clinical practice
You found that older people believed
the pain care was based on a formulaic
assessment and that it often wasn’t
good enough.
Does it hurt when I do this?
You conducted an ethnographic study.
What does that involve?
Study asks how well nurses
understand patient pain.
Joanne Harmon interviewed by Conor Burke
R
esearch has found that pain care for
hospitalised patients over 65 years
old is assessment driven and lacks
sufficient patient input.
The study revealed that pain care was
hampered due to a lack of appropriate and
meaningful pain care provision, and that
nurses lacked insight and understanding on
the nature of pain for the older person.
In addition, for people with dementia who
come to hospital from residential aged care,
the lack of an advocate and the inability to
communicate can hinder pain care further.
The study raises questions about the
current pain assessment models used and
whether pain management needs to be
re-evaluated.
To find out more, Nursing Review spoke
with lead author Joanne Harmon from the
University of South Australia’s School of
Nursing and Midwifery.
NR: What prompted your research?
JH: I undertook this research as part of
my nursing PhD. I was interested in the
culturally mediated barriers nurses face
when they assess and manage pain for the
older person in a hospital setting.
I went to two different hospitals and
watched the nurses when they were
providing pain care for the older person.
I interviewed the nurses and patients to get
their views on the pain care.
That’s when you explore a situation. You
come in with a preconceived question,
and you immerse yourself in the setting to
discover the insider’s view of something.
When I was in the hospitals, I spent over
1000 hours doing observation. We had
acute care, medical/surgical oncology and
sub-acute, and I watched nurses during the
day, night and evening shifts.
You watch and observe what is going on,
then you undertake interviews, which are
semi-structured, so you have a basic set of
questions. As you go through the process,
your questions become more focused until
you try to experience all the different ways
in which a process happens, so you can
have saturation of your data.
I did multiple interviews of non-registered
nurses over about six months. I interviewed
about 11 older people over that time as well.
What sort of questions were you putting
to the nurses and the older people?
The questions you ask are very open, like:
“Why are you in hospital?”, “Can you talk to
me about what it’s like to do all the tests?”,
and “What’s it like to have a nurse provide
pain care provision for you?”
Older people are very talkative and quite
happy to discuss what it’s like to have a
nurse providing pain care.
As for the nurses, I would ask: “What’s it
like to care for an older person in an acute
care setting?”, “What’s it like to provide pain
care for an older person?”, and “What are
your perceptions about providing pain care
for an older person?”
I would follow them on, but generally
assessing multiple interviews when the
nurse says: “Well, in this situation I would
do this or that.” You can always tie it back
to the observation you saw. And then you
get the variances and the social rules, or the
reasons, for why they did it that way.
For an older person, good pain care should
be safe, effective and provide relief.
I found a massive disconnect, because
the nurses were focused on gaining a
numerical value for the intensity of the pain
at that point in time. They’d ask the older
person to rate their pain out of 10, but the
older person responded differently – and
importantly, they didn’t use numerical
values when talking about their pain.
What I found was that the lack of
inclusion of the older person’s input makes
us have to rethink what is evidence-based
best practice in this context.
The other important research finding
was that nurses lacked an understanding
of the nature of the older person’s pain.
It was a common theme. The nurses
spoke about the older person denying
they had pain, or that they wouldn’t tell the
nurses they had pain. They were listening,
but they weren’t hearing the context of
what the older person was saying.
There was a disconnect or dissonance
between what the nurses thought the
nature of the older person’s pain was,
and what the older person thought of
the nurses’ thinking about the nature of
their pain.
It was interesting to see the representation
of something as intensely personal and
subjective as pain, and the difficulties nurses
have when trying to encapsulate that and
put it into an objective measurement.
They tend to skew more towards the
organisational compliance for auditing,
as opposed to gaining an understanding
of what is happening for the older person
and being able to transfer that onto the
next nurse, the next ward, or even the next
hospital the older person goes to.
Do we need different assessment
tools or more training for dealing with
older patients?
The last thing any nurse wants to hear is:
“We need another form.”
The fact is, these pain assessment tools
for the older person – particularly those
with dementia, cognitive impairment or a
disability – do exist and are in position.
What we need is to have the tools in the
patient’s notes or medical records, so they
follow the older person on the journey
through the hospital system. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 25