Nursing Review Issue 6 | Nov-Dec 2016 | Page 36

specialty focus
specialty focus
What were you able to gather about the prevalence of post-traumatic stress and what else did the responses reveal about the impact traumatic births have on midwives? Overall, the study showed that witnessing birth trauma had a strong impact on midwives’ emotional health. Almost one-fifth( 17 per cent) of midwives in the study reported re-experiencing, hyperarousal and avoidance symptoms after witnessing a traumatic birth event and met the criteria for probable PTSD. Many other midwives in the study had symptoms below the threshold for probable PTSD. This shows that a post-traumatic stress response to witnessing traumatic birth events is common among midwives.
Midwives also recalled feeling helpless( 92 per cent) or horrified( 75 per cent) after witnessing the traumatic birth event. Half of the midwives( 51 per cent) recalled an immediate reaction of fear. About two-thirds( 65.3 per cent) recalled feeling guilty about what happened to the woman and almost half( 46.7 per cent) felt responsible for the traumatic event they had witnessed.
Midwives who recalled an index birth trauma event that included interpersonal trauma features had much stronger emotional reactions than midwives who witnessed birth trauma without interpersonal trauma features. Midwives who witnessed disrespectful or abusive care as part of a traumatic birth event were 20 times more likely to recall anger, six times more likely to recall feeling powerless and four times more likely to recall reacting with horror. They also were twice as likely to feel guilty or responsible for what happened to the woman.
How might traumatic births and post-traumatic stress affect midwives personally and professionally? We have seen that midwives have a powerful emotional response to witnessing birth trauma, in particular when the birth trauma included features of disrespectful and abusive care. Overall, midwives’ strong reaction is an indication of their emotional proximity to the women they care for during labour and birth. Midwives’ feelings of horror during the witnessing of interpersonal, care-related birth trauma suggests they perceive this form of birth trauma as a threat to their sense of personal and professional integrity.
In addition to causing personal suffering, post-traumatic stress may also affect important areas of midwives’ professional functioning, including empathy. In midwifery practice, empathic abilities facilitate good care by enabling midwives to create and maintain supportive relationships with women. Conversely, reduced empathic abilities in midwives may lead to emotionally distant care. Women may report this as unsupportive or even neglectful care. In turn, experiences of unsupportive care are associated with decreased perinatal mental health and can affect women beyond the postnatal period.
Besides reducing midwives’ empathic abilities, post-traumatic stress also has the potential to affect the quality of midwives’ clinical decision-making, by increasing their perceptions of risk in clinical practice. For midwives, overestimation of the likelihood of adverse events occurring during labour and birth can have severe implications for clinical decision making and affect overall professional performance.
What could the prevalence of post-traumatic stress mean for the profession as a whole? The profession needs to take the issue of post-traumatic stress seriously. It touches the heart of the profession if it adversely affects midwives’ [ empathic abilities and the ] close and supportive relationships with women in their care.
The paper called for a reduction in the incidence of traumatic birth events experienced by women and witnessed by midwives. What is needed to tackle this issue and what else can be done to reduce potential post-traumatic stress? To reduce trauma in the maternity care context, it is key that maternity care organisations systemically target birth trauma by introducing trauma-informed care and practice. This aims to promote an organisational culture of awareness. An essential component of trauma-informed care and practice is that health services do not inflict additional trauma on consumers or staff. Research into organisations has identified that traumatisation is less likely to happen in those with flat management structures and where adequate decision-making authority is allocated to all involved professional groups. This creates a safer environment for patients. In maternity care, in contrast, we often have clinical environments that are hierarchical. The survey also asked about midwives’ decision authority at the time they witnessed the traumatic birth event. Midwives with higher levels of decision-making authority witnessed less care-related birth trauma and also had fewer symptoms of post-traumatic stress. So increasing midwives’ autonomy during the provision of labour and birth care may reduce the overall incidence of birth trauma. Since the trauma burden is high in maternity services, this is an important area for future research. ■
nursingreview. com. au | 17