news
Will dispute
Nurse banned from aged
care work after inheriting
resident’s estate.
A
nurse has been banned from
working in aged care over
her involvement in an elderly
resident’s will.
Abha Kumar was disqualified by the
Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal
from re-applying for registration or
providing any health service in aged or
disability care for five years, after she
became over-involved in an elderly
resident’s affairs.
In July 2015, 92-year-old Lionel Cox
was admitted to Cambridge House, the
residential aged care facility at which
Kumar worked as nurse unit manager.
Cox owned his own home, had no
family and had not made a will. He was
also sitting on an estate worth more than
$1,000,000.
He had previously lived in that Fitzroy
home with the assistance and care of his
neighbours and his case manager from
the Brotherhood of St Laurence.
After his case manager convinced
him to try respite care, Cox told nurses
his intention was to stay “until the cold
months were over”.
Later that month, Kumar purchased a
kit from the post office, which Cox used
to write his will before the witness of
two staff members, under the direction
of Kumar.
Unknown to them, the will named
Kumar as sole beneficiary of Cox’s estate.
Cox died that same year of natural
causes and, the following year, Kumar sold
the house she had inherited from Cox for
over $1,000,000.
Keeping staff safe
Hospitals could face rise in prosecutions
for failing to protect nurses.
H
ealth departments are risking an uptick in compensation
claims if they don’t take steps to ensure staff safety.
That’s the warning from an injury compensation lawyer
and former emergency department nurse.
Following reports that Caboolture Hospital Mental Health Unit
staff are afraid to go to work after a string of assaults by patients
on staff, Trent Johnson said: “Not only at Caboolture, but around
the state, Queensland Health is aware its staff regularly face real
risk of injury just doing their job, and what’s happening demands a
tougher response from it.”
2 | nursingreview.com.au
Kumar admitted to the tribunal that she
made false statements to staff about the
will, saying Cox named two nephews in
Ireland in it and that it had been torn up.
The tribunal stripped Kumar of her
nursing registration due to her over-
involvement in Cox’s affairs, and her
failures to manage a conflict of interest
and practise the profession of nursing in
a reflective way.
Nursing and Midwifery Board of
Australia (NMBA) chair Associate Professor
Lynette Cusack said the board would take
action where nurses were benefitting from
over-involvement with vulnerable patients.
“Nurses are among the most trusted
professions in our community, and the
vast majority work with deep integrity and
a commitment to providing professional
care for vulnerable people,” she said.
“When the actions of an individual let
down the standards of the profession, we
will take action to keep patients and the
community safe from exploitation.”
Should Kumar wish to re-register in five
years’ time, the NMBA will then decide
whether she is fit to do so. ■
Johnson, now a director with Queensland law firm Bennett
& Philp Lawyers, spent four years working as a registered nurse
at Caboolture Hospital. He said: “It’s a sad reflection on today’s
society that frontline staff – including administration, doctors,
nurses and security – cannot perform their work without risk of
injury from physical and verbal assault.
“If Queensland Health fails to take proper steps to ensure its staff
can safely do their work without being abused and assaulted, it
can expect to receive plenty more compensation claims against it.”
Johnson added that hospitals also face increasing insurance
premiums and the risk of Workplace Health and Safety
Queensland prosecutions.
“Unions have been pushing for safe and better working
conditions for hospital staff,” he said.
“It is time for Queensland Health to actively work with the
unions and the Queensland Police Service to implement tough
measures to prevent workplace assaults and ensure emergency
response and hospital staff can carry out their duties safely at
all times.”
Johnson encouraged hospital staff injured by violent patients
to press criminal charges and pursue claims for damages where
possible against those responsible for the assaults.
“The injured staff member should also lodge a workers’
compensation claim as soon as possible after the event, so they
can receive appropriate and early treatment.
“In many instances they may also be able to sue their employer
for any ongoing injuries and loss due to the employer’s failure to
provide a safe working environment, failing to provide adequate
staffing, failing to have regard to prior history of aggressive
behaviour of particular patients and so on.
“In those circumstances, it is important to make an early report
so supporting evidence can be preserved,” he said. ■