industry & reform
Deck the
swabs
s
taff at UK hospitals have been advised not to perform
vaginal seeding, after academics called into question the
benefits of the procedure.
Writing in the journal BMJ, Aubrey Cunnington, clinical senior
lecturer from Imperial College London, stated that the authors
advised staff to cease the activity – which involves swabbing
infants with the mother’s vaginal fluid – as they believe the “small
risk of harm cannot be justified without evidence of benefit”.
The authors said media coverage of the potential benefits
of vaginal seeding, including that it might decrease the risk of
disease among infants born by caesarean section, had increased
demand for it among women attending their hospitals. “Demand
has outstripped both professional awareness and professional
guidance on this practice,” Cunnington wrote.
Infections such as group B streptococcus, herpes simplex
virus, Chlamydia trachomatis, and Neisseria gonorrhoeae,
which mothers may carry asymptomatically, would probably be
transferred on a vaginal swab, the authors stated. They added that
parents who have had vaginal seeding performed should mention
it to health professionals if the baby later becomes unwell and
workers should ask about it when assessing newborns who may
have an infection.
The authors drew attention to the effects that breast feeding and
antibiotic exposure have on developing microbiota. “Encouraging
breast feeding and avoiding unnecessary antibiotics may be much
more important than worrying about transferring vaginal fluid on a
swab,” they wrote.
The team said the simplicity of vaginal seeding means mothers
can do it easily themselves, and health professionals should
respect their autonomy but ensure that those interested in
swabbing are fully informed about the possible risks.
Professsor Steve Robson, who was recently elected president of
the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and
Gynecologists (RANZCOG), has advised extreme caution for those
seeking to perform the intervention. Here he discusses the risks and
precautions his college has determined are vital for babies health.
nR: Vaginal seeding has been promoted here in australia.
where does RanZcOg stand on this?
sR: The current position of our college is that it is an unproven
intervention and there’s a potential for harm, so at the moment
we’re advising caution and we’re certainly not promoting it as part
of routine care. Our position is that at the current time, it should be
used only as part of a properly conducted study.
The authors of the bMJ article focusing on this issue stated
that encouraging breast feeding and avoiding unnecessary
antibiotics may be much more important than worrying about
transferring vaginal fluid on a swab. How much merit is there in
this statement?
The benefits of vaginal
seeding have yet to be proven
– and the risks are real.
Steve Robson interviewed by Dallas Bastian
8 | nursingreview.com.au
I think it’s important to understand where the impetus for the
practice and intervention of vaginal seeding came from. A
number of publications in the literature over the last few years
have [shown] associations between some conditions – such
as diabetes, asthma and, to a certain extent, children being
overweight – and caesarean sections. [The theory is that children
delivered this way] may be exposed to additional groups of
bacteria and acquire different bacteria on their bodies than
children exposed to vaginal fluid during birth. There has been
some suggestion that perhaps the mode of the baby’s birth and
the exposure to different bacteria can alter developmental and
immune trajectories in the baby.