Legal corner
Implied dangers
Take care to fill all the implicit
obligations of the employment
contract, or termination
may well be justified.
By Scott Trueman
A
ll employees, including nurses, have in their contract of
employment a number of implied duties that are owed
to their employer. Four of these are to obey a lawful and
reasonable direction or request, to undertake duties and tasks in
a diligent and competent manner, not to act against the interests
of the employer, and not to make or arrange secret commissions.
An aged-care worker’s recent claim for unfair dismissal, which
was denied, is an illustration of these duties and the serious
consequences that may result if they are breached.
The employer was a large organisation that provided healthcare
in both institutional and private residential settings throughout
Australia. The care worker commenced employment in April
2001 on a casual basis, and worked in that role until her dismissal
in June 2015. Usually, the courts expect that longstanding
employees, particularly those who have given loyal and faithful
service, are to be dealt with more leniently than recent hires when
matters of performance and dismissal are aired.
The worker’s primary role was to provide personal care
and/or home support services in patients’ homes. The level and
number of duties were dependent on the needs of the patient
and were reflected in the patients’ care plans. The duties may
have included:
24 | nursingreview.com.au
• H
ome care or housekeeping, including cleaning, laundry and
meal preparation
• Personal care, including hygiene and grooming
• Medication supervision
• Respite home care
• Social support or attendant care.
The care worker was dismissed on the basis of three alleged
performance and conduct issues. First, for breaching the policies
and procedures of the aged-care employer (hereinafter referred
to as ‘the employer’) by performing work for cash payments in a
private arrangement. Second, for allegedly failing to report the
deteriorating health of a patient of the employer for whom she
was responsible. Third, for failing to comply with a number of
lawful and reasonable directions to attend meetings to discuss the
employer’s concerns in relation to the aforementioned matters.
In relation to the remunerated ‘additional/private’ services for
the patient, the care worker asserted as justification that she had
to ‘work outside the square’ and felt she owed a duty of care to the
patient. This meant that ‘shopping shifts’ were necessary despite
being declined by the employer as part of the patient’s suite of
required services of care. The Fair Work Commission noted that
the worker did approach her employer about having shopping and
other services included in the care plan but this was refused. The
care worker did not deny undertaking work for cash payments
pursuant to collateral private arrangements with the patient.
The arrangement came to the employer’s attention only
through one of the patient’s telephone calls, during which the
cash rate of $20 an hour for shopping, preparing meals and
feeding the patient’s cat, plus an extra $50 a week for helping, was
disclosed. The commission found that this arrangement was partly
justifiable to dismiss the care worker.