news
Weird part of the night
Poor mental health and car crashes:
warnings for shiftworkers.
S
hiftworkers are at greater risk of poor mental health and
of crashing their car after their first shift of the week, two
separate studies suggest.
In the first, an international team of researchers examined the
schedules and mental health symptoms of more than 28,000
participants.
Dr Tracy Kolbe-Alexander from the University of Southern
Queensland said that working outside standard hours (7am to
6pm) held potential physical and mental health consequences.
She said shiftwork was associated with a 28 per cent increased
likelihood of adverse mental health outcomes combined. And
female shiftworkers were more likely to report symptoms –
particularly depressive symptoms – than women who did not
work shifts.
“Night work and inconsistent work hours disrupt the normal
sleep-wake cycle,” she said. “Sleeping at odd times of the
day, together with shifting schedules, creates challenges for
maintaining a healthy work-life balance.”
In the car crash study, researchers investigated the theory that
the cumulative effects of night shift increase the likelihood that an
accident will occur as time goes on.
They found shiftworkers were more likely to crash their car after
finishing their first night shift of the week rather than later on.
Lead researcher Professor Greg Roach, based at CQUni
Adelaide’s Appleton Institute, recruited 43 people for simulated
shiftwork in their sleep laboratory.
The participants completed seven consecutive eight-hour night
shifts in an office, then each day had 20-minute commutes in a
driving simulator – one at 10.30pm, as if they were going to work,
and one to represent their trip home at 7.10am.
“Most guidelines recommend a maximum of two to four
consecutive night shifts, based on the notion that fatigue risk
increases with each successive night shift due to accumulated
sleep loss,” Roach said.
“Our results challenge that notion.”
The study also found that the likelihood of a shiftworker
crashing on the way home from night shift on the first night is
eight times greater than the likelihood of crashing on the way
to work. ■
Too much of a good thing?
Oxygen use put to the test.
H
istorically, oxygen has been
treated like holy water, but it’s
time to take a closer look at its
role in hospitals.
That’s the call from Professor Rinaldo
Bellomo, a researcher at Monash
4 | nursingreview.com.au
University’s Australian and New Zealand
Intensive Care Research Centre. Bellomo
issued the suggestion following his
research involving 1000 ICU patients.
Participants were assigned to two groups:
one receiving the normal amount of
oxygen, and the other a smaller amount.
The study’s findings suggested that
unnecessary levels of oxygen make no
difference to the recovery of ICU patients
and might actually be dangerous for some.
“There’s been an underlying assumption
that oxygen is good for patients and that
doctors should give it to them liberally and
should make sure the oxygen levels are
high,” Bellomo said.
“But there’s never been any data or
evidence or trial [demonstrating] that that’s
actually true.”
What’s more, Bellomo found “a signal
to suggest increased survival with less
oxygen” among people who suffered
hypoxic brain injury due to cardiac arrest.
“So even though the totality of ICU
patients put together do not appear to
show a difference between these two
treatments, in some specific sub-groups of
people, giving less oxygen may well be a
good thing,” he explained.
The research team is now planning
further investigation into this sub-group.
Overall, Bellomo said the research could
bring about a decrease in the amount of
oxygen therapy that’s being given “because
it’s likely to be seen to be unnecessary”.
“More large trials of oxygen therapy are
now a global priority,” he added.
The findings of the study, ‘Conservative
Oxygen Therapy during Mechanical
Ventilation in the ICU’, will appear in
the New England Journal of Medicine. ■