clinical practice
better not
to know
The rise of ‘incidentalomas’
is evidence that our medical
tests may be too good –
and used too often.
Paul Glasziou interviewed by Patrick Avenell
p
rofessor Paul Glasziou from Bond University heads up
a team of Australian researchers – including professors
Rachelle Buchbinder from Monash, and Chris Maher and
Kirsten McCaffery from the University of Sydney – who have just
received a $9,578,895 grant to investigate unnecessary testing and
treatment of so-called ‘incidentalomas’, particularly in the areas of
musculoskeletal diseases, cardiovascular disease and cancer.
In this interview with Nursing Review, Glasziou explains what an
incidentaloma is and how too much testing can lead to trauma
and illness, rather than preventing it.
NR: Tell me a bit about yourself and the team that you’ve put
together to spend the $9.5 million grant
pg: I’m a general practice researcher who’s been working in
what’s called evidence-based medicine, which is about using
the best research to guide clinical practice, for about 20 years.
Recently, there’s been a concern about what’s called overdiagnosis leading to over-treatment. We’ve put together a team
of chief investigators: myself; Rachelle Buchbinder from Monash
University, she’s a rheumatologist who works in this area; Chris
Maher, who is a physiotherapist at the University of Sydney; and
Kirsten McCaffery, who is a health psychologist, also at USYD. The
four of us have a common interest in dealing with this problem of
over-testing and over-diagnosis.
20 | nursingreview.com.au
can you give our readers an idea about what over-testing and
over-diagnosis are?
You can think of it as a case of our tests getting better and better.
In some ways, the tests are too good. We’re detecting things that
probably wouldn’t harm anybody in their lifetime. Just to give you
a specific example of that, I’m 61 years old and pretty healthy and
well, but if you did an ultrasound of my shoulder, there’s a 13 per
cent chance that you’d find what’s called a rotator cuff tear.
If you did magnetic resonance imaging (an MRI) of my spine,
there would be a 78 per cent chance that you’d find a disc bulge
and a 28 per cent chance of a disc protrusion, even though I feel
perfectly well.
The problem is that we’re doing more and more imaging and
tests on people and detecting things that look like a disease but
probably aren’t even causing the person a problem. We find them
incidentally as well.
An ‘incidentaloma’ is something that’s accidentally discovered.
For example, there’s been an increase in the apparent amount
of thyroid cancer over the last two decades, about three-fold in
Australia. A lot of that appears to be due to some of the imaging
being done to look at arteries in the neck, for example. People also
look at the thyroid [when they do that] and they may discover a
little lump there. Then they end up biopsying it and finding some
abnormal cells, which can look like cancer but wouldn’t have
disturbed a person in their lifetime.
some might argue it’s better to be sa