INDUSTRY & REFORM
the best people to nursing or to care
in general because of the perceived
low pay.
to provide the sort of care that you would
want your parents to have.
Aged care is a $20 billion a year
industry, yet the big players always cry
poor. They say they can’t afford to pay
staff more and can’t afford more staff.
When I was researching my talk for the
2019 ACN National Nursing Forum, I also
believed the rhetoric, which most people
believe, that residential aged care is a
bottomless pit of financial need.
In doing the research, I read the funding
and financing of the aged care sector
report 2017 – a government report on the
public record. I was really shocked to read
those figures that you’ve mentioned, which
is that in 2015–16, residential aged care
alone generated $17.4 billion of revenue,
which represents nearly 1 per cent of gross
domestic product. That money’s going
somewhere, and I can tell you that money
is not going into care.
We could say that maybe some of the
issues we’re seeing in the aged care
sector are a result of not attracting
That is true, and I think the negative
perception of aged care as a workplace
is multifactorial. I think low wages is one
of the things. As I said, I think this would
also relate to the childcare industry, but
in combination with low wages and short
staffing, the aged care industry is always a
stressed and panicky place.
It’s a bit like being on Survivor, where
you actually run out of good manners.
I’ve worked in TAFE for 15 years and TAFE
was well funded, it was well structured, it
was very pleasant, a nice clean place to
work. You didn’t have that sense of anxiety
and rushing that you get in residential
aged care.
The whole emotional tempo in
residential aged care facilities is what’s
responsible for making it visually and
experientially for a very unattractive
place to work.
When I was working in TAFE, I was
training aged care workers for 15 years, so
I knew that cohort of workers extremely
well. When I worked directly with them
for six years in residential aged care, and
after that in home care, one thing I noticed
about these workers as a whole was that
they were not there for the money.
They were there because they cared.
They were there because they were
people who genuinely wanted to make
a difference to people’s lives. They could
have made far more money working at
Coles or Woolies, or doing cleaning – they
could have got $35 an hour – but they
weren’t there for the money.
But the experiences that they had in
there meant that at the end of their work
day, they continually felt unsatisfied. They
hadn’t achieved what they needed to do,
and they hadn’t been able to spend the
time with the residents.
When I was teaching at TAFE, we
focused on personal sense of care, but
by the time they got into the industry, it
wasn’t possible.
Staffing payment and ratios is a matter
of debate among academics and
politicians, but we know without a
doubt that there is a gender pay gap.
Could the overwhelmingly female
workforce of aged care and nursing be
the key reason staff are underpaid?
That is actually a really interesting point
you raise there, and it’s a big part of it.
I’d also done some interesting research
when I was preparing for this talk around
that very thing. Some of the research
I read was talking a little bit about
how overwhelmingly female workers,
particularly in healthcare, fear that financial
incentives will lead to a loss of truly caring
motivations, as though love and money
can’t go together.
The research further found that these
workers are far more likely to mobilise
themselves industrially around quality
of care issues than pay issues, and this
goes very much to the way that aged care
workers identify themselves.
I think it’s another reason for the low pay
in aged care work, because employers are
aware of this sense among the workers,
and which employer would not want
to take advantage of and capitalise on
this perception?
We have a sector that’s trying to
make changes while still trying to be
financially viable. How can we fix this?
The first thing we need to do is fix the
ratios. Fixing the ratios means that we at
least could come within striking distance
of being able to provide genuinely
dignified care.
Workers don’t feel pride in work when
they know they cannot reach the goals
that they aspire to, but we do need to have
staff to resident ratios mandated.
It’s a bit like we don’t have plastic bags in
supermarkets. I didn’t bring my own bags:
they forced me to bring them. People
won’t do anything until you force them.
These need to be mandated in law, and
of course there needs to be scrutiny of the
They could [be making]
far more money working at
Coles or Woolies.
way that particularly private providers are
using their profits.
What are they using them for? Are they
using them to improve care and wages,
or are they using them to put up another
chandelier?
This is where some of the oversight
needs to happen, to start directing some
of those wages towards the workers and
putting on more workers.
In all honesty, these workers will work
for the wages they’re given, but they need
to know they’re working in a big enough
team to provide the care that they aspire
to give. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 17