Credibility Crisis
The Credibility Crisis: When Trust Falls, Brands Fall Harder
By Frankline Kibuacha
One of the stubbornly viral stories in Kenya’ s social media streets at the moment is the story of a renowned Nairobi car dealership. Just recently, this company was the go-to name for imported vehicles and an inspiration for many Kenyan youth- a business that built its reputation on trust and reliability, sweat and tears. But that trust was shattered when allegations surfaced that some customers never received the cars they paid for. Disgruntled buyers took to social media with receipts and unfulfilled promises, and the news spread like wildfire. Within weeks, the once-thriving dealership faced legal battles and a tarnished reputation. Unsalvageable? We don’ t know, but years of goodwill and brand equity were erased in an instant.
This story isn’ t an isolated incident. From local businesses to global giants, the credibility crisis knows no bounds. Even the most established brands, even presidents, have found themselves in the crosshairs. Remember that old adage, one day you’ re cock of the walk, the next, a feather duster. No one is immune.
Actually, the higher they rise, the harder they fall. Consider the case of Boeing, a century-old titan of aviation. In 2018- 2019, two fatal crashes of their 737 MAX aircraft led to a global grounding of the fleet. The subsequent investigations revealed that Boeing had allegedly downplayed safety concerns and rushed the aircraft into service. The cost? Beyond the tragic loss of life, Boeing ' s reputation suffered a blow that wiped billions off its market value and shattered public trust.
There is also the case of Volkswagen ' s emissions scandal in 2015. The company had built its reputation on German engineering excellence and environmental responsibility. When it emerged that they had deliberately cheated emissions tests, the betrayal cut deep. It wasn ' t just about the deception- it was about violating core brand promises that consumers had invested in emotionally and financially. Volkswagen faced billions in fines, saw its stock prices plummet, and experienced lasting damage to its brand credibility. Even years later, the shadow of Dieselgate, as it was called, lingers over the company’ s marketing efforts.
What is Credibility Crisis, then?
At its core, a credibility crisis occurs when there ' s a significant breach in the trust between a brand and its stakeholders- be they customers, employees, investors, or the general public. Unlike typical business challenges, a credibility crisis strikes at the very foundation of a brand ' s relationship with its audience. It ' s the moment when the gap between what a brand promises and what it delivers becomes so wide that it fractures the basic trust that makes business possible.
What distinguishes a credibility crisis from a regular business setback is its potential for exponential damage. When customers lose faith in a brand ' s basic truthfulness or integrity, they don ' t just stop buying- they often become active critics, sharing their negative experiences and convincing others to stay away. In the digital age, this ripple effect can quickly become a tsunami of distrust.
What distinguishes a credibility crisis from a regular business setback is its potential for exponential damage. When customers lose faith in a brand ' s basic truthfulness or integrity, they don ' t just stop buying- they often become active critics, sharing their negative experiences and convincing others to stay away. In the digital age, this ripple effect can quickly become a tsunami of distrust.
A credibility crisis typically emerges from one of three sources:
• Intentional deception, like Volkswagen ' s emissions scandal.
• Systematic failures that betray customer trust, as in Boeing ' s 737
60 MAL64 / 25 ISSUE