industry & reform
A job for the royal commission
The impact of poor staffing levels and
private-for-profit ownership on quality of care.
By Julie Henderson
T
he recent announcement of a royal commission into aged
care has brought into focus the staffing levels and skill mix
of residential aged care facilities.
Demand for aged care services is increasing due to the
ageing of the Baby Boomer population and post-war migration,
leading to concerns with the costs of providing aged care
services. To address perceptions of rising costs, the current
federal government has made changes to aged care funding
and legislation, making it easier for private-for-profit groups to
purchase and manage residential aged care facilities.
The changes made include increased user payments to
facilities through the reintroduction of a refundable deposit to
pay accommodation costs, the capacity to charge for additional
services, and legislative changes to make it easier to transfer
ownership of aged care beds. These changes, along with
guaranteed funding from the federal government through ACFI
payments, make aged care attractive for investors.
At the same time, concerns have been raised about having
enough staff to meet service demand. Currently, care services in
residential aged care are provided by a combination of nursing
and care worker staff, with the balance of staffing shifting towards
care workers in the last 10–15 years. Care workers are cheaper
to employ and provide a means of achieving cost savings and
increasing returns to investors. Cost savings can also be achieved
by employing fewer staff.
As a consequence, residents are receiving fewer hours of care.
In 2015, residents in Australian residential aged care facilities
received 39.8 hours of direct care/fortnight, which averaged up to
2.86 hours/resident per day.
A recent study which used activity timings for the care tasks
required for residents with a range of diagnoses determined that
between 2.5 and 5 hours of care were indicated, suggesting that
residents are experiencing shortfalls in the number of hours of
care they receive.
A team from Flinders University and the University of South
Australia recently conducted a study of nurses’ and care workers’
perceptions of the level of care which was missed in residential
aged care and the reasons why care was missed. The study,
which was commissioned by the ANMF, surveyed 3206 staff
10 | nursingreview.com.au
working in aged care settings across Australia, including aged
care wards in public hospitals and multipurpose services. Missed
care for this study was defined as required resident care that is
omitted (either in part or in whole) or delayed due to multiple
demands and inadequate staffing and material resources, and/or
communication breakdown.
The central finding was that staff believed that care was being
missed in all facilities, with higher levels of missed care reported in
facilities which are privately owned.
Unscheduled tasks, such as responding to call bells and to
toileting needs within five minutes, were most likely to be missed,
although there were deficits in completing all tasks.
When asked to indicate the reasons why care was missed, staff in
all facilities viewed too few staff, the complexity of resident needs,
inadequate skill mix of nursing and care work staff, and unbalanced
resident allocation as the greatest reasons for missed care.
Government employees reported significantly lower scores for
16 of the 27 items than staff employed in privately owned facilities,
with staff in private-for-profit owned facilities rating 14 of the 27
items as being a greater cause of missed care than staff in other
settings. These differences were most notable in relation to access
to resources.
Staff/resident ratios were also found to be higher in privately
owned facilities, meaning each staff member was delivering care
to more residents and had less time with each resident to complete
care tasks. There is also some evidence from responses to open
questions that enrolled nurses were being replaced by care workers
and of employment of recently graduated registered nurses over
more experienced registered nurses in private-for-profit facilities.
Given that people are being admitted to residential aged
care when they are frail and more dependent on services than
previously, and that residential aged care facilities are dealing with
higher proportions of residents with dementia, staff are dealing
with residents who have more complex needs and greater need for
nursing care. At the moment, there are no mandated staffing levels
for residential aged care, with the standards only stipulating that
adequate staffing be provided. This allows residential aged care
facilities to reduce running costs through cutting staffing levels.
It may be timely, therefore, for the royal commission to explore
the impact of private-for-profit ownership on quality of care
and to consider the establishment of mandated staffing levels to
ensure resident safety. ■
Dr Julie Henderson is a research associate at Flinders University
where she undertakes nursing and public health research.