clinical practice
PC gone mad?
Political correctness could
obscure obese patient data.
Kim McClean interviewed by Megan Tran
N
SW Health recently warned doctors
against using the term 'obese' to
preserve the dignity of patients,
but a work health and safety manager has
argued the term is important for patient
admissions data.
At the Australian College of Nursing’s
recent National Nursing Forum, WA
Country Health Service’s (WACHS)
Kim McClean spoke about the importance
of obesity coding accuracy in mitigating
patient handling risks to healthcare staff.
She said the guidelines instructed
doctors to use positive language when
discussing the weight of their patients as
well as talking in a non-judgmental manner.
Doctors were advised not to use words
like ‘skinny’, ‘malnourished’ and ‘morbidly
20 | nursingreview.com.au
obese’, and instead use terms like ‘well
above healthy weight’, she said.
McClean said the problem with this
is that obese is a clinical term, not a
derogatory one, and is defined by a BMI
rating of above 30.
The use of subjective words doesn’t result
in clinical findings, so the use of data will
be voided, meaning we can’t identify those
who are obese, she said.
Her pilot study examined the use of
obesity terms and indicators in WACHS
patient admission data to quantify obese
patient admissions, determine the accuracy
of obesity coded data within the patient
admission data, and examine the availability
of alternate methods of determining and
recording obesity.
It reviewed 310 records of adults who were
admitted to WACHS hospitals between 2015
and 2017 with type 2 diabetes (associated
with obesity).
“Seven methods of quantitative analysis
were used to determine accuracy of obesity
coding between medical file content and
admission data,“ the study said.
“An examination of current coding
practices and clinical note taking was
also conducted in order to provide
recommendations for improved obesity
coding.“
McClean said the study would support
what she suspected – that the use of
the word obese would be able to lead
to improvements in data recording and
accuracy, and in turn better support staff.
She added that, with accurate data, we
can show trends, and the data can be used
to increase resources like wheelchairs,
which will reduce the risk of injury to
nursing staff.
Nursing Review spoke with McClean to
find out more.
NR: Why has NSW Health warned
doctors against using the term 'obese'?
KM: NSW Health released a policy in 2017
advising doctors not to tell patients they’re
obese. The aim of this policy is about
respect for patients and preserving dignity,
and these are themes that all Australian
health services support. The guidelines
instructed doctors to use positive language
when discussing the weight of their patients,
as well as talking in a non-judgmental
manner. And doctors are being told to not
use words like 'skinny', 'malnourished' and
'morbidly obese', and instead use terms like
'well above healthy weight'.
The problem we have, and where my
research is certainly pointing towards,
is that obese is a clinical term. It’s not a