news
A hefty
penalty
Nurses push back against cuts; report
finds 20 per cent of group’s income
derived from penalty rates.
By Patrick Avenell
F
our out of five nurses would
consider abandoning the profession
if existing penalty rates applying to
wages were axed, an Australian Nursing &
Midwifery Federation survey has revealed.
Shortly before Christmas, after the
Productivity Commission raised the issue
of significant changes to penalty rates, the
ANMF issued a fresh warning to legislators
against making changes that would reduce
or remove penalty rates and loadings for
those working outside standard hours.
Changes to penalty rates across a range
of industries and professions has been
singled out by many experts as a key area
the government may be seeking changes.
“Our 250,000 members rely on being
fairly compensated for working shifts over
Christmas and other special days, including
public holidays and weekends,” ANMF
federal secretary Lee Thomas said.
She added that the full results of a
member survey, in which 80 per cent of
respondents said they would consider
quitting the profession if existing penalty
rates were axed, would be included in a
2 | nursingreview.com.au
“comprehensive report on the economic
and health impact of cutting penalty rates”.
Proponents of reducing or scrapping
penalty rates have said their cost often
makes operating on Sundays and public
holidays unprofitable. There is also the
argument that reducing Sunday rates to
Saturday levels would open up more job
opportunities for workers and more options
for consumers, clients and patients. In
addition, there is a social argument that
penalty rates are an anachronism because
weekends and Sundays, in particular, are no
longer as revered in Australia as they were
in years past.
The ANMF commissioned the McKell
Institute to prepare a report on how
important penalty rates were to the
profession. Key findings included that
nurses, midwives and carers relied on
penalty rates for 20 per cent of their
income; RNs in public hospitals would
lose $1921 a year in wages if their Sunday
penalty rates were reduced to Saturday
levels. Collectively, nurses, midwives and
aged-care workers would lose almost $360
million annually if Sunday penalty rates
were reduced to Saturday levels.
“Meeting the challenge of an ageing
population as well as advancing health
technology requires a growing and highly
skilled health workforce,” wrote the report’s
authors, John Watkins and Sam Crosby.
“The risk of reduced penalty rates will only
exacerbate these challenges by reducing
workforce participation.”
ANMF assistant federal secretary
Annie Butler said the report showed
how essential penalty rates were to the
profession, and emphasised why nurses
were deserving of the income.
“As the report finds, health is the ‘ultimate
24/7 industry’ with nurses, midwives and
carers required to work inconvenient and
unsociable hours, and weekends and
nights often the busiest times in health
and aged care settings. Whether it’s [late
on] a Saturday night or a public holiday
like Australia Day, they’re always on the job
and it’s only fair and reasonable to expect
that they be rightly compensated for the
constant care they give to the community.
Instead, their penalty rates are at risk.”
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has
indicated that he is open to a discussion on
changing penalty rates. Opposition leader
Bill Shorten has said the Labor Party would
oppose any deleterious changes. ■