news
What’s in a name?
Alternatives to the word ‘cancer’ are needed,
researchers say.
P
atients who are told they have cancer for low risk conditions
are more likely to choose surgery than those who hear
different terms for their diagnosis.
To curb this trend, academics are calling for the removal of the
‘cancer’ label – where appropriate.
Bond University senior research fellow Dr Ray Moynihan put it
bluntly: “It’s time to stop telling people with a very low risk condition
that they have ‘cancer’ if they are very unlikely to be harmed by it.”
Writing in the BMJ, Moynihan, along with researchers from
the University of Sydney and the Mayo Clinic in the US, said the
call follows a growing body of evidence that says describing
a condition using terms like ‘cancer’ can lead to an increased
preference for more invasive treatments.
The BMJ analysis pointed to a study of 394 women to highlight
this impact. The research found that when ductal carcinoma in
situ (DCIS) was described as a ‘non-invasive cancer’, just under half
(47 per cent) of the women preferred surgery over non-surgical
treatment options such as medication or active surveillance,
whereas just a third (34 per cent) preferred surgery when it
was described as a ‘breast lesion’ and 31 per cent when it was
described as ‘abnormal cells’.
Co-author Professor Kirsten McCaffery from the University
of Sydney said while active surveillance is increasingly being
recognised as a safe management option for some patients with
cancer, there is still a strong belief that aggressive treatments are
always needed.
The authors added that the way clinicians categorise conditions
and recommend treatments may also be influenced by labels.
“Several factors may drive them to overdiagnose and overtreat,
albeit unconsciously,” they wrote. “According to a recent review
of the literature, potential drivers of overdiagnosis include fear
of litigation or missing disease, an overemphasis on the need to
diagnose, a lack of awareness of potential iatrogenic harms, and
the challenge of doing nothing rather than something.
“Removing the cancer label from low risk conditions may
help shift clinicians’ perspectives and enable them to feel more
comfortable recommending less invasive options to patients.”
The authors added that change requires discussions between
key cancer classification and staging groups, health agencies,
cancer societies, consumer groups and citizens.
They also noted that while an alternative label needs to be
biologically accurate, it also needs to be something that patients
can understand and that won’t create disproportionate concern. ■
New use for hospital waste
Turning hospital waste into valuable resources
the goal of Aussie researchers.
W
hat if hospital waste could be broken down and used
in agriculture or water treatment?
That’s the idea Australian researchers are working
to make reality.
A team from Charles Sturt University, James Cook University
and the University of Queensland is exploring ways to transform
waste into something useful.
UQ professor Linda Shields, a former theatre nurse, said hospital
waste should not be ignored.
“Hospitals generate a huge amount of waste, and the focus of
our research is to turn that waste into a resource,” she said.
“The project is working on a new way to treat waste, using a
method of breaking it down to produce a safe, char-like material
which could be used for agriculture or water treatment.”
Associate Professor Michael Oelgemöller, a chemist at JCU, was
looking at ways to covert and treat the waste.
“Hospital waste represents an interesting resource and may be
converted into low to medium-value products such as fertilisers or
adsorbents,” he said. “The goal would be to turn this waste into an
income stream.”
The research team is now seeking additional funding to explore
what’s needed for large-scale waste conversions. ■
nursingreview.com.au | 7