Legal Corner
Face value
Case study a warning to
nurses involved in the delivery
of beauty treatments and
procedures.
By Scott Trueman
M
any nurses are engaging in cosmetic and beauty
practices for commercial benefit, either as an employee
or sole practitioner.
While a recent case involved the negligent actions of a person
without nursing registration and training, it contains many salient
legal points for nurses in the cosmetic industry. The court had
to consider the nature of the relationship between a ‘cosmetic
practitioner’ and a customer, the nature of the transaction, issues
of consent, and the assumption of risk.
The uncontested facts are that in June 2017, after making
payments totalling $5000, the plaintiff, Ms J, aged 33, underwent
what the defendant company had represented as a very safe,
non-invasive cosmetic facial treatment procedure described as a
“3D skin lifting by ultrasound”. The procedure was performed by a
trained ultrasound operator employee, Ms C. She was not a nurse.
The treatment commenced with the application of numbing
facial cream, and then continued with heat energy being applied
to Ms J’s face generated by an ultrasound device. The stated
intention was to improve her appearance by delivering a low
amount of focused ultrasound energy to the facial skin. As a
consequence of the treatment, Ms J developed facial redness,
burning, blistering, lumpiness and depigmentation to parts of her
face. This caused her to suffer distress and embarrassment, for
which she claimed damages in negligence.
The first issue for consideration was the nature of the
relationship and consultation. The defendant company denied a
patient and treatment provider relationship. The court rejected
this based on the quasi-medical content and terminology that
appeared in the defendant’s consultation form, which referred to
treatment goals and a variety of potential procedures, including
facial skin tightening, filler treatment, the use of neurotoxins,
ablative laser and non-laser resurfacing treatment, dermabrasion
or deep facial peels, lipoplasty to the face and neck regions,
facelift, blepharoplasty, and brow lift.
10 | nursingreview.com.au
Further, the form sought to record patient information about
medications and other health conditions or diseases consistent
with taking a patient’s medical history. It also contained spaces
for notes to be made about any assessment of clinical response
factors and factors relating to the assessment of face and neck
skin for laxity, volume and quality.
The court found the form used language that presupposed
the existence of a medical/therapeutic relationship and “gave
the impression of a relationship between a patient and a
treatment provider”.
Those findings were relevant to the consideration of the duty of
care owed to Ms J. The duty of care owed by the therapist, Ms C,
was to exercise reasonable care, skill and judgment in applying
the treatment, including the duty to provide information about the
nature of known associated risks of harm.
In considering the alleged negligent operation of the ultrasound
device, the court noted that the aim was not to cause damage to
the dermal junction of the skin layers. The treatment did not raise
any communicated suggestions of skin damage of any kind, or of
scarring. The court found that in light of Ms C’s certification and
training, she must have been aware of the risk of facial burns if the
ultrasound was delivered at too high a dose or for too long.
In finding negligence, the judge stated that the activity of
promoting and charging a fee of such a large proportion ($5000)
“carries with it that reasonable care would be taken … in the
performance of the treatment so as not to cause avoidable
damage to the appearance of the plaintiff’s face”.
Informed consent and the assumption of risks by Ms J were
the last issues to be judicially considered. Noteworthy for the
court was that she had not had such ultrasound treatment before
and did not quite understand how it would affect her skin and
therefore asked Ms C how the procedure worked.
She was told it would produce a very good result and make
her skin firmer and look younger, and that the procedure was
safe. During the same conversation, there was no discussion
or information provided concerning any inherent risks of harm
associated with the treatment.
The defendant company also relied on Ms J’s signed
consultation form as evidence of consent. The court rejected this
because “proffering the last page of the consultation form to [Ms J]
to sign after she was already lying down supine on the treatment
bench did not relevantly constitute consent to risk ... At that
time, the treatment had already commenced, with the plaintiff’s
facial skin having been prepared and numbed by an unidentified
anaesthetising cream as the first step in the treatment”.
Further, Ms J was only asked to sign the last page for a “legal
issue” that was not explained or elaborated upon at that time. In
all the circumstances, this did not constitute valid consent, as the
content of the form that related to risk had not been drawn to
Ms J’s attention and made known to her before the treatment.
The permanent facial skin damage, hyperpigmentation,
lumpiness and alteration of facial appearance, when talking or
smiling, resulted in a verdict for Ms J in the sum of $24,557.
This case contains lessons for nurses undertaking cosmetic or
beauty procedures. Courts, depending on the circumstances,
may assess notions of duty of care, negligence, consent and
assumption of risk in line with established medico-legal case law.
The same obligations and duties apply. ■
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School of Nursing, Midwifery and
Nutrition at James Cook University.