technology
Can’t simulate compassion
The use of mannequins and other
high-tech tools may be leading to workers less
in tune with the emotional needs of patients.
By Dallas Bastian and Andrew Bracey
E
mpathy and compassion are often
lacking when students engage with
simulation technologies in nursing
programs, a lecturer has said.
Sue Dean, a lecturer at the University of
Technology Sydney, wrote about the topic
in the Journal of Advanced Nursing.
Dean says the use of simulation
technologies, such as high-fidelity
mannequins, is sparking concern about
the quality of nurses’ communication in
their professional practice. In her editorial,
Dean recalls seeing this technology being
used during the opening of a simulation
laboratory in a large university a few years
ago. There, she noticed a few red flags.
“What caused us much consternation
whilst observing the demonstration was
that not once in the interaction did any
attending ‘nurse’ acknowledge the anxiety
the ‘patient’ would have undoubtedly
been feeling, let alone address any of
his likely emotional or psychological
concerns,” Dean writes. “In other words,
the actual person in the bed was ignored
in favour of the technology and the purely
physiological data it provided.”
28 | nursingreview.com.au
In an interview with Nursing Review,
Dean says: “I ran some focus groups and
asked students who’d been working with
the mannequins over a period of time how
they related to the patient in the bed, what
they focused on. Basically … they were so
busy focusing on the clinical skills they
needed to achieve while they were in the
laboratories, they paid little attention to the
patient as a person.”
Dean says that while the students reported
they were encouraged by the academics
who were running the laboratories to relate
to the patient as a person, they often didn’t
have time to do so.
“If they did relate to the mannequin in the
bed as a patient, other students laughed at
them and thought they were being silly,”
she says. “My feelings are that nurses learn
best on real patients – particularly around
interpersonal skills. If we want nurses to be
caring, kind, and compassionate, then they
need to understand that every patient they
look after in the hospital environment or
the healthcare sector has unique needs.”
Dean says nurses need to respond to
the unique needs of patients, rather than
simply applying the skills they’ve learned
during a program without real thought.
The caring aspect of nursing, she adds,
is one of the most important parts of the
profession and she fears that this vital
element is being “diminished and lost”.
“There is evidence now to say that
it’s a huge concern with any healthcare
professional – it’s not only nurses – they’re
lacking or not as caring and 6