specialty focus
A courageous life
Understanding and treating
adverse childhood experiences.
By Tona Gillen
T
he African-American statesman
Frederick Douglass (1818–95)
wrote that “it is easier to build
strong children than to repair broken men”.
Although he was referring to the abhorrent
slave trade (he had been a slave himself),
it is a pertinent statement that resonates
today, particularly when we consider
the lasting impact of adverse childhood
experiences (ACEs).
The 10 most common ACEs are listed
below (Felitti et al, 2006):
• Physical abuse
• Emotional abuse
• Sexual abuse
• Physical neglect
• Emotional neglect
• Exposure to domestic violence or
where the mother was treated violently
• Parental substance abuse
• Parental mental illness (depression
or suicidality)
• Household member incarcerated
• Parental discord (separated/divorced).
The Queensland Children’s Hospital
(QCH) admits children who have sustained
injuries secondary to physical abuse. This
is sometimes referred to as intentional
or inflicted injury. The paediatric trauma
service database captures all injured
children who are admitted to QCH for
more than 24 hours.
20 | nursingreview.com.au
Over a 10-year period (2008–18), this data
revealed that approximately two children
were admitted per month with unexplained
physical injuries.
Children who had self-harmed (e.g.
intentional hanging injuries, burns from
home-made devices) and children who
reported they had been assaulted at school
were excluded from this data.
Patients included were those with
subdural haemorrhages, rib fractures, retinal
haemorrhages, as well as those with long
bone fractures or extensive bruising (usually
on the torso, ears and neck) with no clear
mechanism of injury. There was no plausible
explanation for these injuries. Ninety-seven
per cent of these children were younger
than two years of age.
Another more detailed study of trauma
patients admitted to the QCH intensive care
unit over a seven-year period (2008–15)
analysed 542 injured patients aged
0–15 years. Overall mortality rates were
11.1 per cent. The mechanisms of injury
with the greatest mortality were intentional
inflicted injury (also referred to as physical
abuse) and drownings in young children
aged 0–4 years (Coulthard et al, 2019).
In addition to the broad term ‘emotional
abuse’, there are other ACEs, which may
include bereavement, bullying, poverty
or community adversities such as living in
an at-risk area or a neighbourhood where
violence or high levels of crime prevail.
To compound the child’s emotional
vulnerability, there is usually no-one
the child can turn to for support. Their
caregivers and their safety network, the
people they should be able to turn to in
times of crisis or stress, are either absent
or are often the people who violate and
betray them.
Any of the listed ACEs can have a negative
impact on the child and can be stressful.
One’s capacity to deal with stress is said
to be influenced by one’s family of origin,
genetics, age, experience and support
networks. The Yerkes-Dodson Law implies
that some stress improves performance but
too much stress has a negative impact. This
is graphically represented as a stress bell
curve, which increases initially but decreases
with prolonged levels of stress.
There are three recognised forms of stress
(Gino, 2016):
• A positive stress
• A tolerable stress
• A complex or toxic stress.
Positive stress is perhaps best understood as
a personal challenge that you can deal with,
perhaps an exam. This can be a positive and
motivating form of stress.
Tolerable stress is a more difficult
situation, such as the loss of a loved one or
sustaining a severe injury. This stress can
continue for prolonged periods of time
depending on the situation but usually
lessens over time.
Complex stress – more recently
referred to as ‘toxic stress’ – is the result of
exaggerated and prolonged fear, perhaps
from repeated exposure to ACEs or from
personal violation or violence.
Without conscious direction or
awareness, the autonomic nervous system,
made up of the sympathetic nervous
system and the parasympathetic nervous
system, regulates the heart rate, blood
pressure, pupil dilation, body temperature
and digestion.
A stressful or dangerous situation
activates the sympathetic nervous system,
which increases the body’s heart rate,
sending extra blood to the muscles.
Breathing becomes faster and oxygen is
delivered to the brain; an infusion of glucose
is directed into the bloodstream for a quick
energy boost. This response prepares us
to either fight or flee the situation. The
greater oxygen demand from the heart may
result in vasoconstriction and secondary
ischaemia, which in turn may lead to
cardiovascular disease.
On the other hand, there is the vagus
nerve – the nerve that stimulates the
parasympathetic nervous system which
allows the body to calm and to slow down
and enables time to ‘rest and digest’.