specialty focus
specialty focus
Midwives battle PTSD
These professionals establish personal bonds while performing perinatal care and can have severe reactions if their patients have traumatic births.
Julia Leinweber interviewed by Dallas Bastian
The events midwives witness and participate in on the job may increase their vulnerability to post-traumatic stress disorder, new research suggests.
The study, led by Dr Julia Leinweber at Griffith University, found almost one-fifth of 707 midwives surveyed met the criteria for probable PTSD, as laid out by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, edition 4.
Leinweber surveyed midwives across all types of healthcare settings, aiming to get a sense of their feelings of competence during stressful moments. Co-author professor Jenny Gamble, from the Menzies Health Institute Queensland, says events midwives may encounter include the death or injury of a mother or baby during birth, abusive care by family members or simply care that is not undertaken in a sensitive way.
“ Midwives, unfortunately, often say they feel powerless to intervene to change the way care is [ applied ] by other healthcare providers, or they may feel pressured to make a decision by another professional,” Gamble says.“ Alternatively, they may feel that the mother’ s expressed wishes are overridden by organisational requirements of the hospital during the birth. If a midwife feels that she can’ t do anything about these situations, [ they ] can produce feelings of stress, which can escalate.”
Nursing Review sits down with Leinweber to discuss the personal and professional impact traumatic births have on midwives and what must be done to reduce birth trauma.
NR: What are some of the traumatic events Australian midwives encounter daily? JL: Many midwives witness disrespectful, or even what they perceive as abusive, treatment of women during labour and birth. This could involve observing disrespectful ways of communicating with a woman during labour and birth or watching a woman being persuaded or pressured into agreeing to a procedure that is not in her or her baby’ s best interests. Less common forms of witnessed birth trauma are related to unexpected emergency caesareans or vaginal operative births.
The survey used a standardised measure to assess post-traumatic stress symptoms in midwives. What aspects of births and the role of the midwife did the survey home in on? Whilst there is evidence that witnessing traumatic birth events does affect midwives, my PhD study is the first to investigate post-traumatic stress as a result of different types of birth trauma exposure. A Traumatic Events in Perinatal Care List( TEPCL) was developed for the study. This measure distinguishes between interpersonal, care-related birth trauma and non-interpersonal birth trauma. Interpersonal, care-related birth trauma includes disrespectful and abusive care. Non-interpersonal birth trauma is often related to obstetric emergencies and may include death or severe injury of mother or baby.
We know midwives are often emotionally close to women and may identify with women they care for during labour and birth. These are special features of midwifery care that enable midwives to provide sensitive intrapartum care and meet the needs of the mother. Receiving sensitive intrapartum care is important to women and it enhances their birth experience and postpartum wellbeing. However, these features may render midwives particularly vulnerable to experiencing distress when witnessing birth trauma.
16 | nursingreview. com. au