clinical practice
clinical practice
Meetings of minds
There is no substitute for the authentic
experience third-year nursing students get from
personal interactions with consumers who
are living with mental illness or its aftermath.
Fiona Orr interviewed by Dallas Bastian
T
he University of Technology
Sydney is bringing nursing students
together with people who have
lived experience of mental illness to build
rapport and empathy.
In a collaboration with fellow UTS
academics and healthcare consumers,
health academic Fiona Orr developed the
‘Making It Real’ simulation, which gives
third-year nursing students the opportunity
to practise newly learnt, recovery-focused,
therapeutic communication skills in a safe,
simulated environment.
Students speak freely with consumers
and learn about their healthcare
experiences and recovery process.
Orr says being able to show sensitivity
and respect, build rapport and demonstrate
empathy are vital skills that facilitate the
development of trusting, collaborative
partnerships between healthcare providers
and consumers.
“It’s a privilege to be with people, to
listen to their story and to support and
assist them in whichever ways you can,”
22 | nursingreview.com.au
she adds. “When someone experiences
a mental illness, they can feel very
vulnerable, so it’s important that nurses are
trustworthy, compassionate and interested
in supporting the person.”
Nursing Review sits down with Orr
to learn more about Making it Real and
the skills students develop through this
approach to learning.
NR: One of the aims of the sessions is to
foster empathy amongst the students.
How important is empathy when
interacting with patients with a history of
mental health issues?
FO: Empathy is important for any nurse
interacting with any healthcare consumer,
and certainly that’s the case when
somebody might have had a mental health
problem. It’s important for all nurses to try
to get an understanding of the particular
person’s experience in life. Trying to see it
from that person’s perspective, not your
own and in terms of how you live and the
life you have, but from the view of this
particular person to whom you’re relating.
That can be difficult for students,
particularly if they haven’t had any lived
experiences of mental ill health themselves,
or haven’t known many people who have.
All people have mental health needs, so
when student’s work in healthcare settings,
they will need to be able to empathise
with an individual mental health problem
or concern, and sometimes that will be
an actual illness experience the person is
having, or the consequences of living with
an illness.
What are some other vital skills students
may hone through these sessions?
When we run this live simulation with
guests who have a lived experience,
the students get to practise therapeutic
communication. Even before they ask
any questions about the individual’s
experience, they need to be able to engage
with the person, to connect and develop
some rapport, rather than just launching in
and wanting to know answers.
[The simulation] gets them to connect
with a real person; it’s happening right in
front of them. Even if they do come with
sort of prepared questions or ideas, they
soon find out they’ve got to connect with
this person at this moment, and it’s up to
the guest to decide what they would like to
share or not.
The students get quite a good
opportunity to develop [skills for] engaging
and rapport building, and then some of the
therapeutic communication skills in terms
of expressing empathy, asking open-ended
questions, and also becoming mindful of
their own non-verbal communication and
how they’re feeling through the interaction.
That’s often a good insight for the health
professionals or the nurses to monitor:
‘How am I reacting to what this person is
saying, or telling me, or revealing to me?’
These are personal pieces of information
that are being given, and it sort of gets
students to think they’re dealing with a
real person, not a diagnosis, not a set of
symptoms, and they’ve got to interact with
the person who is right before them, right
here, right now.
How are the simulations run? What do
students experience?
The students form pairs and each pair
interacts with one of our invited guests.
They’re all sitting in separate spaces. The
students interact with the guests who have
the lived experience for about 20 minutes.
This simulation is situated in the final
year of the mental health nursing subject,
so the students are trying to engage
with the consumer and get a sense of
what recovery means to that individual.
For many students, clinical practice
experiences might have been more around
understanding diagnostic groups, and
signs and symptoms of illness, and perhaps
seeing mental health consumers receiving
care in acute services. But here, they’re
working with somebody who’s not acutely
unwell, and has much experience using
services and recovering from illness.
In that 20 minutes, [the students] are
getting quite an insight as to what it’s
like to live with and recover from mental
illness and what ways they could make a
difference. These are students who are
about to go out into the healthcare system
as registered nurses.
That’s how the simulation runs. The
healthcare consumer then gives the
students immediate feedback about how the
interaction went, and those are constructive
comments. The students get to see what
they’ve done quite well, how they’ve
connected, the kinds of questioning they
used, the kind of rapport they develo ped. The
consumers will also give some constructive
feedback in terms of areas the students could
develop a bit further.
After the students have the interaction
and receive the feedback, [all of the
students return] and we process in a large
group the experience they have just had,
with the consumers present. We talk
about what they gained from it as learning
experience and how they might be able to
use that in their practice, what they might
now do differently once they go out to
healthcare services.
Also, there is a self-reflection template
that they work on in their pairs, where they
start reflecting on the experience they
just had and document areas where they
think they did quite well, and the kinds of
communication techniques they used, and
areas where they think they could develop
further. They reflect on the feedback the
healthcare consumer has given them and
how they can make sense of that and use
in practice.
The whole simulation is about a
two-hour experience for the class.
What feedback have you received from
the students and the consumers who
were involved in the sessions?
We asked students to volunteer and
complete an evaluation of the simulation,
and many of them choose to do that,
which is great. Overwhelmingly, what
comes out is that they say this is such a
unique opportunity. They say they’ve never
done such a simulation throughout their
three-year degree. Even more so, they’ve
never received feedback directly from the
healthcare consumer when out on their
nursing placements. It would be rare for
someone using a health service to turn
around and have a conversation with a
student about how an interaction just went,
or offer an observation about the nursing
student’s practice. It just wouldn’t tend
to happen.
The students also say it helps them see
beyond the illness and the diagnosis, to
the person behind them. It highlights that
they always need to remember that when
interacting in practice, every person is
indeed an individual.
They often say things like, ‘We should
have more of these simulations. We should
have them throughout the three years of
our program where we interact with real
people and not actors, and not in a roleplay setting, but with an actual healthcare
consumer with lived experience.’
The healthcare consumers, the guests
in our simulations, enjoy the experience
and their feedback is that they also think
it’s a unique learning/teaching strategy.
They see it as incredibly important … [and]
they say they need to see more of that
empathic interaction going on, with health
professionals being able to connect with
the experience and listening to what the
healthcare consumer has to say about how
they would like their recovery to go.
This is the third year I’ve run the
simulation, and every year I get more and
more consumers who are interested in
joining us. Even our original three or four
consumers have continued doing this with
us because they see it as so valuable in
terms of the students getting insights they
perhaps don’t get when they’re out on their
clinical placements.
Based on the feedback from students, do
you think other education providers and
healthcare organisations should set up
similar education programs?
It’s something that all providers of
education – not only for nursing students
but for all health profession students –
would benefit from. Ideally, I would like
to extend this program within our degree
program at UTS, and have it in one of my
other mental health nursing subjects,
where we have more than 600 students
undertaking a core mental health subject.
It’s being run in a subject for students
who elect it. We have about 100 students
in that subject, but we have much wider,
larger subjects where I’d like to see every
nursing student at UTS get this experience
of making it real, and I’m sure it’d be of
benefit to all students across the country. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 23