industry & reform
Other consequences are expectations in hospitals and administrators , expectations that nurses will fit in with the shift requirements of the hospital . Really , it ’ s all about sacrificing family and own social needs for the hospital which really isn ’ t seen to the same extent in other health professions .
In what way does the fact that this is a predominantly a female dominated profession play a role ? Nurses are put in that role of the oldfashioned , sexist ideals we often associated with women , which is conforming , obedient , and self-sacrificing . It ’ s really convenient for our governments to rely on this idea and image of the nurse because then they can ignore issues of pay and poor working conditions that are just getting worse for our nurses . This idea that as a woman , we will be happy to accept whatever ’ s thrown at us , and also to bend to the needs of others .
Women obviously continue to be subjugated in wider society and obviously this occurs within the hospital and other healthcare settings , and unfortunately people who are subjugated tend to go on to subjugate others . We do have issues of hierarchy and bullying and manipulation in nursing , rather than assertive discussion in many situations . We often find people who are in positions of limited power trying to find ways to control their own lives and dominate others , and that can happen through bullying . That really can be a consequence of nursing being a highly female profession .
Like the military , another hierarchical profession , this can really cause attrition and deep stress , and PTSD . And also the idea that as women , nurses must fit into the health system and build their own resilience , which really is looking at the idea of they need to bend to the increasingly unrealistic expectations of hospital administration , rather than finding a way that everyone can compromise so that everybody ’ s needs are met .
How has COVID changed the way society perceives the nursing profession ? This is a really complex one . In some good ways , the public are waking up to the idea that the nurse has a key role in health protection and public health . And they ’ re more aware of the struggles they have , in an under-resourced health environment . But some of the negatives are that maybe we ’ ve reinforced the idea of the nurse as the martyr . We ’ ve seen the public celebrating nursing sacrifice , we ’ ve seen nurses leave their families to move in with patients in nursing homes , for example .
There ’ s been more clapping and celebrating of this sacrificial behaviour , which is strange . When we really think about it , looking at for example President Trump calling nurses warriors , running into death like soldiers , running into bullets . This image of the nurses as a martyr . It really makes it easier for the public to accept the death of our nurses from COVID as natural , as part of a martyr role . Rather than being outraged about the situation , the lack of personal protective equipment , loss of resources , et cetera .
What do you think needs to change to improve the image of nurses ? It ’ s a double edged sword , but we do need to remove the profession ’ s image away from traditional ideas of women as the self-sacrificing person . We really need to educate our administrators and the members of the multidisciplinary team about the nurse ’ s role , to increase respect for the nurse and support communication
“ We ’ ve reinforced the idea of the nurse as a martyr , rather than as an empowered professional .
I still think that we ’ re trying to do more and more at university , so that nurses are training with medical students , physio , so they have collaboration . We need to really improve respect and mutual communication , so that ’ s another way we can really promote the nursing image , and we really need to challenge the idea of the nurse as the angel or martyr that ’ s portrayed in the public and stop celebrating this . Women and men in nursing need to have more power and control in their everyday lives . Planning their off duty , planning their career advancement . They ’ re at the coalface of care and nurses have been protesting for decades about clinical status and pay and we really need to be listening to these nurses rather than silencing them . ■
nursingreview . com . au | 11