Legal corner
CVs aren’t
optional reading
Managers who don’t undertake
proper due diligence when hiring
staff may face problems whenever
employees commit crimes.
By Scott Trueman
N
urses in management employ
staff regularly. How they do this
is, to a large degree, within their
employers’ discretion. If due diligence
is not undertaken in the process of
checking whether a nurse is suitable and/
or has an adverse history, it may leave the
employer open to liability for actions of the
employed nurse.
The recent NSW Coroner’s report into
the tragedy at Quakers Hill Nursing Home
is enlightening. Whilst the report discusses
the importance of pre-employment
screening in providing a safe environment
for nursing home residents, it is applicable
30 | nursingreview.com.au
to other facilities, such as hospitals, as well.
The coroner investigated the deaths of
14 residents at Quakers Hill as a result of
a fire deliberately set by RN Roger Dean –
an employee at the facility – in a botched
attempt to conceal his theft of Schedule
8 drugs. The coroner found that Quakers
Hill management had not undertaken
adequate pre-employment screening in
relation to Dean and stated that employers
may be exposed to legal liability if they fail
unreasonably to carry out a comprehensive
check on potential employees.
Dean was first registered as a nurse in
December 1996. He worked at a hospital
and community health service (HCHS)
in mental health and drug and alcohol
rehabilitation from 2002 until 2007. He
resigned following an investigation into
his behaviour in the workplace. Dean
worked at another hospital (H1) from 2005.
In June of 2011, he was found at work
under the influence of drugs. He informed
the director of nursing and nurse unit
manager during a follow up interview that
he suffered from bipolar disorder and that
he had recently changed his medication.
He said this was why he was adversely
affected on the day, and he had since
readjusted his medication. In support,
Dean provided a GP letter confirming
he suffered from a bipolar disorder with
overt signs of depression, and that he was
stable and fit to resume his duties as an
RN. However, in September of 2011, Dean
resigned from H1, having been moved
from night duty to days to enable proper
supervision and to ensure patient safety
was not compromised.
Later in 2011, Dean applied for
employment at Quakers Hill and was
informed there was a registered nurse
night duty position available. He provided
a copy of his CV but had outdated written
references; the most recent nursing one
was 11 years old. The references were also
inappropriate. They included his partner
from a job at a cheesecake shop and
someone from a time when he worked for
three months at another hospital (H2) in
1997. This was misleading, as it deliberately
omitted his employment at HCHS, and his
most recent nursing experience, at H1. The
only work disclosed from 2007 onward was
at the cheesecake shop.
Dean commenced employment as a
permanent part-time RN at Quakers Hill
on two night shifts and one morning shift
each week. The job requirements included
a current police check, experience
supervising staff and current registration
as an RN. The Quakers Hill employment
checklist included obtaining a police check.
Prior to being appointed, nurses were
required to undergo a medical screening.
The checklist required management
to contact an applicant’s referees. But
in Dean’s case, no medical screening
occurred. Further, no one contacted any of
his referees.
The facility manager stated at the inquest
that she expected little from referees
and that she preferred to observe new
employees on the job during the threemonth probation period. On this point,
the coroner stated, “If she or someone in
the management hierarchy had pressed