technology
experience as empathic, and environments that are demanding,
exhausting and stressful. So there really is a crisis.
What’s changing, and why has it been increasingly important
to talk about?
There are some really interesting and important studies that have
shown a real generational shift in empathy levels, particularly over
the last decade. There was a large study with nearly 14,000 young
people in it in the US that identified that empathy levels have
declined by more than 40 per cent over the last 30 years, with the
steepest decline occurring in the last 10 years. And a lot of that has
been attributed to the increased use of social media, but obviously
there are other reasons.
And in healthcare, we generally expect graduates to have an
empathic disposition. However, a body of evidence has shown
that empathy levels generally decline by up to 50 per cent during
the period of enrolment in an undergraduate nursing or medical
degree. So whereas students may start off with relatively high levels
of empathy, and the research shows that they do, it really does drop
off while they’re enrolled. And it’s been attributed to lots of factors.
Curricula tend to focus on knowledge and skills – technical skills –
and we prioritise those as a humanistic value, such as empathy, and
we don’t usually teach or directly assess empathy skills. So that’s
problematic. And we expose students to human suffering without
adequate preparation and support. We don’t help them to become
resilient. We don’t focus on students developing their own empathic
skills. We just kind of present them in healthcare settings and expect
them to maintain empathy, and it doesn’t actually happen.
Although more and more healthcare programs are starting
to implement educational interventions specifically focused on
empathy levels, very few of them have been evaluated. So that’s
one of the things we’re doing in our project.
So how can nurses and aged care professionals be more
empathetic?
They can become more empathic through a number of different
mechanisms. For example, we know that mindfulness – and in
particular, loving kindness meditations – really allows people to be
more empathic. In universities, we’re actually focusing on teaching
empathy. There are a number of different strategies: we’re
introducing digital stories, simulations, activities and experiences
that allow students to walk in the patient’s shoes, to see the
healthcare experience through the eyes of a patient, so that
they understand what it feels like, what it looks like. And then we
challenge them through lots of discussion, debriefing and debates
to reconsider their attitudes, biases and preconceptions, and to
imagine how they can provide more empathic care.
Is empathy nurtured or learned?
Both. Most people are hard-wired with empathy: even a baby will
cry if it sees another baby cry. So we are hard-wired. About 98 per
cent of people have an empathic disposition, or what we call a
trait empathy. However, empathy is also a stake or a skill. So we
could be empathic to one group of people, and to another group
of people we may be indifferent, and yet to another group we
may actually be biased against them, because our empathy levels
fluctuate at different times in our lives depending on what we’ve
got going on based on our experiences and knowledge of other
people, and our understanding of other people.
But there is a body of research that says we can target empathy.
And targeting empathy is actually key to changing attitudes and
the behaviours of healthcare professionals, particularly towards
the vulnerable and stigmatised patient groups. And they are the
ones that we worry about most, because we know that people
who are from a vulnerable group – for example, older people,
people who don’t speak English, people with a mental illness,
homeless people – are the people that need empathy the most,
but ironically they are the people who are least likely to experience
empathic healthcare interactions.
What did your research focus on?
Our research was founded on a quote that came from a Bristol
Royal Infirmary report, which said that it’s in the formative years
of undergraduate education that attitudes are forged and skills
imparted which shape the quality of engagement with patients for
years to come. So that’s the quote that really drove us, and what
we were focusing on is, how do you teach and evaluate empathy?
Our research is multifocused and very collaborative, so
members of the Empathy Initiative group, which is developing
the Virtual Empathy Museum, have conducted a wide range of
projects over the last four or five years, designed to enhance
healthcare students’ and professionals’ level of empathy towards
people from vulnerable groups.
And the Virtual Empathy Museum was designed to capitalise
on that work, that previous research that had been done, and to
disseminate it and get it out there.
So the museum’s quite unique, because it’s a digital resource,
and it is a repository of web-based, authentic and engaging
curriculum materials. And we’re collecting, creating and curating
them in a format that means they will be readily available to
educators, both in universities and in healthcare settings, so they
can use them to enhance people’s empathy levels.
And you know, it’s a wide range of different curriculum
materials. It includes simulation, tool kits, digital stories and
meditation resources. And they can be used flexibly. They’re
authentic, because they’ve been co-created with patients and
people that are the recipients of healthcare, and they’re very
engaging and exciting. What we’ve done is not just create them,
but evaluated them. So we know they work.
How did the ATN grant for the Virtual Empathy Museum come
about?
The museum is funded by the Australian Technology Network of
Universities Strategic Initiative Grant. That network of universities
includes UTS, Curtin, RMIT and the University of South Australia.
They provide a small amount of funding each year directly aimed
at facilitating scholarship and research into learning and teaching,
and to supporting innovative teaching and learning approaches
that will promote systemic change.
We were fortunate because we already had the Empathy
Initiative research group, so we were already doing work in this
area. When the grants were announced, we came together and
submitted an application and we were successful.
Is there anything else you’d like to add?
I should mention that we’re launching the Virtual Empathy
Museum on the 7th of December in Sydney, at the Mercure Hotel,
and we’ve got our Empathy Symposium, where we’ve got a whole
range of plenary speakers and a really exciting day planned. Our
aim is to create a conversation or even a movement where people
come together and network and brainstorm about empathy, how it
can be taught, and why it matters. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 29