What to look for in your motion control feedback device
EDITOR’ S CHOICE SMARTER MOTION STARTS HERE
KOLLMORGEN
What to look for in your motion control feedback device
When it comes to the world of motion control, it’ s easy to take your feedback device for granted. After all, it’ s a small part of the system and is typically tucked inside the motor housing, out of sight and out of mind. However, the impact this seemingly minor component has on a system’ s accuracy, performance, reliability, and ease of integration is hard to overstate.
Today’ s servo systems depend on accurate, consistent feedback to maintain position, control speed, and execute complex motion profiles. But not all feedback devices you can specify are created equal. Traditional encoders or resolvers still do the job in many applications, but application requirements increasingly need devices that go beyond the basics. Design engineers also want faster integration and less testing time. Modernizing your feedback device can mean reducing wiring, simplifying setup, or eliminating long-standing compromises on resolution, accuracy, and smoothness of motion.
Whether you’ re specifying a new servo system or looking to simplify an existing design, it’ s worth asking: what do you actually need your feedback device to do, and what’ s now possible?
What are you really looking for? Most engineers don’ t start out looking for a feedback device. They’ re looking for performance, reliability, and a system that behaves the way it’ s supposed to, every time. That means starting with the right questions – not“ which sensing technology is best?” but“ what performance does my application need to achieve?”
At the most basic level, your feedback device needs to deliver the resolution and accuracy required to drive the motion loop effectively. Too little, and you’ ll see ripples in motion, jitter in position holds, vibration in the machine, or just plain inaccurate positioning. Too much, and you might be paying for more capability than needed. Mechanics connecting to a motor shaft can only so accurately connect to the part of the machine doing the work which is where the motion really matters.
Other considerations quickly come into play, such as how smooth the motion is, how noisy the signal is, and how much bandwidth does it offer compared to your requirements. Fortunately, these are mostly straightforward questions, and most engineers know how to weigh them up.
But modern feedback devices also bring in another category of features that extend beyond the basic specs and simplify the machine as a whole.
This is where many of today’ s biggest gains are being made.
They include:
Simple cabling: Servo systems used to rely on dedicated feedback cables, sometimes requiring 13 or more wires just for feedback. That meant bigger cabinets, more connectors, tighter bends through cable trays, and more hands-on work during installation.
Modern single-cable feedback systems simplify all of that. By taking the motor power cable and just adding two wires for feedback data to fit everything into a single cable, they reduce effort and cut install time. Single-cable can make a major difference on compact machines where space is tight and reduce machine build time
Built-in motor ID: Many modern feedback devices now include onboard memory that stores the motor’ s ID, specs, and even tuning parameters. When connected to a
18 PECM Issue 77