise overpower by his imperious language ." --Martyn, The Life and Times of Luther , pages 271 , 272 . At the next interview , Luther presented a clear , concise , and forcible exposition of his views , fully supported by many quotations from Scripture . This paper , after reading aloud , he handed to the cardinal , who , however , cast it contemptuously aside , declaring it to be a mass of idle words and irrelevant quotations .
Luther , fully aroused , now met the haughty prelate on his own ground--the traditions and teachings of the church--and utterly overthrew his assumptions . When the prelate saw that Luther ' s reasoning was unanswerable , he lost all self-control , and in a rage cried out : " Retract ! or I will send you to Rome , there to appear before the judges commissioned to take cognizance of your cause . I will excommunicate you and all your partisans , and all who shall at any time countenance you , and will cast them out of the church ." And he finally declared , in a haughty and angry tone : " Retract , or return no more ." --D' Aubigne , London ed ., b . 4 , ch . 8 . The Reformer promptly withdrew with his friends , thus declaring plainly that no retraction was to be expected from him . This was not what the cardinal had purposed . He had flattered himself that by violence he could awe Luther to submission . Now , left alone with his supporters , he looked from one to another in utter chagrin at the unexpected failure of his schemes .
Luther ' s efforts on this occasion were not without good results . The large assembly present had opportunity to compare the two men , and to judge for themselves of the spirit manifested by them , as well as of the strength and truthfulness of their positions . How marked the contrast ! The Reformer , simple , humble , firm , stood up in the strength of God , having truth on his side ; the pope ' s representative , self-important , overbearing , haughty , and unreasonable ,
86