Since the majority of investors use their selfdirected IRA’ s to start their own portfolio of real estate investments. The tax advantages work according to the ownership percentage your IRA has based on what amount it took to buy the property. Simply put, let’ s assume for example, that you buy a singlefamily rental property for $ 500,000? You put down 50 % of the purchase price, i. e. $ 250,000 and you finance the other 50 % with a‘ nonrecourse’ loan of $ 250,000. The IRS requires that you not personally guarantee the money you borrow if you’ re buying an investment property with your IRA money as was previously mentioned. That’ s a primary rule of thumb. Hence, the requirement that the mortgage be a nonrecourse mortgage, means the mortgage lienholder has no recourse against the IRA investor should the investor default on making the monthly payment( s) for any reason. The lender can only seize the property, nothing else.
That said, in our example, your IRA owns 50 % of the property that you purchased with the IRA funds. The 50 % of the purchase price that the IRA borrowed represents the same percentage of the profits, if there are any after deducting expenses, that will be subject to taxes. Therefore, whatever monthly profit the property derives from the rental income will be taxed under the category known as‘ Unrealized Business Income Tax’ commonly referred to as UBIT, as follows:
1. The first $ 1000 of profit, after deducting all monthly expenses is tax deferred and goes back to the IRA, 2. The remaining 50 % of the profit, after deducting all expenses, goes back into the IRA tax deferred, 3. The remaining 50 % balance of the profit will be taxed at the Trust rate of 37 %. For this example, if we assume a monthly profit of $ 2500 after deducting all expenses, the first $ 1000 goes to the IRA tax deferred( only for the first month of ownership), the remaining $ 1500 of profit is divided up with $ 750
Image from Canva Pro
going back to the IRA tax deferred and the remaining $ 750 of profit gets taxed at the Trust rate of 37 %. That amounts to $ 277.50 in tax. Therefore, on a profit of $ 2500, you’ re out of pocket $ 277.50 which is a net tax of 11 % of your $ 2500 net profit.
If this was a conventional investment with no retirement account involved, your $ 2500 profit would be taxed as ordinary income. Whatever your ordinary income tax rate is after deducting your monthly expenses would be what you would pay in taxes. Hence, assuming an ordinary income tax rate of 25 %, your tax on $ 2500 of profit( after expenses, of course) would be $ 625 or about 3 times more than if you used your IRA to make the same investment.
When it comes to selling the property you bought with your IRA, the second form of tax advantage that applies to any longterm capital gains when the property has been held for more than one year by your IRA is called‘ Unrealized Debt Financing’( UDFI). The same formula described above that correlates to the percentage of ownership by the IRA versus the percentage of financing that remains owing is how the IRS quantifies what the tax on those gains
will be. Simply stated, assuming a capital gain of $ 100,000 is realized in the sale of the IRA owned property and, also assuming the property still owes 20 % of the original debt incurred when it was purchased, then 20 % of the gain will be taxed at the longterm capital gain rate based on one’ s taxable income rate. Based on those rates for 2025, most individual’ s income tax bracket for income if married and filing jointly according to the worldwide web is between $ 96,701 and $ 600,050, the long term capital gain rate is 15 %. That 15 % rate also holds true for those who are single earning between $ 48,351 and $ 533,400 as well as those married earning between $ 48,351 and $ 300,000 filing separately. The capital gain rate jumps up to 20 % on gains if your earnings exceed these numbers. Hence, for purposes of our example of a capital gain of $ 100,000 for the sale of the IRA owned property, 80 % of that gain would go back to the IRA account tax deferred; only 20 % of that gain, or $ 20,000, would be taxed at the capital gain rate of 15 %. This would result in a tax of $ 3000 on a longterm capital gain of $ 100,000 for your IRA owned property.
Image from Canva Pro
67