LEGAL CORNER
Needle and the
damage done
A moment of carelessness
lands a nurse in court.
By Scott Trueman
I
n any action alleging negligence by a
nurse, it is for the plaintiff to prove a
number of ‘ingredients’.
One ingredient is whether the actions of
the nurse fell below the reasonable standard
expected of the skill and knowledge of the
nurse in question. Hence, reference is made
to the skill and knowledge of the nurse in
question. This can be a factually difficult test
to ‘defend’ if the nurse, over time, has no
recollection of the alleged negligent action.
In such a situation, the court must make
a factual determination. A recent case
involving the giving of a heparin injection
is illustrative.
The plaintiff (patient) in 2013 had
embarked on a program to improve her
fitness and lose weight. She succeeded
in losing 35kg. This resulted in excess
abdominal skin. On 17 May 2014 she saw
Dr M, a plastic surgeon, who discussed
with her the possibilities of treatment by
abdominoplasty.
Dr M operated on the plaintiff on
11 August 2014. The plaintiff returned to
the ward at about 2pm. Dr M also ordered
the administration of heparin to be given by
subcutaneous injection twice daily.
The plaintiff received the first injection of
heparin at 8am on 12 August. That injection
was given by a nurse who “pinched” the
plaintiff’s left thigh and administered the
injection just beneath the skin. The plaintiff
10 | nursingreview.com.au
had no pain at the time of the injection and
no complications afterwards.
The second injection was administered by
Nurse N, at about 8pm on the same day.
The plaintiff gave the following evidence:
“He came into the room. He was holding a
green tray … He prepared the injection and
then put it straight into my thigh, and he did
not pinch my skin. I had instant pain, it was
like a bee sting, and I said ‘Ouch’.”
The plaintiff’s husband, who was at the
bedside, supported the plaintiff’s evidence.
Nurse N did not remember at trial giving
the injection. He gave evidence that he
had significant experience giving various
types of injections, including subcutaneous
injections. He said that as a result of his
training, he adopted a “standard practice,
an invariable practice”. He described his
technique for giving a heparin injection in
detail. This involved “gathering” as much
subcutaneous tissue as he could and then
gently inserting the needle at a 45-degree
angle. He would then slowly inject the
medication, taking about 30 seconds to
empty the syringe. His nursing notes made
no mention of the heparin injection.
The plaintiff asserted that after the
injection she had pain in her thigh. The next
morning, she noticed a lump in the area of
the injection. The plaintiff described the pain
to an RMO as extending across her thigh
to the top of the knee and the back of her
leg, and further, that the area hurt when
touched. This remained the situation until
the plaintiff was discharged on 15 August.
This situation continued post discharge,
despite follow-up consultations and various
treatments.
In essence, the plaintiff alleged that the
defendant (Nurse N):
1. Failed to pinch the skin up, lift or pull
the top layer of skin away from the
muscle before administering the heparin
injection, so as to inject into the superficial
subcutaneous fat and avoid injecting into
the deeper subcutaneous region of the
lateral femoral cutaneous nerve, thereby
damaging the nerve.
2. Injected the needle into the deeper
subcutaneous region of the lateral femoral
cutaneous nerve and damaged the nerve.
The decision focused on factual findings
by the trial judge, who stated: “I accept that
for a nurse such as Nurse N, the giving of a
heparin injection was a reasonably routine
mechanical task ... However, Nurse N’s
complete lack of recollection of the specific
injection … means he can only assert
what he believes he would have done by
reference to his usual, or ‘invariable’, practice.
I should note that I have some difficulty with
the notion of an invariable practice. Ordinary
human experience suggests that there can
always be momentary lapses or careless
errors in the performance of mundane or
routine tasks.
“That being said, Nurse N impressed
me as an earnest and hardworking nurse.
However, I have no doubt he had a busy
workload and I infer that he was probably
under time pressure to complete his tasks
before the end of his shift at 10pm.
“I am satisfied that Nurse N did administer
the injection in a manner which fell below
the standard of care to be expected of
a nurse in his position. Whether due to
the pressure of work, or just momentary
carelessness, he inserted the needle at an
angle which allowed the point to penetrate
the deeper tissues overlying the plaintiff’s
left thigh muscle.
“I find that he probably did not attempt
to ‘pinch’ the skin on the plaintiff’s thigh, or
that if he did make that attempt, he did not
do so effectively. The injection did cause
immediate sharp pain to the plaintiff who
made an exclamation to the effect of what
both she and her husband testified to.”
Accordingly, judgement was entered in
favour of the plaintiff. Damages recoverable
by the plaintiff amounted to over $250,000.
A momentary lapse of concentration
in not pinching the skin or inserting the
needle correctly can have serious monetary
consequences for a nurse’s employer – in
this case, over a quarter of a million dollars.
No matter how small the issue, nursing
notes are a nurse’s best friend. Why?
Because memories fade and we cannot be
expected to remember every nursing care
task we undertake years later, particularly
those that are minor and routine. In this
case, the time between the injection and
the trial was about five years. n
Scott Trueman is a lecturer in the School
of Nursing, Midwifery and Nutrition at
James Cook University.