industry & reform
Mark Knight. Photo: Herald Sun
recommendations. I think that point about
not waiting is a really important one in
that what’s happened in the past is we
wait until the end and then discover that
the changes that are needed are going
to take a long time. And so I think they’re
right to be saying we’ve got to be doing
something now.”
As for whether the government might
take notice of these concerns, on past form
Ibrahim is unsure.
“I think that both parties and
governments in the past have sat around
waiting, and when they finished waiting,
they haven’t actually done anything.
“And the commission’s paper
highlighting the 18 inquiries that have
been done over the last 20 years clearly
lays it out to the public that when the
government says they’re waiting to the end,
they’re waiting to do nothing, and I think
we need this reaction to address these
[issues], and that would get us prepared
for the recommendations that come next
year,” he said.
BETTER OFF WORKING AT ALDI?
ROYAL COMMISSION WITNESS
TALKS AGED CARE PAY
Nurses working in aged care are paid
so poorly that they are forced to stay
on higher casual rates and work 52
weeks a year to attain a living wage,
the royal commission heard at the third
Melbourne hearing.
Paul Gilbert from the ANMF’s Victorian
Branch also said that due to low pay rates,
nurses often take more than one job to
make ends meet.
8 | nursingreview.com.au
“I think that most people we speak to
do want more hours and occasionally get
more hours, but it’s still not a static like it is
in most other industries, where you know
you’re going to be working three, four,
five days a week. No-one gets to work
full‑time. People are working multiple jobs
to get an income.”
The pay for personal care workers is also
poor, according to Gilbert.
“The comment I hear when I go and
have meetings is, ‘I could get paid more
working on the checkout at Aldi,’ and it’s
technically true, because they see those
jobs advertised with an hourly rate of $24
to $26 dollars. Our enrolled nurse and
registered nurse members are paid more
than the personal care worker cohort, but
not a whole lot more,” he said.
Also appearing at the Melbourne hearing
was nurse practitioner Amy Lazzaro, who
believes that high staff turnover is linked to
poor pay.
Lazzaro, who runs a geriatric outreach
program covering a district of 832,000
people in Western Sydney, said: “A lot of
[staff] report back to me that turnover is
subsequent to pay.”
She also told the commission that she
was “shocked” at the staffing mixes and
numbers in aged care.
Lazzaro said that obtaining full patients’
histories when she enters a facility is
difficult because the nurses on site are
too busy.
“I started the service and got out there
on the road in 2015. I was shocked, to be
honest. There are a large number of carers
or assistants in nursing that work within
residential aged care. They seem to make
up the bulk of the workforce,” she said.
“I found that the RNs are responsible for
sometimes a whole level or a whole wing
of the nursing home, with one RN on to
maybe 50 or 80 residents.
“And then they’re working within their
shift with a large number of assistants
in nursing whom they’re responsible for
overseeing within a shift. And I think that’s
quite challenging for them working in
those conditions.”
She also believes that assistant staff
training – often only 12 weeks – is “poor”
and that nurse assistants and care workers
are often “ill-equipped for what they’re
walking into” compared to RNs.
Asked if she could change one thing
about the residential aged care system,
Lazzaro replied: “I would implement nurse
to patient ratios, including more RNs on
per shift and over a 24-hour period, and
I would most definitely implement more
education and ongoing training to nurses
at all levels on all nursing topics within
aged care”.
COMMONWEALTH M.I.A. ON
AGED CARE WORKFORCE: ROYAL
COMMISSION LAWYER
The Commonwealth appears to be missing
in action. This was senior counsel assisting
Peter Rozen’s assertion as he discussed
governance and leadership within the aged
care sector while wrapping up a week of
royal commission hearings centred on the
aged care workforce.
Rozen said the Commonwealth needs
to demonstrate leadership and commit
the resources necessary to ensure delivery
of an aged care system that meets
community standards, and, he added, “it
needs to act quickly”.
“There appears to be a lack of leadership
and expertise about aged care within the
Department of Health,” he said.
That concern was echoed by Benetas
chief executive Sandra Hills, who appeared
at the royal commission on Thursday and
called for a Cabinet minister for ageing.
When Rozen asked Hills at the hearing
if the Department of Health was providing
enough leadership, she responded: “No.”
Earlier in the day, Rozen pushed health
department secretary Glenys Beauchamp
on the topic of Commonwealth leadership
as it related to Australia’s Aged Care
Workforce Strategy, put together by
Professor John Pollaers.
At the heart of the back and forth was
a briefing note on the Pollaers report