RACA Journal I November 2026 www. refrigerationandaircon. co. za 15
RENEWABLE ENERGY
FROM GRID RISK TO GRID READY
By Eamonn Ryan
Rethinking South Africa’ s renewable energy transition. business
At Solar & Storage Live Africa in Gauteng, CEO and founder of Commodore Industries Tokologo Phetla gave a presentation on four interlinked themes: how Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme( REIPPP) and the private Power Purchase Agreement( PPA) market have drifted into a price war; how the‘ just’ part of the just transition has not yet reached households; why the lack of risk capital and weak localisation policy are shutting out new players; and where the next wave of opportunity will lie if we design the system more intelligently.
South Africa’ s energy transition is usually discussed in terms of megawatts, technologies and decarbonisation targets. But the real story is about incentives, capital, ownership and national sovereignty, said Phetla. From inside the independent power producer( IPP) space, it is increasingly clear that the way South Africa is structuring this transition may weaken the very industry we need to build – and limit the benefits that reach ordinary South Africans.
“ South Africa’ s REIPPP is widely praised. It has brought in foreign capital, built gigawatts of renewable capacity, and created a credible contracting framework. But its very success has produced an unintended problem: tariffs have been pushed down to levels where projects no longer make sense on a risk‐adjusted basis.”
Early rounds saw tariffs around R4 – R5 per kWh. Over time, technology cost reductions and fierce competition compressed them into the 40 – 50c / kWh range for solar PV. On paper that looks like a victory for procurement; in practice, we are testing the floor of what a rational investor should accept for a long‐dated infrastructure asset in this environment.
“ Solar is not an innovation‐driven business in the way software is. Once everyone is using similar modules, inverters and engineering standards, the only real differentiators are equipment supply chains, construction efficiency and cost of capital. Those can yield modest advantages, not miracles. When tariffs are driven too low, developers are forced to squeeze EPC margins and front‐load returns into construction, instead of earning them over 20 years of operation,” said Phetla.
In effect, REIPPP risks becoming less an IPP programme and more a construction price war.“ At IRRs of 9 % or below, many local investors quite sensibly ask why they should undertake years of development and operational risk when lower‐risk instruments can yield 12 %. If serious local players walk away, the programme loses credibility and the country loses local industrial depth.”
There is a better way. Instead of awarding purely on lowest price, the IPP Office and ministry could set a standard tariff by technology and grid region – say 70c / kWh – and then award capacity to projects based on readiness, quality and system value. " Those that can credibly reach commercial operation by a certain date and meet robust technical and environmental criteria receive PPAs at that tariff until the window’ s quota is filled,” said Phetla.
That structure would shift competition toward project quality and speed, while keeping tariffs at levels that support bankable returns and long‐term reliability.
A‘ JUST’ TRANSITION THAT HASN’ T REACHED THE METER The phrase‘ just energy transition’ suggests that ordinary South Africans will share in the gains of decarbonisation. But if we follow the money through the current system, we find most benefits accruing elsewhere.
IPP owners benefit from long‐term offtake contracts. Commercial banks and DFIs earn returns on large volumes of project finance debt. Eskom secures capacity at costs lower than new coal. Large corporates signing private PPAs can lock in cheaper tariffs that fall straight to their bottom line.
“ The household in a municipal supply area, however, sees something different. Municipal tariffs continue to rise, driven by structural inefficiencies, historical debt, mark‐ups and cross‐subsidies. The fact that Eskom might buy power from an IPP at 40 – 50c / kWh has not translated into lower numbers on a typical residential bill.
CEO and founder of Commodore Industries Tokologo Phetla.
All images by © RACA Journal
RACA Journal I November 2026 www. refrigerationandaircon. co. za 15